- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a closed-loop, physics-informed agent framework for long-horizon physical visual generation. The authors employ reinforcement learning to train VisionCreator-P1, aiming to address the severe problem of Global Causal Drift. They decompose the optimization process into short sub-blocks to improve credit assignment during training. Additionally, they introduce two datasets for this task.
Critical strengths
- Provides datasets for future research.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper overstates its novelty, and I found few new insights in it. Using an agent to generate physical processes is a common idea, yet the paper introduces numerous elaborate terms to describe it. “Global Causal Drift,” for example, is essentially accumulated error, which is not new. I do not think the work offers substantially new ideas to the community. Moreover, this approach merely shifts the challenges of video generation to the agent rather than resolving them, placing the burden on the VLM without guaranteeing reliability.
- In the figure, the text isn't aligned, and the boxes aren't aligned either. The fonts also change. I think it needs more polishment.
Questions for authors
- How reliable is the VLM-based transition verifier? Although the paper includes held-out and human evaluations, it does not directly quantify the verifier’s false acceptance rate on physically invalid transitions.
- Table 2 does not include a comparison with the latest Seedance, H3, and Kling models. As such SOTA video models have temporal attention, I think they will better simulate the physical process.
- Could a recent VLM, such as GPT-5.6, outperform the RL-trained Qwen-VL model in a zero-shot setting?