acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Multi-Hop Knowledge Editing via Intermediate-Entity Representation Alignment

Abstract

Even when a single-hop edit succeeds, related multi-hop predictions may remain unchanged. We investigate whether access to the updated intermediate-entity representation can help the edited knowledge participate in downstream computation. Through layer-wise hidden-state interventions, we find that introducing the desired-object representation at the subject position can increase the target probability and redirect the final predictive state toward direct next-hop recall. This intervention identifies intermediate-entity reuse as an intervention-sensitive representational factor associated with multi-hop propagation. Based on this observation, we propose Intermediate-Entity Representation Editing (IERE), which converts the temporary intervention into persistent parameter updates. IERE schedules interacting edits from downstream to upstream, recursively re-extracts the latest desired-object representations, aligns subject representations accordingly, and finally applies batched factual editing. It uses only single-hop edit requests and requires no edit-specific multi-hop questions, next-hop relations, reasoning paths, or target answers. Experiments on Llama-3-8B-Instruct and GPT-J-6B show that IERE preserves strong direct editing, achieves the highest forward multi-hop accuracy among single-hop-only methods in all six settings, and remains competitive with methods that use auxiliary multi-hop information. Relation-specific evaluation further shows subject-level locality comparable to MEMIT.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Knowledge Editing, Multi-hop Knowledge Editing

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 30%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.67 over 3 reviews, above 70% of the others.
Reviewer_fAsvOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies a failure in knowledge editing: a direct factual edit may succeed without changing answers to questions that depend on it. A layer-wise intervention places the desired object’s representation at the subject position and increases support for the downstream answer. Motivated by this result, the authors propose IERE. It aligns subject representations with desired-object representations through parameter updates, processes dependent edits from downstream to upstream, and finishes with batched factual editing. The method uses only single-hop edit requests. On MQuAKE, IERE achieves the highest forward multi-hop accuracy among the tested single-hop-only editors in all six model–hop settings. The paper also reports method ablations, subject-level locality on RippleEdits, and broader capability results on CSQA and MMLU.

Critical strengths
  1. Strong multi-hop gains using only single-hop edit requests. On Llama-3-8B-Instruct, IERE reaches 39.76%, 34.37%, and 21.41% accuracy from two to four hops, substantially outperforming the tested single-hop editors under the same information constraint. This is important because IERE does not require edit-specific multi-hop questions, reasoning paths, next-hop relations, or target answers.
  2. The method is tied to a concrete internal representation hypothesis. The layer-wise intervention shows that placing the desired-object representation at the subject position can move the prediction toward direct next-hop recall. This gives IERE a specific representational target instead of treating multi-hop improvement as a purely behavioral objective. The evidence does not fully establish the mechanism in the final edited model, but the connection between the intervention and the editing rule makes the method easier to interpret and analyze.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The representation mechanism is not verified in the final edited model. Section 4 inserts the desired-object representation into the unedited model and improves the downstream prediction. IERE then approximates that intervention with a parameter update (eq. 6), followed by a factual edit to overlapping parameters (eq. 7). Table 2 shows the behavioral effects, but does not establish whether the final model develops the intended subject-to-object representation shift or whether that shift drives the multi-hop gains. This limits the mechanistic claim, though the performance results stand. Evidence of the shift in the final model and its contribution to the gain would support the proposed explanation.
  2. The cross-model difference is not well explained. IERE brings large multi-hop gains on Llama-3, while the improvements on GPT-J are much smaller in several settings. Since the same editing framework is applied to both models, this gap suggests that the effectiveness of representation alignment may depend on model-specific properties. The paper reports the difference but offers little analysis of why it occurs. A brief analysis of the intervention behavior or representation alignment across the two models would help clarify when IERE is likely to work well and would make the cross-model claim easier to interpret.
Questions for authors
  1. After both stages of IERE, does an unpatched multi-hop input produce the intended subject-to-object representation shift? Is that signature associated with the cases IERE solves beyond factual editing alone?
  2. What do the intervention results and the failure analysis suggest about the Llama and GPT-J’s gap? Is GPT-J failing to establish the alignment, losing it during factual editing, or showing a different limitation?
  3. The NoSched ablation processes all edits in one round. Which part of the current evidence identifies the downstream-to-upstream order itself as the source of the longer-hop gain, apart from using multiple rounds and refreshed representations?
1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer fAsv

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback.

