acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Plan Once, Predict All: Latent Planning for Non-Autoregressive User Behavior Forecasting

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Modeling future user behavior trajectories is crucial for capturing evolving preferences and enabling proactive recommendations. However, most sequential recommenders either focus on next-item prediction or extend to multi-step forecasting via autoregressive rollout, which often incurs error accumulation and high inference cost. To alleviate these problems, we propose LapTop, a latent planning framework for user behavior trajectory prediction that generates multi-step actions through parallel trajectory decoding without autoregressive rollout. LapTop introduces a compact set of latent plan tokens that operate in the hidden space to encode long-term intent and global preference structure, together with learnable future query slots that decode all future steps simultaneously. To capture the inherent uncertainty of user behaviors, LapTop adopts a variational learning scheme that aligns a history-conditioned prior with a future-aware posterior during training, while using only the prior at inference time. This design enables diverse and coherent trajectory generation without iterative decoding. Experiments on real-world benchmarks demonstrate that LapTop consistently outperforms state-of-the-art baselines in multi-step accuracy and trajectory quality, while also reducing inference latency.

Primary area:
generative models
Keywords:
User Behavior Trajectory Prediction, Sequential Recommendation, Latent Planning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_Dem9OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes LapTop, a latent‑planning framework. Drawing on variational auto‑encoder (VAE) ideas, it designs a latent‑planning variable z. During training, the posterior distribution which incorporates future information is leveraged to learn high‑level user intents, which are then distilled into a history‑only prior distribution. It introduces plan tokens and future query slots to output the complete H‑step future trajectory via a single parallel decoding pass, without autoregressive roll‑out or multi‑step denoising iterations required by diffusion models.

Critical strengths

S1. LapTop leverages plan tokens together with learnable future query slots to produce all H future steps within one single forward pass. It adopts VAE prior‑posterior alignment to model the multi‑modal uncertainty of future user behaviors.

S2. The latent variable z captures high‑level user future intents instead of merely modeling single‑step item preferences. Extensive ablation studies verify the necessity of plan tokens, the VAE latent variable, and the KL‑loss weight.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Model performance is highly sensitive to the KL regularization weight β. Setting β=0 degrades the model into a deterministic predictor with substantial performance drops; an excessively large β over‑regularizes and compresses the expressive power of the latent space. The optimal β requires fine‑grained grid‑search on the validation set. Optimal values are similar but not identical across different datasets, raising practical tuning overhead. The paper does not propose an adaptive KL weighting scheme to mitigate this sensitivity.

W2. The reported Oracle Gain represents a theoretical upper bound obtained by picking the best item from sampled candidate sets, which is infeasible for real‑world online systems where ground‑truth oracle labels are unavailable. Although the model can generate highly diverse trajectories via sampling, the real‑world effectiveness of raw sampled outputs for recommendation ranking is not evaluated. The correlation between diversity metrics (Self‑BLEU, Jaccard distance) and practical business metrics is insufficiently justified. It also remains to be verified whether improved diversity comes at the cost of single‑step recommendation accuracy.

Questions for authors

Q1. All experiments in this work rely purely on item‑ID sequences. Real‑world recommender systems commonly have rich side‑information such as user profiles, item attributes and temporal signals. How can the LapTop framework accommodate these kinds of side‑information? Can they be simply embedded into the input embedding layer, or do modifications to the plan‑token / latent‑variable modules become necessary?

Q2. Since model performance is highly sensitive to the KL regularization weight β, have you considered adaptive KL‑weighting strategies to reduce hyperparameter‑tuning burden and improve cross‑dataset robustness?

Q3. The Oracle Gain demonstrates large theoretical benefits brought by sampling, yet the oracle setting is an ideal upper‑bound that requires ground‑truth labels and cannot be deployed online. If multiple trajectories sampled from LapTop are directly adopted for re‑ranking, what practical impact would sampling diversity exert on online Precision / Recall?

