- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This work develops diffusion features for domain-generalized 3D semantic segmentation. SRA selects and spatially aligns diffusion activations, BIR exchanges information between modalities at corresponding points, and SSM injects the resulting features into the segmentation branches. Experiments cover four domain shifts and report improvements in ensemble segmentation accuracy over the comparative methods.
Critical strengths
The main results are promising. In Table 1, the DG ensemble outperforms XDiff3D for most settings. The paper includes useful component ablations and parameter studies. Table 3 shows clear gains from adding BIR and SSM on two tasks, while Tables 4,5,6, and 7 examine diffusion variants, fusion methods, timesteps, and dimensions.
Critical weaknesses
-
The specific benefits of the proposed mechanisms need stronger controls. Table 3 introduces two diffusion priors together with SRA, so SRA’s contribution is unclear.
-
The comparison with recent work is limited, particularly for DG, the main focus of this paper. Table 1 includes two DA methods from 2025, but only one DG method from 2025. Please include additional relevant methods from 2025 and/or 2026 under a comparable evaluation protocol.
Questions for authors
-
The baseline results are inconsistent across tables. For vKITTI→sKITTI on DG, Table 2 reports UniDSeg’s 3D mIoU as 42.12 and Ours 3D mIoU as 59.64, consistent with their listed class scores, whereas Table 1 reports 44.7 for UniDSeg and 59.7 for Ours. The inconsistent baseline results need to be resolved.
-
Figure 2 covers four domain shifts but shows only one example per setting and compares only with UniDSeg. Please include more diverse scenes and zoomed-in comparisons, particularly for small objects, class boundaries, and sparse regions. Adding XDiff3D would also help show where the proposed method improves over the closest baseline.
2 comments
Other Response.
Q1. Different numbers between Tables 1 and 2.
Q1.A. Thank you for checking the class averages. The differences arise because our reproduction differs from the original paper in UniDSeg [7], and separate training runs of D²SIR. The 44.7 in Table 1 is the 3D mIoU reported in the original UniDSeg paper for vKITTI → SemanticKITTI DG. The 42.12 in Table 2 comes from our reproduction of the ViT-L/14 checkpoint at 39k iterations. Therefore, we have highlighted the reproduction values in red in Table 2. For D²SIR, the original Table 1 run yielded 59.67, which rounds to 59.7. The rerun used for Table 2 and subsequent experiments yielded 59.64, which rounds to 59.6. We have standardized the manuscript on the rerun, reporting 59.6 at one decimal place and 59.64 at two. Thanks again for the reminder.
Q2. Qualitative comparisons in Figure 2.
Q2.A. More comparisons have been added to Figure 2, including other methods XDiff3D [8], and zoomed-in comparisons. Additionally, to expand the comparison, we added two more frames per setting to the appendix, with full views and zoomed-in regions that highlight small objects, class boundaries, and sparse regions.
References
[1] Liang et al. UniDxMD: Towards Unified Representation for Cross-Modal Unsupervised Domain Adaptation in 3D Semantic Segmentation. ICCV, 2025. Paper · Supplement
[2] Sun et al. Cross-modal unsupervised domain adaptation for 3D semantic segmentation via multi-scale fusion-then-distillation. Journal of King Saud University Computer and Information Sciences, 2025. Paper
[3] Zhang et al. UniD-Shift: Towards Unified Semantic Segmentation via Interpretable Share-Private Multimodal Decomposition. arXiv:2605.07356, 2026. Paper
[4] Wu et al. BeyondSparse: Facilitating Mamba to Enhance Cross-Domain 3D Semantic Segmentation in Adverse Weather. AAAI, 2026. Paper
[5] Kim et al. Toward Enhanced Representation Learning for Single-Source Domain Generalization in LiDAR Semantic Segmentation. IEEE TPAMI, 2026. Paper
[6] Yang et al. Explicit Geometry-Reflectance Domain Shift Modeling for Robust LiDAR Segmentation in Adverse Weather. IJCV, 2026. Paper
[7] Wu et al. UniDSeg: Unified Cross-Domain 3D Semantic Segmentation via Visual Foundation Models Prior. NeurIPS, 2024. Paper
[8] Li et al. No Object Is an Island: Enhancing 3D Semantic Segmentation Generalization with Diffusion Models. NeurIPS, 2025. Paper
Additional experiments are provided to compare the advantages of the method. More comparisons on recent work.
W1. Isolating the contribution of SRA.
W1.A. Thank you for your suggestion. The table below supplements the individual contribution of SRA (as modified in Table 3 of the paper). The fourth and fifth data rows in the table below correspond to the variants without and with SRA, respectively. To achieve the variant without SRA, we average each layer's residual activations within each frame for each modality and assign the resulting features to all valid points in that frame. In 3D results,adding SRA improves 2.3% (43.7% to 46.0%) on vKITTI/sKITTI and 0.2% (64.7% to 64.9%) on nuScenes:USA/Sing. In xM results,adding SRA improves 1.8% (59.5% to 61.3%) on vKITTI/sKITTI and 0.3% (72.1% to 72.4%) on nuScenes:USA/Sing. The experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of the proposed SRA.
W2. Comparisons with recent work.
W2.A1. Thank you for your suggestion. We have searched for all relevant papers again on Google Scholar. The comparisons that can be added are shown in the table below. Regarding the DA method, UniDxMD [1] (2025 ICCV) reports the same validation settings in the appendix. For MS-xMUDA [2] (2025 KSUCIC), we report the pseudo-label retraining results and use the nuScenes-Lidarseg columns with point-level annotations for both nuScenes transfers. UniD-Shift [3] (2026 arXiv) reports 74.5 xM on USA → Singapore. However, the paper leaves its use of unlabeled target training data and its exact test split unspecified. We will add a matched-protocol comparison with UniD-Shift after the camera-ready submission. Regarding the DG method, BeyondSparse [4] (2026 AAAI), DGLSS++ [5] (2026 TPAMI), GRCNet [6] (2026 IJCV) are proposed for LiDAR-only setting, which differs from the cross-modal method. To the best of our knowledge, no other existing cross-modal domain generalization methods for the RGB-LiDAR modality follow this same experimental protocol. Extending these LiDAR-only methods to the RGB-LiDAR fusion (xM) scenario would necessitate the integration of an RGB branch. Since these LiDAR-only methods rely on the LiDAR SemanticSTF dataset, our future work could explore how to leverage single 3D diffusion models to enhance domain generalization.
W2.A2. Currently, there has been insufficient exploration of cross-modal domain generalization methods within the field. Our complete code and model weights will be publicly available on GitHub after the paper is accepted (as stated in the abstract), facilitating further research on this cross-modal domain generalization models.