Q1. Representation Shift and Prediction Improvements

IERE induces the intended representation shift during normal inference, and its alignment updates contribute to multi-hop predictions where MEMIT fails but IERE succeeds.

Representation Shift. We measured subject–desired-object cosine similarity across editing stages without activation patching (Table 1). Similarity increases substantially after representation alignment but partially decreases after factual editing, demonstrating that the intended representation shift can arise through parameter editing.

Contribution to Multi-Hop Predictions. For cases where MEMIT fails but IERE succeeds, we removed the representation-alignment parameter updates while keeping the factual-editing update fixed. The resulting answer change rates (Table 1) show that many previously correct predictions become incorrect, indicating that these updates contribute to IERE's additional multi-hop successes.

Table 1. Stage-wise cosine similarity and answer change rate after removing representation-alignment updates.

ModelHopsOriginalAfter alignmentFinal IEREAnswer change rate (%)
Llama-3-8B-Instruct20.51570.97160.925699.05
30.52740.95860.875095.37
40.50880.95930.876777.94
GPT-J-6B20.88820.99990.951498.10
30.93080.99970.924371.43
40.90600.99980.746448.65

Q2. Cross-Model Performance Gap

GPT-J-6B can establish and benefit from intermediate-entity representation alignment, but subsequent factual editing may weaken this alignment, contributing to its smaller multi-hop gains.

Intervention and Failure Analysis. The original intervention results demonstrate the benefit of intermediate-entity representations, while Appendix A.4 shows that GPT-J-6B has higher proportions of Partial propagation and Negative/ineffective update among failed cases, suggesting additional propagation limitations.

Investigating the Performance Gap. Activation patching after MEMIT yields comparable performance across both models and substantially improves GPT-J-6B over IERE (Table 2), indicating that GPT-J-6B can utilize intermediate-entity information.

Stage-wise cosine similarity (Table 1) shows that both models establish high representation similarity after alignment, but factual editing partially weakens it, particularly on GPT-J-6B at 4 hops. This suggests that incomplete preservation of representation alignment may contribute to the performance gap.

Table 2. Multi-hop generation accuracy with intermediate-entity activation patching after MEMIT.

ModelMethod2-hop3-hop4-hop
Llama-3-8B-InstructMEMIT + patch53.8626.6116.61
IERE39.7634.3721.41
GPT-J-6BMEMIT + patch52.7922.6220.45
IERE25.408.209.90

Q3. Contribution of Dependency Order

Downstream-to-upstream scheduling enables upstream edits to use updated desired-object representations, contributing to longer-hop propagation.

Dependency-Aware Scheduling. As explained in Section 5.1, downstream edits update the representations required as alignment targets by upstream edits. Therefore, processing downstream edits first ensures that upstream alignment uses the updated desired-object representations.

Additional Experiment. Since NoSched does not isolate dependency direction, we introduced a reverse-order IERE variant while preserving multi-round alignment and representation refreshing (Table 3). Reversing the order reduces multi-hop accuracy in all six settings, confirming the contribution of downstream-to-upstream scheduling.

Table 3. Multi-hop generation accuracy under default and reversed dependency orders.

