- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a Relation Conflict Estimation framework for generalizable face forgery detection. The main idea is to model the discrepancy between facial patch representations and their context-induced relation responses, together with pairwise relation-conflict separation and cross-frame distribution regularization. However, the experimental comparison is not sufficiently up to date for an ICLR 2027 submission. In particular, the main cross-dataset evaluation compares only against methods published up to 2025. The cross-operation evaluations only include a TIFS2026 baseline, which is actually work from one or two years ago based on the publication speed of the journal. As a result, the paper does not convincingly establish the effectiveness of the proposed method against the current state of the art. Furthermore, the paper lacks theoretical justification or direct empirical comparisons to prove that the claimed 'relation conflict' captures anything fundamentally different from ordinary patch-level feature discrepancy, which has already been extensively explored in prior works.
Critical strengths
1.The paper addresses the important problem of generalizable face forgery detection under unseen datasets, manipulation methods, and generation mechanisms.
2.The idea of using contextual discrepancies between facial patches and their surrounding regions is intuitive and potentially complementary to local appearance artifacts.
Critical weaknesses
1.The main experimental comparisons use outdated and incomplete baselines. In Table 1, the cross-dataset evaluation does not include any method published after 2025. In Table 2, the cross-manipulation evaluation includes only one TIFS2026 baseline, MAP-Mamba, while most other baselines are from 2024 or earlier.
2.The core novelty of Relation Conflict Estimation is not sufficiently distinguished from existing contextual and token-level modeling methods. The proposed framework combines a 3×3 local neighborhood, the class token, cross-attention, cosine discrepancy, a margin-based separation loss, and entropy regularization. These components are relatively standard individually.
3.The paper repeatedly states that the method operates “without extra inference-time computation.” However, the relation estimation and relation-aware prediction pathways are still retained during inference. Table 6 in the appendix also shows increases in both the number of parameters and FLOPs.
Questions for authors
1Why does the paper not compare against more recent baselines?
2The pape fundamentally relies on computing cosine similarity and applying a separation loss to measure differences. Both of these are common solutions. What is the strict theoretical or direct empirical distinction between the claimed "relation conflict" and the already well-explored "patch discrepancy"?