- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes GRAM-VLA, an RDT-based model for dual-arm manipulation using depth observations. It introduces TCPE to inject language, RGB, and depth conditions into different layers, and a Gramian-volume loss to encourage multimodal alignment during training. The full model has a higher average success rate than the reported baselines across eight real-robot tasks and is more robust to appearance and object-height changes.
Critical strengths
- The full system improves performance on real-robot tasks. In Table 1, its average success rate is 53.6%, compared with 30.0% for RDT and 46.3% for DP3. This suggests practical value, although the source of the gain is unclear.
- The improvements under appearance and height changes in Table 2 are substantial. These are relevant robustness challenges for manipulation policies and, in my view, the paper’s strongest results.
Critical weaknesses
- The paper does not isolate its claimed contributions. It adds depth, a depth encoder, TCPE, and the GRAM loss together, but does not compare against an RDT model with the same depth observations or ablate TCPE and the GRAM loss separately. Depth alone could explain much of the reported gain, especially under height changes. Because alternating condition injection and Gramian-volume learning build on prior work, the paper needs to show what its proposed components add.
- The experiments do not clearly support the dual-arm and long-horizon claims. In Figure 4, the arms mainly act in sequence, and the full-task completion rate of pretrained GRAM-VLA is 15%. The higher stage score shows better progress on this task, but does not establish improved two-arm coordination or long-horizon planning specifically.
Questions for authors
- Additional evidence that could change my assessment: Can the authors provide a matched RDT + depth baseline and separate ablations for TCPE and the GRAM loss, using the same observations and training setup? This would clarify whether the proposed components add value beyond depth.
- Clarification and possible additional evidence: Which experiment isolates a benefit for two-arm coordination rather than a general benefit from depth in spatial manipulation? If the current paper has no such result, is a targeted evaluation available?