- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies telic instruction following in streaming video generation, where a model should complete a requested state transition, avoid progress regression, and preserve the achieved consequence. The paper introduces State Forcing, a state-privileged on-policy self-distillation framework built on a pretrained streaming video generator. During training, a frozen teacher receives a verified terminal video chunk through two complementary conditions: ADVANCE uses the terminal chunk to guide an unfinished event toward completion, while HOLD uses it to supervise consequence retention after completion. The student follows its standard streaming pipeline and matches the teacher’s denoising predictions along student-generated trajectories, requiring no additional inputs or computation at inference. The paper also introduces TelicBench, containing 150 instructions evaluated using Completion Rate, Telic Violation Rate, and Telic Success Rate. Component ablations and a limited human study provide additional validation.
Critical strengths
-
Important and underexplored problem formulation. The paper identifies a meaningful limitation of current streaming video generators: long-term visual coherence does not guarantee successful task execution. Explicitly separating completion, non-regressing progress, and consequence retention provides a useful perspective that is not adequately captured by standard long-video quality metrics.
-
Practical terminal-state supervision with no inference-time overhead. Using verified terminal chunks as privileged teacher context is intuitive and practically attractive. The ADVANCE and HOLD conditions target two distinct failure modes, and the ablations provide initial evidence that they play complementary roles. The trained student retains the original architecture, sampler, prompt, and cache policy at inference.
Critical weaknesses
-
The methodological novelty is limited relative to prior privileged on-policy distillation. The core training objective, student-generated rollout, frozen teacher, stop-gradient cache update, and denoising prediction matching largely follow existing OPSD-style methods. The primary technical modification is how the teacher context is initialized using terminal chunks. Consequently, the method may be viewed as a task-specific application of OPSD-V rather than a fundamentally new distillation framework. The paper lacks a matched comparison against OPSD-V or standard on-policy distillation using the same telic data, initialization, and training budget.
-
The experiments do not conclusively establish the claimed mechanism. The central claim that terminal-state privilege teaches progress and consequence retention is not supported by sufficient counterfactual ablations. In particular, the paper does not compare correct terminal chunks against random future chunks, non-terminal chunks, mismatched terminal chunks, or terminal text alone. Moreover, TVR does not penalize pausing or inactivity, so reduced motion or post-completion freezing may improve the reported metrics without demonstrating genuine consequence retention. Generic VBench scores do not directly rule out this shortcut on telic prompts. This concern is amplified because the same VLM family is used for prompt generation, training-data verification, terminal-state localization, and automatic evaluation.
-
The visual results and method presentation need improvement. In Figures 1 and 2, the first and last frames exhibit noticeable inconsistencies in visual details, such as changes in the color of the girl’s skirt. Moreover, the LongLive results appear reasonably strong, making the qualitative advantage of State Forcing less convincing. In Figure 3, the overall framework appears highly similar to OPSD-V, and the paper should more clearly highlight its methodological differences.
These limitations prevent the current evidence from clearly separating the proposed mechanism from simpler explanations such as telic-specific fine-tuning, stronger state anchoring, or motion suppression.
Questions for authors
-
How many source rollouts were generated to obtain the 3,000 accepted training records? What proportion was rejected because of incomplete execution, incorrect initial states, or subject/scene drift? This information is important for determining whether the method mainly learns from easy cases that the base model can already complete.
-
How are ADVANCE and HOLD records constructed and balanced? Can the same source rollout provide both branches, and how are the unfinished prefix, terminal boundary, and terminal chunk (G) selected? The current description does not establish how much variation exists in the training states.
-
In ADVANCE, the future terminal chunk replaces the initial sink while being assigned the sink’s temporal positions. How are positional encodings and cache timestamps handled in this operation? Why does placing future content at past temporal positions not introduce temporal aliasing or encourage direct appearance copying?
-
How does State Forcing compare with standard OPSD-V, ordinary on-policy distillation, and supervised fine-tuning when all methods use the same warm-up checkpoint, telic training data, and optimization budget? Without these matched baselines, it is difficult to attribute the gains specifically to terminal-state forcing.