ModelHopsIERE D→UIERE U→DMEMIT
Llama-3-8B-Instruct239.7626.998.51
334.376.875.10
421.4110.227.35
GPT-J-6B225.4016.7617.69
38.206.435.54
49.900.968.95
Reviewer_WcziOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the failure of successful single-hop knowledge edits to propagate to related multi-hop predictions. Through layer-wise hidden-state interventions, the authors inject the desired-object representation into the subject positions of a multi-hop input. They observe a reduction in target-answer negative log-likelihood and a shift of the final predictive state toward that induced by direct next-hop recall.

Motivated by this observation, the authors propose Intermediate-Entity Representation Editing (IERE). The method constructs dependencies from subject-object matches within an edit batch, processes edits from downstream to upstream, re-extracts updated object representations, and updates MLP parameters to align subject representations with these targets. It then applies MEMIT for batched factual editing. IERE uses only single-hop edit requests, without edit-specific multi-hop questions, next-hop relations, reasoning paths, or target answers. Experiments on Llama-3-8B-Instruct and GPT-J-6B report improved multi-hop propagation on MQuAKE, alongside component ablations, subject-level locality evaluation on RippleEdits, and global capability evaluations.

Critical strengths
  1. The setting is practically meaningful, and the method improves propagation without edit-specific multi-hop information. In Table 1, IERE achieves the highest multi-hop accuracy among methods receiving only single-hop edit requests across all six model-hop settings. For example, its 2-hop accuracy on Llama-3-8B-Instruct is 39.76%, compared with 8.51% for MEMIT and 8.64% for AlphaEdit. These results demonstrate practical value.

  2. Table 2 shows that removing dependency-aware scheduling harms multi-hop propagation, while removing the final factual editing stage reduces direct-edit success. Reversing the two stages also changes the balance between direct editing and propagation. These experiments help explain why the complete procedure is effective.

Critical weaknesses
  1. IERE largely relies on existing editing machinery, including MEMIT-style parameter updates and factual editing, while introducing desired-object representation alignment and dependency-aware scheduling. Prior work has already explored mechanistically motivated multi-hop editing: IFMET (ICML 2025) edits shallow and deep MLP layers using single-hop and multi-hop editing prompts, while CaKE (EMNLP 2025) uses reasoning-circuit analysis to guide editing with curated samples. IERE differs in aligning desired-object representations using only single-hop edit requests and recursively refreshing these targets through dependency-aware scheduling. Although these distinctions are meaningful and the proposed combination is effective, the paper does not sufficiently establish the extent of its methodological advance over the closest approaches.

  2. Section 4 shows that injecting intermediate-entity representations improves downstream predictions, particularly at earlier layers. However, Hopping Too Late (EMNLP 2024) has already studied bridge-entity computation and shown that patching later-layer representations back into earlier layers can improve multi-hop predictions. This differs from IERE's intervention, which inserts a separately extracted desired-object representation at subject positions. Moreover, Section 4 and Appendix A.1 perform their interventions on the original model. Although Table 2 provides behavioral ablations supporting the method design, it does not directly verify whether the final parameter-edited model achieves its gains through the same representation-level mechanism. This leaves a minor, fixable gap in the mechanistic evidence, rather than establishing that the reported performance gains are unsound. Consequently, the experiments provide useful motivation, but I find their additional mechanistic insight limited.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the principal technical advance in combining the desired-object alignment target, the MEMIT-style update, and dependency-aware scheduling? In particular, what new editing principle or capability makes this combination a substantial methodological contribution? A precise comparison with the closest existing approaches would help distinguish the originality of the method from its empirical effectiveness.

  2. What new insight about knowledge-edit propagation follows from Section 4 beyond the observation that providing the desired intermediate-entity representation can improve downstream recall? Please clarify which finding substantially advances our understanding relative to existing representation-intervention approaches.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Wczi

We thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical relevance of our setting and the experimental improvements. We clarify the methodological contributions and the additional insights from Section 4 below.

Q1. Methodological Contributions

IERE's main contribution is the coordination of a propagation-oriented representation-editing objective with dependency-aware target refreshing, enabling multi-hop propagation using only single-hop edit requests.

