- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper aims to recover causal relations that operate at different temporal scales. It proposes CausalSR, which decomposes time series into frequency bands, combines interaction strength with phase information to orient candidate edges, and applies conditional screening and joint graph refinement. Experiments on synthetic and reference-based temporal datasets report improved structural recovery, with additional analyses of reconstruction quality and sensitivity to the chosen bands and thresholds.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses the difficulty of separating interactions with different temporal responses. The scale-specific graph representation provides an interpretable way to examine relations that may be obscured in the original signals.
- The experiments include band-wise versions of existing methods and ablations of scale partitioning and joint refinement. These comparisons help distinguish the contribution of the proposed framework from that of decomposition alone.
Critical weaknesses
-- The theoretical analysis does not establish when the inferred directions represent direct causal relations. The phase result proves that averaging preserves an ordering already shared by the selected local phases. It does not show that this ordering identifies a causal direction or separates direct effects from responses to a common driver. The authors acknowledge that phase is only directional evidence, but the remaining steps do not close this gap. In particular, screening conditions on simultaneous scale components rather than their relevant histories, so delayed common causes can still produce misleading associations. The connection between the stated assumptions and reliable causal recovery therefore remains insufficiently justified.
-- The joint refinement does not clearly preserve the evidence used to construct the initial graphs. The initial stage selects edges through phase ordering and conditional screening, whereas refinement updates the graph weights using reconstruction and acyclicity. The description does not specify whether rejected edges remain excluded or whether the assigned directions are maintained. Moreover, reconstruction uses contemporaneous combinations of the scale components even though the target relations include delayed effects. Although the ablation demonstrates an average improvement and the authors describe reconstruction as a local consistency criterion, these results do not explain why the updated graphs retain the directional and conditional evidence used to select their candidates.
-- The evaluation does not clearly demonstrate recovery of the correct temporal scale. The synthetic generator provides a separate reference graph for each band, but the reported structural metrics do not specify how scale assignments enter the comparison. It is therefore unclear whether an otherwise correct edge placed in the wrong band is penalized, or how methods producing a single graph are compared with scale-specific outputs. The river visualization is informative, but the displayed distance ranges do not independently establish the temporal scale of each reference relation. This ambiguity limits the evidence for the central claim of recovering scale-resolved structure, beyond improving overall edge recovery.
-- The experimental settings are not sufficiently specified to assess the reported advantage. The synthetic construction describes the general process without giving the frequency boundaries or the distributions of delays and coefficients that determine how easily the components can be separated. The implementation discussion also leaves the actual baseline lag settings and the selection procedure for the default configuration unclear. The existing sensitivity analysis shows that the band partition affects recovery, making these omissions consequential. Without a reproducible account of these choices, it is difficult to determine whether the improvement reflects a broadly useful method or a particularly favorable match between the generated signals and the selected representation.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses.
W1
Thank you for your careful reading. In our structural model, a parent has a direct effect if changing its value changes the target while the target’s other direct causes are held fixed [1]. In Eq. (46), increasing a lagged parent by Δ changes the target by aΔ when the other parents and the disturbance are held fixed.
For an established direct lagged relation, temporal precedence determines its direction [2]. Consider Y(t)=aX(t−ℓ)+U(t), where a>0 and U is independent of the source process X. Under our cross-spectrum convention, the phase difference is wrap(2πfℓ). When 0<fℓ<1/4, its sign indicates that X leads Y. T2 shows that circular aggregation preserves this order when the selected local phases lie in the same admissible quadrant.
CausalSR screens candidate edges using ridge partial correlation conditioned on the contemporaneous band components of the other observed variables (Eqs. (11)–(14)). This screen can remove an association induced by a common driver when the conditioning components capture the relevant driver history. For example, suppose X=f(Zt−a,U) and Y=g(Zt−b,V), where U and V are mutually independent and the pair (U,V) is independent of Z. If each lagged value of Z carries information beyond the other, both belong in the conditioning set. Conditioning on both blocks the common-driver path even when the response delays differ, giving X⊥Y∣(Zt−a,Zt−b).
W2
We appreciate your thoughtful question. Our implementation includes a fixed-support option. For each band k, a binary mask M(k) records the directed edges retained after phase selection and conditional screening. With this option enabled, we impose A(k)=M(k)⊙B(k) throughout optimization. A retained edge can weaken or drop out, but it cannot reverse direction, and a screened-out edge cannot reappear.
With the directions fixed, joint refinement uses information across bands to estimate the edge weights. Let u be the source component of a retained edge and r the current target residual after reconstruction across bands. Changing the edge weight by d gives a squared error of ∥r−du∥2. For nonzero u, the minimizing adjustment is d=u⊤r/(u⊤u), which reduces the reconstruction error whenever u⊤r=0. We plan to study an end-to-end model that jointly learns band boundaries, lagged effects, and graph weights.
W3
Thank you for the opportunity to clarify. On synthetic data, each prediction is a triple (source, target, band). We compute F1 separately against each band’s reference graph and report the unweighted mean of the three scores.
For comparisons with methods that return a single graph, we evaluate all methods against the directed union of the reference graphs. For CausalSR, we likewise take the directed union of its predicted graphs. For example, suppose a true short-band edge is predicted in the correct direction only in the mid band. It counts as a false negative in the short band, a false positive in the mid band, and a true positive in the union.
The CausalRivers reference graph records directed connectivity between stations. At comparable propagation speeds, a longer river path implies a longer travel time. We therefore use along-river distance as a proxy for response time to interpret which station pairs appear in each band. We evaluate scale assignment on the synthetic benchmark, which provides a band label for each reference edge.
W4
Thank you for this suggestion. We choose the analysis bands based on the sampling interval and the expected response times in the system. In the matched synthetic setting, we align the analysis bands with the data-generating bands so that each scale has a unique reference graph. This lets us test whether CausalSR recovers the correct parents and edge directions at each scale. Fig. 7 examines sensitivity to this alignment by holding the analysis bands fixed and varying the data-generating band boundaries.
One limitation of CausalSR is that the response bands must be specified in advance. We plan to investigate how to learn their boundaries from data. Upon acceptance, we will release the exact frequency ranges, the sampling distributions for delays and coefficients, the lag windows used by the baselines, the tuning protocol, the random seeds, and the run commands alongside the code.
References
[1] Pearl, J. Causality: Models, Reasoning, and Inference. 2nd ed., Cambridge University Press, 2009.
[2] Granger, C. W. J. Testing for causality: A personal viewpoint. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control 2, 329–352, 1980.