- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper adds a frame-level marginal DMD term from an image teacher (Qwen-Image) on top of joint DMD for few-step video distillation. LatentBridge maps video latents to image latents, and LVS chooses which frames to supervise. It improves visual quality and semantic scores on both causal and bidirectional students.
Critical strengths
The idea is simple and gives consistent gains across all NFE settings at no inference cost. The LatentBridge ablation (Tab. 4) clearly shows that applying marginal DMD directly to video latents collapses motion.
Critical weaknesses
With Wan-14B as the image teacher the gain is small (80.67→81.43), so most of the improvement comes from the stronger Qwen-Image prior, and the closest prior image-teacher distillation methods (MCM, Zhu et al. 2024) are not compared. The theory assumes the key conclusion (that the image teacher's marginal is closer to real frames), and temporal quality is checked only with coarse VBench metrics.
Questions for authors
How does the method compare with Zhu et al. 2024 and with a frame-level reward baseline using the same image prior? How is "Total" computed, and what are the official VBench temporal-consistency scores?
We really appreciate the reviewer for the detailed and constructive feedback. We are pleased that you recognize the simplicity and usefulness of our approach and its consistent gains without additional inference cost. Below, we address your concerns point by point.
Question 1: How does the method compare with Zhu et al. 2024?
Response: Thank you for this suggestion. We adapt MCM and AVDM² to Wan for comparison. For AVDM², we additionally provide our LatentBridge to enable frame-level score matching with the same Qwen-Image teacher.
Table 1. VBench Total comparison on Wan under matched generation modes and 4-step budgets.
Question 2: How is "Total" computed, and what are the official VBench temporal-consistency scores?
Response: We follow the official VBench aggregation:
Total = 100 × (0.8 × Quality + 0.2 × Semantic)
Quality = (Subject Consistency + Background Consistency + Temporal Flickering + Motion Smoothness + Aesthetic Quality + Imaging Quality + 0.5 × Dynamic Degree) / 6.5
We additionally report the official VBench temporal-consistency metrics below.
Table 2. VBench temporal-consistency scores.
Concern 3: With Wan-14B as the image teacher the gain is small (80.67→81.43), so most of the improvement comes from the stronger Qwen-Image prior. How does the method compare with a frame-level reward baseline using the same image prior?
Response: Thank you for raising this point. We would like to clarify that a 0.76-point improvement on VBench is non-trivial. For context, Causal Forcing reports a 0.30-point improvement over Self Forcing in VBench Total (83.74 → 84.04).
We agree that Qwen-Image provides a stronger prior, while effectively transferring this prior is a key contribution of our method. To examine the role of the transfer mechanism, we also evaluate a DMD2-style alternative that combines joint video DMD with a frame-level adversarial loss, using 10,000 Qwen-Image-generated images to train the discriminator. Its lower performance compared with DuoMatching supports the effectiveness of our approach in transferring the image prior.
Table 3. Comparison of transfer mechanisms using the same Qwen-Image prior source under matched 2-step settings.
Concern 4: The theory assumes the key conclusion (that the image teacher's marginal is closer to real frames).
Response: Thank you for raising this concern. To empirically examine its marginal-quality assumption, we use the same video prompts to generate 1,000 Qwen-Image images and Wan2.1-14B videos, then compare the images and sampled video frames against 1,000 randomly sampled OpenVidHD reference frames. Qwen-Image achieves a lower FID (61.79 vs. 66.85), providing empirical evidence consistent with this assumption.