- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes TwinDropGS, a twin dropout-based consistency regularization framework for sparse-view 3D Gaussian Splatting. The method constructs two complementary Gaussian subfields and enforces error-guided low-frequency consistency between their renderings. A progressive scheduling strategy further adjusts dropout and consistency strength during training. Experiments on multiple benchmarks demonstrate consistent improvements in novel-view synthesis quality.
Critical strengths
S1. Clear Motivation. The paper identifies the lack of consistency constraints across different dropout realizations and provides a well-motivated solution.
S2. Simple and Effective Design. The proposed framework is straightforward and does not require additional pretrained models or external geometric priors.
S3. Consistent Performance Improvements. The method achieves consistent improvements across multiple sparse-view benchmarks, including LLFF, Mip-NeRF360, and Blender.
Critical weaknesses
-
Significant Computational Overhead. TwinDropGS approximately doubles the training time compared with DropGaussian (151s vs. 74s, Tab 3). Although TwinDropGS-S reduces this overhead, its reconstruction quality is lower than that of the full model. The quality-efficiency trade-off remains a concern.
-
Limited Comparison with Feed-forward Sparse-view Reconstruction Methods. The experiments focus primarily on optimization-based methods, without comparisons against recent feed-forward sparse-view reconstruction approaches. Including representative feed-forward baselines would provide a more comprehensive understanding of the method's performance and practical trade-offs
Questions for authors
Q1. Geometric Accuracy and Structural Consistency. Does enforcing rendering consistency between Gaussian subfields actually improve the underlying 3D geometry? Could the authors provide quantitative geometric evaluations or additional structural analyses to support this claim?
3 comments
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. The authors have adequately addressed my concerns regarding geometric accuracy, computational overhead, and comparisons with feed-forward methods. The additional results provide sufficient evidence to support the proposed method.
Therefore, I maintain my original rating.
Response to Reviewer 3wcs
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you for confirming that our additional experiments have adequately addressed your concerns. We would like to further emphasize that TwinDropGS goes beyond conventional dropout strategy design by rethinking sparse-view Gaussian optimization from a consistency-centric perspective. Rather than treating stochastic Gaussian subfields as independent training realizations, our framework makes dropout-induced discrepancies explicitly observable and regularizable, establishing a new perspective on dropout-based regularization. Importantly, this simple, prior-free, and plug-and-play design achieves consistent improvements in reconstruction quality, geometric accuracy, and training stability, with additional compute-matched experiments confirming that the gains are not merely due to increased computation. More broadly, we believe this consistency-centric perspective offers a generalizable regularization principle with potential applications beyond sparse-view reconstruction, such as dynamic scene reconstruction and other 3D representation learning tasks.
We sincerely appreciate your valuable suggestions and continued support. Please let us know if you have any remaining questions or suggestions. We would greatly appreciate your consideration of a more favorable score.
Thank you again for your valuable time and consideration.
Best regards,
The Authors
Response to Reviewer 3wcs
We sincerely thank you for recognizing the clear motivation, simplicity, and consistent performance improvements of our method. We also appreciate your constructive comments and suggestions. In response to your concerns, we have conducted additional experiments on geometric accuracy, computational efficiency, and comparisons with feed-forward methods. We provide detailed point-by-point responses below.
1. Geometry Accuracy and Structural Consistency.
TwinDropGS enforces consistency between two complementary subsets of the same Gaussian field, reducing structural instability caused by stochastic dropout. Since inaccurate geometric structures are more sensitive to different subsets, consistency regularization suppresses floating Gaussians, incorrect occlusions, and local geometric noise, thereby improving reconstruction quality. Following the evaluation protocol of Co-Adaptation, we further evaluate depth quality on LLFF 3-view. The results confirm TwinDropGS's effectiveness in improving geometric accuracy and structural consistency.
2. Computational Cost and Efficiency.
Although TwinDropGS introduces additional training overhead compared with DropGaussian, it achieves a favorable quality-efficiency trade-off. Under matched training budgets, TwinDropGS-S (74s, 20.99 dB) outperforms DropGaussian (74s, 20.33 dB), while full TwinDropGS (151s, 21.20 dB) surpasses DropGaussian trained for 20k iterations (157.8s, 20.39 dB). Moreover, as shown below, TwinDropGS achieves superior reconstruction quality with substantially less training time than other competitive methods, including FSGS, CoR-GS, and NexusGS. Compared with the full TwinDropGS, TwinDropGS-S reduces training time by approximately 51% (74s vs. 151s), while maintaining competitive reconstruction quality with only a 0.21 dB decrease in PSNR.
3. Comparison with Feed-Forward Methods.
Following DropGaussian's evaluation protocol, we compare TwinDropGS with representative feed-forward methods on Replica 2-view. TwinDropGS achieves the best PSNR, SSIM, and LPIPS, demonstrating superior reconstruction quality. Although pre-trained feed-forward methods offer faster inference, TwinDropGS achieves superior reconstruction quality under sparse-view inputs. We have added the corresponding discussion and quantitative comparisons in Appendix A of the revised manuscript.