7 comments
Author Response to Reviewer yp4i (Part 2/5)
Matched Experimental Comparisons
Following the reviewer’s suggestion, we retrain OPSD-V from the same Warm-up Only checkpoint using the same accepted telic records and matched training compute. This baseline retains OPSD-V’s temporal-context supervision procedure, adapted to the common telic source rollouts. We also evaluate direct SFT from the same checkpoint under a matched compute budget. The accepted records contain verified prefixes and terminal intervals, but their complete source rollouts may contain temporal violations. We therefore construct reliable SFT demonstrations by retaining fully successful executions from this pool. This SFT baseline uses a filtered subset and is reported separately from the data-matched OPSD-V. All methods use the same TelicBench evaluation protocol. Scores are percentages.
| Method | CR ↑ | TVR ↓ | TSR ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Warm-up Only | 39.87 | 20.02 | 19.20 |
| Matched SFT | 33.33 | 15.25 | 16.67 |
| Matched OPSD-V | 44.67 | 23.05 | 17.33 |
| State Forcing | 51.33 | 7.60 | 37.33 |
State Forcing exceeds matched OPSD-V by 20.00 percentage points in TSR, while reducing TVR by 15.45 points and achieving higher completion. These results support the benefit of terminal-state-oriented supervision beyond applying existing video OPSD to the same telic records. The tested SFT configuration also does not reproduce these gains.
Taken together, our distinct state-privileged supervision design and matched experimental results establish State Forcing as a substantive methodological contribution beyond existing OPSD-based methods. To the best of our knowledge, State Forcing is the first to formulate telic instruction following as a distinct problem in streaming video generation and develop a dedicated training approach that jointly addresses completion, non-regressing progression, and consequence retention.
Weakness 2 — Insufficient evidence for the proposed mechanism
Counterfactual ablations of terminal-state privilege.
To test whether the gains depend on correctly matched terminal-state evidence, we replace the verified terminal chunk with four alternatives: random future chunks sampled without terminal-state filtering, non-terminal chunks, terminal chunks from mismatched rollouts, and terminal-state text alone. All variants retain the same training settings, differing only in the privileged teacher context. Scores are percentages.
| Teacher Context | CR ↑ | TVR ↓ | TSR ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| Random future chunk | 30.13 | 11.32 | 20.53 |
| Non-terminal chunk | 31.60 | 10.79 | 19.73 |
| Mismatched terminal chunk | 29.07 | 16.79 | 18.27 |
| Terminal-state text only | 39.33 | 17.02 | 19.60 |
| State Forcing | 51.33 | 7.60 | 37.33 |
Correct terminal chunks achieve the highest completion and strict-success rates and the lowest violation rate. Their TSR exceeds the strongest alternative by 16.80 percentage points. These controls support the importance of verified, correctly matched visual terminal-state evidence: arbitrary future context, incomplete-state evidence, mismatched outcomes, and terminal descriptions alone do not reproduce the gains.
Independent VLM evaluation.
To assess the robustness of our evaluation to the choice of VLM judge, we additionally evaluate all methods using Gemini 3.8 Flash as an independent evaluator. We retain the same TelicBench videos, evaluation rubrics, frame-sampling protocol, and scoring criteria, changing only the evaluator.
| Method | CR ↑ | TVR ↓ | TSR ↑ |
|---|---|---|---|
| SkyReels-V2 | 19.33 | 18.90 | 6.00 |
| MAGI-1 | 32.67 | 14.27 | 15.33 |
| Self Forcing | 44.67 | 22.44 | 16.67 |
| Rolling Forcing | 48.67 | 16.33 | 20.00 |
| Context Forcing | 50.67 | 17.32 | 23.33 |
| LongLive | 49.33 | 15.57 | 25.33 |
| State Forcing | 52.00 | 9.87 | 35.33 |
Despite differences in absolute scores, Gemini independently identifies State Forcing as the best-performing method across all three metrics. Our blinded human study (Section 5.3) further corroborates this finding: State Forcing achieves the highest completion rate (60%) and strict success rate (34%), as well as the lowest violation extent (1.56). The consistent findings across GPT-5.6, Gemini 3.8 Flash, and human evaluations provide strong evidence for the reliability of our evaluation and the effectiveness of State Forcing.