Comparison with Existing Methods. MEMIT primarily establishes direct factual associations, while IFMET constructs additional multi-hop editing prompts and CaKE uses circuit-guided training examples. In contrast, IERE constructs its propagation target directly from the desired-object representation without edit-specific multi-hop supervision.

Coordinated Editing Principle. IERE aligns subject representations with desired-object representations through MEMIT-style parameter updates. Since downstream edits can change the representations required by upstream alignment, IERE processes dependent edits from downstream to upstream and re-extracts updated alignment targets. Thus, the methodological advance lies in coordinating propagation-oriented representation alignment with dynamic target refreshing, rather than in the parameter-update solver or scheduling alone.

Q2. Mechanistic Insights and Validation

Section 4 identifies an independently constructible representation target for multi-hop propagation, extending representation intervention into a practical parameter-editing objective.

Mechanistic Insight. Hopping Too Late back-patches representations derived from the same multi-hop input. In contrast, our intervention uses desired-object representations constructed solely from single-hop edit requests. Beyond reducing target NLL, it shifts the final predictive state toward direct next-hop recall, identifying a propagation-oriented editing target without edit-specific multi-hop supervision.

Additional Evidence. To address the related concern about whether this mechanism operates after parameter editing, we conducted further analyses (Table 1). Stage-wise cosine similarity confirms that representation alignment induces the intended shift during normal inference, although factual editing partially weakens it. Moreover, removing the representation-alignment parameter updates causes many cases solved by IERE but not MEMIT to become incorrect, demonstrating their contribution to multi-hop improvements.

Table 1. Stage-wise cosine similarity and answer change rate after removing representation-alignment updates.

ModelHopsOriginalAfter alignmentFinal IEREAnswer change rate (%)
Llama-3-8B-Instruct20.51570.97160.925699.05
30.52740.95860.875095.37
40.50880.95930.876777.94
GPT-J-6B20.88820.99990.951498.10
30.93080.99970.924371.43
40.90600.99980.746448.65

Thanks for the clarification. My concerns over such combinational work, with no clear introduction of new editing principle or capability, are not resolved. No instinct insights could be deduced from the presentation. I choose to maintain my score.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comment by Authors

We thank the reviewer for the follow-up. We would like to further clarify the findings of Section 4 and the methodological contribution of IERE.

1. HTL relies on multi-hop-query-dependent hidden states. HTL back-patches higher-layer states extracted from the same multi-hop question. These states contain information conditioned on the specific question, including its next-hop relation, and therefore cannot be directly constructed when only single-hop edit requests are available.

2. Section 4 identifies a multi-hop-independent representation target. Unlike HTL, we construct intermediate-entity representations solely from the desired object, without using multi-hop questions, next-hop relations, or target answers. Injecting these representations reduces target NLL and shifts the final predictive state toward direct next-hop recall. This demonstrates that independently constructed entity representations can guide downstream computation without multi-hop information.

3. IERE converts this finding into a parameter-editing objective. By aligning subject representations with desired-object representations, IERE enables knowledge propagation using only single-hop edit requests. Unlike IFMET and CaKE, which rely on auxiliary multi-hop information, IERE requires no edit-specific multi-hop questions, reasoning paths, or answers.

Thus, IERE's contribution is not merely a combination of existing techniques, but a multi-hop-independent representation-alignment objective that enables edited knowledge to be reused in downstream reasoning.

Reviewer_hjCPOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes Intermediate-Entity Representation Editing (IERE) to improve multi-hop knowledge propagation after factual editing in LLMs. The authors first use hidden-state interventions to show that injecting the representation of an updated intermediate entity can improve downstream predictions. Based on this observation, IERE combines representation alignment, dependency-aware edit scheduling, and MEMIT-based factual editing. The method requires only single-hop edit requests without additional multi-hop questions or reasoning paths. Experiments on Llama-3-8B-Instruct and GPT-J-6B show improvements in multi-hop accuracy over conventional single-hop editing methods, while maintaining high direct editing success rates.

