- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes PARAD, a modular framework that reframes physical reconstruction as active disentanglement: interventions control which physical differences are expressed, sensing controls which remain measurable, and intervention–sensing pairs are selected to distinguish task-relevant physical alternatives under a limited acquisition budget, with interchangeable models and existing inverse solvers. The authors conduct fairly extensive experiments across thermal, vibration, and wave-scattering systems, demonstrating improved reconstruction and held-out prediction.
Critical strengths
-
The distinction between improving an estimate on fixed data and acquiring evidence that rules out alternative physical explanations is useful and clearly developed. Separating physical response generation from observation formation provides an intuitive way to understand why different physical systems can remain consistent with the same measurements.
-
The framework is demonstrated with different reconstruction components and physical systems, including an existing VVT inverse core and a frozen diffusion prior. The same-core replay, unchanged-history controls, and known-observation controls help separate some of the effects of acquisition, inference, and calibration. The combination of generated thermal data, public vibration simulations, real vibration video, and scattering experiments also gives the study useful breadth.
Critical weaknesses
-
The benefit of feedback over a strong fixed design remains uncertain. The thermal comparison includes only four objects and one adaptive decision per object, while the larger scattering confirmation uses fixed acquisition. More detailed per-object results and planning costs would help establish the practical value of feedback.
-
The reliability of the approximate acquisition scores is unclear. The planner relies on local linearization and an approximate joint covariance, but the paper does not establish how sensitive candidate rankings and acquisition choices are to these approximations.
Questions for authors
-
For the thermal confirmation, could you report the per-object differences between feedback and the universal fixed design on the policy-unused new-task metric in Table 1, alongside the additional planning time? Appendix C.2 already provides per-object target-error reductions, but these do not directly establish how the new-task improvement is distributed across objects. Please also distinguish offline fixed-design selection costs from per-object online planning costs.
-
How sensitive are the selected experiments to the local linearization and covariance approximation used by the planner? For example, whether a higher-fidelity estimate changes the candidate ranking or selected protocol—would help establish when the approximate utility is reliable. Can the authors relate this sensitivity to cases where feedback helps and cases where it does not?
Urge for reply
Dear reviewers and ACs:
I hope this message finds you well, as the discussion period is near its end with less than 1 day, I want to ensure we have addressed your concerns satisfactorily. If there are any additional concerns, please let us know. We really appreciate your advice and comments.
Thank you again for your time and efforts.