Reviewer_ALQuOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies user behavior trajectory prediction, where a model predicts the next H interactions from a user's history. LapTop augments a SASRec-style Transformer with learnable plan tokens and horizon-specific future query tokens. A conditional variational latent variable is inferred from history and future during training, and a history-conditioned prior supplies the latent plan at inference. The plan is injected into the plan tokens, and all future query outputs are computed in a single trajectory decoding pass without feeding back predicted items. Deterministic inference uses the prior mean and requires a history-prior encoding pass followed by the decoding pass. Experiments compare sequential and diffusion-based baselines on Beauty, MovieLens-1M, and LastFM, with additional MovieLens-10M/20M experiments. The reported results show improved ranking and trajectory-matching metrics, with inference time close to SASRec. Architectural ablations, sampling diagnostics, attention-mask comparisons, and limited-history evaluations further examine the design.

Critical strengths

1. A useful empirical trade-off between trajectory prediction quality and inference cost. Table 1 compares against both sequential models and several diffusion-based methods, including LPDO. Table 5 reports measured V100 inference times: on MovieLens-1M with H=10, LapTop takes 3.26 seconds versus 3.29 for SASRec and 12.26 for LPDO, while SeqMatch@50 improves to 0.0591 from 0.0299 and 0.0449, respectively. Appendices K and L explicitly account for the prior encoding and trajectory decoding stages. The large-scale results in Table 7 further support usefulness beyond the main benchmark sizes.

2. The architectural evaluation includes several meaningful alternatives. Table 2 evaluates parallel queries alone, added plan tokens, direct latent injection into future tokens, deterministic planning, and a CVAE without plan tokens. On MovieLens-1M with H=10, the full model improves SeqMatch@50 from 5.21% for parallel queries alone to 5.98%. These controls provide evidence for the combined design beyond a comparison against autoregressive rollout. Appendix H also explains how next-item baselines are adapted, and Appendix Q examines alternative attention masks. These are substantive strengths of the evaluation.

Critical weaknesses

1. The described training objective and the key controls do not isolate the claimed latent-planning mechanism. Equation (18) and Algorithm 1 specify standard Gaussian KL regularization, while Appendix P says that the full model uses free bits to keep the latent active and that standard KL produces almost deterministic samples. The threshold, exact objective, and use of free bits in Tables 1–2 and 8 are unspecified. This is material because the reported sampling advantage depends on that intervention. Section 5.4 further calls beta=0 a deterministic parallel predictor. Under Equations (10)–(18), however, posterior sampling remains present when beta is zero, and the separate prior MLP loses its KL supervision. Poor prior-only inference in that condition would not isolate the benefit of stochastic planning. Likewise, Figure 8's r=0 control removes all plan tokens. Equation (14) routes z exclusively through those tokens, so removing them disconnects z from the predictor by construction. Zero sample diversity in this control cannot establish that plan-token mediation is necessary compared with another latent interface. Table 2's direct-injection variants are useful controls, but their stochastic quality and latent-utilization results are not reported alongside Figure 8. The evidence therefore does not cleanly separate plan-token design, prior training, and collapse prevention.

2. The full-model reference differs between the main and ablation tables without a documented setting difference. For MovieLens-1M at H=10, Table 1 gives SeqHR@10=0.1625 and SeqNDCG@10=0.0693, while the Full row of Table 2 gives 16.85% and 7.07%, or 0.1685 and 0.0707. For LastFM at H=10, Table 1 gives SeqHR@10=0.2489 and SeqMatch@50=0.0900, while Table 2 gives 26.16% and 10.35%, or 0.2616 and 0.1035. Percentage scaling does not reconcile the values. Different seeds or configurations could explain them, but Section 5.4 and the captions do not identify such a difference. Because component effects are assessed against this Full reference, the ablation cannot be linked unambiguously to the main model until the authors specify the data, objective, checkpoints, and seed aggregation behind both tables. This is a concrete reporting inconsistency requiring reconciliation; it does not establish which table is incorrect.

