acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Accept, Challenge, or Amend? Receiver-Side Information Handling in Multi-Agent Systems

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

In multi-agent systems, specifying who communicates with whom does not determine how a receiving agent should handle incoming information. We formulate receiver-side information handling as a separately configurable system design dimension and study three representative policies: ACCEPT, in which the receiver uses the sender’s information as the basis for subsequent actions; CHALLENGE, in which the receiver returns local evidence and requests sender-side revision; and LOCAL AMEND, in which the receiver locally adjusts its subsequent actions within its own responsibility boundary. Using Qwen3-Max and GPT-5.6-Luna, we conduct paired end-to-end evaluations across ALFWorld, AppWorld, ToolSandbox, and Collab-Overcooked, together with controlled handoff experiments in ALFWorld to investigate the underlying mechanisms. Our results show that different fixed handling policies lead to distinct execution trajectories, realized intervention behavior, and computational costs, while no single fixed policy consistently dominates across the tested environments and model backbones. Controlled experiments further show that when receivers possess diagnostic local evidence, challenging or locally amending erroneous handoffs substantially improves immediate repair; in contrast, interventions without such evidence can incur additional cost without improving final task performance. Motivated by these findings, we introduce an evidence-gated adaptive receiver-side handling strategy that dynamically selects among ACCEPT, CHALLENGE, and LOCAL AMEND at each information handoff based on local conflict evidence, repair reliability, and responsibility boundaries. Across the eight model–environment combinations, the adaptive strategy attains or ties the highest primary task-performance point estimate in seven cases and remains close to the best fixed policy in the remaining case. While not always minimizing token usage, it exhibits more consistent relative performance across environments and model backbones and generally avoids the highest token costs associated with fixed policies. Overall, our findings establish receiver-side information handling as an important system design dimension that should be explicitly configured and evaluated in multi-agent systems.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
Multi-Agent Systems, Receiver-Side Information Handling, Agent Communication, Long-Horizon Agent Evaluation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_qJmwOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies receiver-side information handling as an explicit design dimension in LLM-based multi-agent systems. Instead of treating an incoming message as something that should always be followed, the paper considers three alternative handling policies (accept, challenge, local amend). The authors evaluate these policies using Qwen3-Max and GPT-5.6-Luna across ALFWorld, AppWorld, ToolSandbox, and Collab-Overcooked, and complement the end-to-end evaluation with controlled ALFWorld handoff experiments. Based on these observations, the paper proposes an evidence-gated adaptive policy that selects among the policies according to receiver-visible conflict and local repairability. Across eight model-environment combinations, the adaptive policy matches or exceeds the best fixed/reference condition in 7.

Critical strengths
  1. Good problem formulation. The paper identifies a relatively under-explored aspect of multi-agent system design: not only who communicates with whom, but also what authority the receiver should assign to an incoming message.

  2. Comprehensive controlled-mechanism analysis. The controlled ALFWorld experiments manipulate evidence ownership and receiver visibility, showing, for example, that CHALLENGE is highly effective when repair information remains with the sender, whereas LOCAL AMEND becomes much more effective when the relevant evidence is moved into the receiver's history. The matched-revision control further suggests that the benefit of CHALLENGE is not simply caused by giving the sender an additional model call, but is related to the diagnostic content of the feedback. This provides a reasonably convincing mechanistic story for why different handling policies can be preferable under different information conditions.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Instability of prompt-based strategy selection and self-judgment.

The adaptive policy assumes that the receiver can determine whether there is a "concrete local conflict" and whether a "reliable in-scope repair" is available, and these judgments are made within the receiver's ordinary generation rather than by an independently calibrated module. In this case, the evidence-gated policy relies on internal judgments that may be difficult for an LLM itself to make reliably. This creates a potential error-propagation issue: if the receiver incorrectly believes that it has reliable repair evidence, LOCAL AMEND may be selected when CHALLENGE or ACCEPT would have been safer. Empirically, The controlled routing experiment shows 93.3% overall route agreement, but the errors are concentrated at the CHALLENGE boundary, with only 60% recall for expected CHALLENGE cases.

Therefore, using a separate or trained module may make the judment more reliable.

  1. The end-to-end empirical evaluation is relatively small and heterogeneous.

The per-environment sample sizes are only 50 tasks for ALFWorld and 30 tasks for each of AppWorld, ToolSandbox, and Collab-Overcooked. Moreover, the environments use substantially different task structures and evaluation metrics, with ToolSandbox using a similarity score rather than binary success. This makes it difficult to assess the statistical robustness and generality of the reported point-estimate improvements. For example, several adaptive improvements are only a few percentage points, and the main adaptive table explicitly reports point estimates without significance marks.

Questions for authors
  1. The current formulation emphasizes concrete conflict and reliable local repair. A particularly interesting case is when both sender and receiver possess evidence supporting different interpretations of the state. How does the policy behave when the two agents have conflicting but individually plausible evidence?