Critical strengths

The paper addresses an important limitation of existing knowledge editing methods. Successful single-hop editing does not necessarily lead to correct predictions on related multi-hop questions. The proposed approach attempts to address this problem through intermediate-entity representations rather than relying on additional multi-hop supervision.

The experimental results are encouraging, particularly on Llama-3-8B-Instruct. The improvements over MEMIT and AlphaEdit are substantial, and the ablation experiments provide evidence for the contribution of dependency-aware scheduling. The combination of representation interventions and parameter editing is also interesting.

Critical weaknesses

The strongest results are obtained on Llama-3-8B-Instruct, while the improvements on GPT-J-6B are much smaller. For example, IERE achieves 25.40% accuracy on 2-hop questions with GPT-J, compared with 25.00% for AlphaEdit and 30.45% for IFMET. On 3-hop and 4-hop questions, accuracy remains below 10%. The evaluation covers only two relatively small models, leaving the generality of the approach uncertain.

Appendix A.5 shows that IERE causes larger performance drops on MMLU and CSQA than several baselines. On Llama-3-8B-Instruct, MMLU decreases by 3.16–4.45 percentage points, while GPT-J-6B shows even larger degradation. This raises concerns about whether the improvement in multi-hop propagation comes at the cost of disrupting unrelated knowledge. The subject-level locality results do not fully capture these broader effects.

The hidden-state interventions show that injecting an intermediate-entity representation can increase the probability of the target answer. However, this does not establish that the model is actually reusing the updated intermediate entity during multi-hop reasoning. The intervention may directly alter downstream representations without restoring the intended reasoning process. The large performance drop when dependency-aware scheduling is removed also makes it difficult to separate the effects of representation alignment from those of edit ordering.

Questions for authors

1.Does IERE generalize to larger or more recent LLMs? The performance gap between Llama-3-8B-Instruct and GPT-J-6B is substantial, particularly for longer reasoning chains.

2.What causes the larger MMLU and CSQA degradation compared with MEMIT and ACE? Can the authors characterize which capabilities or knowledge types are most affected by representation alignment?

3.Can the authors provide stronger evidence that IERE improves the reuse of intermediate entities rather than directly steering hidden states toward the expected answer? The current activation patching experiments do not clearly distinguish these possibilities.

4.How does IERE compare with a dependency-aware version of MEMIT that uses the same edit ordering but does not perform intermediate-entity representation alignment? The current NoSched ablation does not isolate the contribution of scheduling relative to a simpler baseline.

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer hjCP

We thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback.

Q1. Generalization and Performance Gap

IERE improves single-hop editing and multi-hop propagation on Qwen2.5-14B; factual editing may weaken alignment on GPT-J-6B.

Generality. Due to the limited rebuttal period, we evaluated IERE against MEMIT on Qwen2.5-14B (Table 1). IERE improves both SNll. and MAcc. across all hop lengths. The additional single-hop gains warrant further investigation.

Performance Gap. Activation patching after MEMIT yields comparable 2-hop accuracy on both models and substantially outperforms IERE on GPT-J-6B (Table 2), indicating that GPT-J-6B can utilize intermediate-entity representations.

Stage-wise cosine similarity (Table 3) shows that both models establish strong alignment, but factual editing subsequently weakens it, particularly on GPT-J-6B at 4 hops. This suggests that incomplete preservation of alignment may contribute to the performance gap.

Table 1. Qwen2.5-14B editing results (%).

Method2-hop SNll.2-hop MAcc.3-hop SNll.3-hop MAcc.4-hop SNll.4-hop MAcc.
MEMIT95.484.9286.330.0093.931.92
IERE99.8712.9099.262.0099.442.88

Table 2. Multi-hop accuracy with representation patching after MEMIT.