Questions for authors
  1. Objective and controls: Which experiments use free bits, and what are its exact threshold, aggregation, and formula? What operations change at beta=0? Please compare latent-conditioning interfaces under the same collapse-prevention and prior-training protocol, and report prior-only versus posterior-conditioned diagnostics and latent utilization. For the Figure 8 r=0 control, is there any remaining path from z to the predictor?

  2. Reconcile numerical reports: Please explain the Full-model differences between Tables 1 and 2 under the same dataset/H labels. Table 8 correctly reports a 58.6% increase from 0.2566 to 0.4070, while its discussion says 70.4%; please correct the arithmetic. Table 3's LastFM actions divided by sequence count give approximately 1,451.29, while Average Lens is 1,254.49; please identify the population and counting convention for each statistic.

  3. What do the probability and sampling metrics establish? Equation (40) is mean per-position NLL, while the text also calls it perplexity. Please specify the implemented quantity and the probabilities used for diffusion models. Is LapTop evaluated at the prior mean or with a latent-marginal estimate? Table 8 reports deterministic and oracle Hit but not mean sampled quality. Please give average sampled Hit/SeqMatch and uncertainty at matched sample budgets. The acknowledged oracle limitation and low overlap among samples do not by themselves establish plausible multimodal futures.

  4. Comparison and data scope: The LPDO/DCRec comparisons and Table 2 controls are substantive. A further relevant trajectory model is GCB; please discuss feasibility of a matched comparison. Appendix F retains 1,927 of 22,363 Beauty sequences and 784 LastFM sequences at H=10. How sensitive are conclusions to this filtering, and what are the paired five-run differences against the strongest baselines? These questions concern the scope and precision of the evidence, not an inference that a small dataset count proves accidental gains.

  5. Implementation and timing: Please provide the configurations and evaluation scripts for the main and ablation tables, preferably as anonymous code during review. For Table 5, specify the timed workload, batch size, warm-up, diffusion steps, and inclusion of both LapTop passes. Appendix K already accounts for the two passes theoretically; the remaining request concerns the measurement protocol.

Reviewer_KNwaOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes LapTop, a latent planning framework for user behavior trajectory prediction. It aims to avoid error accumulation and high inference costs in autoregressive rollout and diffusion-based generation. The method combines parallel future query slots with latent plan tokens, and uses a variational learning scheme to align a future-aware posterior with a history-conditioned prior. Experiments on three real-world datasets show that LapTop improves multi-step prediction accuracy and trajectory quality while reducing inference latency.

Critical strengths
  1. The parallel future query design enables multi-step prediction without autoregressive rollout or iterative denoising, reducing inference costs and avoiding error accumulation from predicted items.
  2. The experiments cover three real-world datasets and compare LapTop with sequential recommendation and diffusion-based methods, showing improvements in prediction performance and inference efficiency.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty and unclear motivation for latent planning. The proposed method appears to be a standard CVAE with an additional mechanism for injecting the latent variable (z) into the decoder through learnable plan tokens. The latent variable (z) is learned through standard reconstruction and KL objectives, without any explicit planning supervision. However, the paper does not clearly explain why such a latent representation should be considered a "plan" or why it needs to be injected through plan tokens rather than used as a normal conditioning signal in the decoder. Although the ablation study shows some performance improvements, the motivation and novelty of this so-called latent planning mechanism remain unclear.
  2. Insufficient experimental validation of the proposed mechanism. If the main innovation is to inject the latent variable into the decoder through plan tokens, the same mechanism could also be applied to autoregressive and diffusion-based models. However, the paper only compares LapTop with these methods without introducing the same mechanism into their architectures. Although Table 2 provides ablation studies within LapTop, it remains unclear whether the performance improvements come from the CVAE framework itself or the proposed plan token mechanism. Therefore, comparisons with autoregressive and diffusion-based models equipped with the same mechanism are needed to better demonstrate its effectiveness.
Questions for authors
  1. Why should the latent variable (z) learned by CVAE be considered a plan rather than a general latent representation?
  2. Can the authors apply the proposed plan token mechanism to autoregressive and diffusion-based models to clarify whether the improvements come from the CVAE framework or the proposed mechanism?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.