  2. The paper assumes all agents are "innocent" (trying to make the task work). However, it's interesting to consider the author's method in a controversial scenario: one, or multiple agents in the system have malicious intentions and wants to ruin the task. Can the author's method still work in such cases? If so, the method can be used to enhance the robustness of a multi-agent system.

Reviewer_jXRtOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies how an agent should handle an incoming message from another agent. It compares three choices: ACCEPT the message, CHALLENGE it by asking the sender to revise, or LOCAL AMEND it within the receiver's responsibilities. The authors evaluate fixed policies and native systems across two models and four environments.

Controlled ALFWorld experiments change whether a conflict is visible, which agent has the evidence needed for repair, and how much history the receiver can see. Other experiments vary feedback while keeping the opportunity for revision fixed. The results show that access to evidence affects which repair choice is useful.

The paper also introduces inline_adaptive, which chooses among the three routes during the receiver's normal generation. Its reported score matches or exceeds the best fixed policy in seven of eight model/environment combinations. The evaluation reports immediate repair, final task outcomes, and token use separately.

Critical strengths
  • The paired experiments show why access to repair evidence matters. When only the sender has the needed evidence (C2), CHALLENGE repairs 24/25 checkpoints for both models. LOCAL AMEND repairs only 7/25 and 4/25. Giving the receiver more history raises LOCAL AMEND from 3/30 to 30/30 and 29/30, while CHALLENGE changes little. Comparing the same checkpoints helps link these differences to evidence access (Table 2, Figure 2, Appendices A.2 to A.4 and B.5). This supports choosing the repair route according to which agent can make the correction.

  • The evaluation separates immediate repairs from final task success. The study includes 1,120 fixed-policy and 280 adaptive trajectories across two models and four environments. It distinguishes a correct immediate action, final task success, and partial completion in ToolSandbox. It also reports negative controls and cases where a local correction still leads to task failure (Appendices B.5, B.6, C.2, and G). These distinctions help assess what the interventions actually achieve.

Critical weaknesses
  • The novelty is unclear, and the presentation obscures the contribution. Inline_adaptive uses a simple evidence-based rule to choose among the three handling routes. The paper needs to explain what this adds to prior work on evidence-aware communication, feedback-based coordination, and agent correction. Appendix C.5 reports a competitive visible-evidence rule, but evaluates it on its development examples. The writing also makes the contribution difficult to identify. The abstract spends too much space on experimental details, and Figures 1 and 3 repeat parts of the same procedure. A shorter abstract and clearer figures would make the main contribution easier to assess.

  • Task-level gains remain uncertain on the small evaluation samples. The main controlled experiments use constructed ALFWorld handoffs. The ToolSandbox replication includes only 12 checkpoints per model. End-to-end evaluations use 30–50 tasks per environment, and several adaptive gains amount to only one to three additional successful tasks. The paper reports paired statistics for controlled experiments, but not variation across repeated executions of the adaptive policy. Better immediate repair does not consistently improve final task success. The adaptive policy also uses more tokens in six of eight comparisons. These results leave it unclear whether the gains would persist on new tasks or justify the extra cost.

Questions for authors
  • How do the adaptive policy and simple evidence rule compare on independent handoffs once all rules and prompts are fixed?

  • How does adaptive routing compare with frequency-matched random routing when both use the same route-specific instructions and feedback?

  • Does the full history-window experiment replicate outside ALFWorld, beyond the ToolSandbox cases with sender-held evidence in Table B4?

  • What are the paired win/loss counts, 95% confidence intervals, and repeated-run results for the adaptive policy in Table 3?

  • Could the main figures and tables distinguish the experimental settings and report task success, repair rates, and costs separately?

Reviewer_Fo6jOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates how agents should handle incoming information and proposes three operators (Accept, Challenge, Amend) as opposed to simply treating the received information as gold truth. The paper says this is for multi-agent systems but I believe this can apply to any agent, even those interacting with humans. The authors formulate this as a local decision problem where the agent chooses from the 3 options first and then executes accordingly. Experiments are performed on four environments, followed by analyses of the various design choices.

Critical strengths
  1. Paper is well motivated - the problem of solving coordination overhead and reducing error propagation is important for multi-agent systems and human-AI interaction.
  2. The paper is well written generally and easy to read (except the math notation).
Critical weaknesses
  1. The experiments are too small-scale to learn anything of significance. n=30/50 are too small and further, the numbers in table 1 and table 3 do not present a meaningful advantage for any single scheme or the adaptive one over Native. I'd also expect to see better baselines like self-reflection, adding critic agents, etc. - just comparing to Native is too weak.
  2. The tasks and setup used (two-agent planner+executor) are fairly basic and limited. I'd suggest demonstrating across a broader variety of settings.
Questions for authors

Overall, I'd say the idea of the paper ("gracefully handle missing info/repair using the right evidence sources") is good. And while the experimental design is carefully controlled, I think the domains used (e.g. AlfWorld) and the number of tasks (n=30) are simply too limited to conclude anything useful. I would strongly suggest improving the statistical validity of the results, adding more proper baseliens, running repeated samples of the agents, and expanding to settings beyond just the two-agent planning based tasks.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.