ModelMethod2-hop3-hop4-hop
Llama-3-8B-InstructMEMIT + patch53.8626.6116.61
IERE39.7634.3721.41
GPT-J-6BMEMIT + patch52.7922.6220.45
IERE25.408.209.90

Table 3. Subject–desired-object cosine similarity.

ModelHopsOriginalAfter representation alignmentFinal IERE
Llama-3-8B-Instruct20.51570.97160.9256
30.52740.95860.8750
40.50880.95930.8767
GPT-J-6B20.88820.99990.9514
30.93080.99970.9243
40.90600.99980.7464

Q2. Global Capability Degradation

Representation-alignment updates contribute to global capability degradation, with domain-specific effects.

Degradation Analysis. We evaluated CSQA and MMLU after representation alignment alone (Table 4). The consistent MMLU degradation indicates that these additional updates contribute to IERE's larger capability loss compared with MEMIT and ACE.

Affected Knowledge Domains. Our subject-level MMLU analysis of the final IERE models (Table 5) identifies Professional Medicine and High School Mathematics as the most affected domains on Llama-3-8B-Instruct and GPT-J-6B, respectively. Since CSQA lacks question-type labels, we restrict the fine-grained analysis to MMLU.

Table 4. CSQA and MMLU accuracy (%).

ModelMethod2-hop CSQA2-hop MMLU3-hop CSQA3-hop MMLU4-hop CSQA4-hop MMLU
Llama-3-8B-InstructBase80.3370.1880.3370.1880.3370.18
Alignment only78.7769.0477.0369.1076.7769.04
IERE80.1167.0279.3365.7378.8966.67
GPT-J-6BBase22.0030.5322.0030.5322.0030.53
Alignment only21.2225.9722.5225.0720.9624.77
IERE17.8925.3819.0025.9620.1124.91

Table 5. Largest MMLU subject declines (pp).

ModelHopsMost affected subjectDecline (pp)
Llama-3-8B-Instruct2Professional medicine23.53
3Machine learning16.96
4Professional medicine16.54
GPT-J-6B2High-school mathematics26.67
3Global facts27.00
4High-school mathematics26.67

Q3. Intermediate-Entity Representation Reuse

Our additional analysis provides evidence that IERE improves the use of intermediate-entity representations during normal multi-hop inference.

We measured subject–desired-object cosine similarity across editing stages without activation patching (Table 3). Similarity increases substantially after representation alignment but partially decreases after factual editing, indicating that IERE induces the intended representation shift through parameter editing.

Q4. Dependency-Aware MEMIT Comparison

Dependency-aware MEMIT generally underperforms IERE, with inconsistent improvements over standard MEMIT.

We evaluated a dependency-aware MEMIT baseline using the same downstream-to-upstream edit order as IERE, but without representation alignment (Table 6).

IERE outperforms this baseline in five of six settings, while dependency-aware MEMIT shows mixed results relative to standard MEMIT. This indicates that ordering factual edits alone cannot reproduce the benefits of dependency-aware representation alignment.

Table 6. Multi-hop accuracy with dependency-aware MEMIT.

ModelHopsMEMITDependency-aware MEMITIERE
Llama-3-8B-Instruct28.5116.2239.76
35.103.5534.37
47.356.7121.41
GPT-J-6B217.6913.9625.40
35.546.878.20
48.9510.869.90

Thank you for the detailed response and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns. The new experiments provide useful evidence regarding generalizability, capability degradation, and the contributions of different components. While some concerns remain, particularly regarding multi-hop accuracy and the underlying mechanism, I believe the rebuttal has adequately addressed my main questions. I will maintain my original positive rating.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Official Comment by Authors

We sincerely thank the reviewer for their thoughtful feedback and positive assessment of our rebuttal. We greatly appreciate your recognition of our efforts and the additional experimental evidence. We are especially grateful for your continued support and decision to maintain your positive rating. Your constructive comments have been invaluable in helping us improve our work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.