Author Response to Reviewer yp4i (Part 3/5)
Distinguishing consequence retention from post-completion freezing.
TVR measures task-related temporal violations rather than motion magnitude. Importantly, whether inactivity constitutes a failure depends on the instruction semantics: maintaining an achieved terminal state may legitimately require static content, whereas suppressing explicitly required scene dynamics would violate the instruction. We therefore do not penalize inactivity alone. TSR further requires both successful completion and violation-free execution, preventing a model from exploiting reduced motion or inactivity without actually executing the requested transition.
To directly investigate post-completion freezing, we conduct an additional dynamics evaluation on TelicBench instructions that explicitly require non-task-related scene dynamics to continue after task completion. We evaluate videos satisfying the strict-success criterion, assessing whether the specified dynamics persist from the first completion timestamp until the end of the rollout. Importantly, the expected dynamics can range from subtle local motions to large-scale background activities, which cannot be adequately assessed using generic motion-magnitude measurements. We therefore use an independent Gemini 3.8 Flash evaluator to assess the preservation of instruction-specified dynamics. We further validate the findings through blinded human evaluation using the same 0–2 scoring rubric.
| Method | VLM score ↑ | Human score ↑ |
|---|---|---|
| LongLive | 1.57 | 1.22 |
| Context Forcing | 1.11 | 1.05 |
| State Forcing | 1.52 | 1.24 |
Scores range from 0 (required dynamics are not preserved) to 2 (required dynamics are fully preserved). VLM evaluation covers all eligible strictly successful videos, while human evaluation uses 30 randomly sampled videos per method, independently rated by five annotators.
Notably, LongLive and Context Forcing serve as general streaming-generation baselines without telic-specific training or post-completion supervision. State Forcing achieves post-completion dynamics scores comparable to LongLive and higher than Context Forcing in both independent evaluations. These results demonstrate that State Forcing can retain the achieved task outcome while preserving explicitly required scene dynamics after completion, rather than relying on post-completion freezing.
Weakness 3 — Visual results and method presentation
Figure 1 is intended to demonstrate telic instruction-following behavior, rather than compare the frame-wise visual quality of individual frames. In the door example, LongLive reverses the opening transition and returns to a closed door. In the character-entry example, it repeats the entry event after completion, producing additional boy instances instead of retaining the requested single-character outcome. State Forcing avoids these failures in the displayed sequences. Importantly, visual consistency and correct telic instruction execution are distinct evaluation dimensions: visually coherent frames do not necessarily imply correct event progression and consequence retention. These side-by-side examples directly illustrate State Forcing's qualitative advantage in telic execution. Table 2 further shows that State Forcing maintains higher subject consistency than LongLive at both 30 seconds (0.9860 vs. 0.9751) and 60 seconds (0.9840 vs. 0.9734), together with higher background consistency at both durations.
Figure 2 presents a controlled empirical study using a frozen LongLive-based generator to motivate State Forcing, rather than qualitative results of the trained State Forcing model. With model parameters and sampling fixed, it isolates the effect of state-privileged context on telic instruction following, demonstrating how verified terminal-state information supports progression and consequence retention. These observations motivate the subsequent ADVANCE and HOLD designs.
Figure 3 separates our designed state-privileged teacher-context construction in Panel (a) from its integration into on-policy distillation in Panel (b). Panel (a) explicitly shows ADVANCE's terminal-sink replacement and HOLD's terminal-only initialization under a consequent-state description. These branch-specific designs are distinct from OPSD-V's use of real-video history as privileged context. Panel (b) illustrates how these contexts are integrated into the shared OPSD training process. Its left side shows the student and privileged teacher contexts, while its right side depicts the student–teacher rollout and prediction-matching pipeline. We follow the schematic presentation in D-OPSD to illustrate this general OPSD procedure. Any visual similarity in this shared component reflects the underlying OPSD mechanics, rather than the method-specific teacher-context construction. The methodological distinction is further supported by the matched comparisons presented in our response to Weakness 1. We expand the Fig.3 caption for clarification.
Author Response to Reviewer yp4i (Part 1/5)
Response to Reviewer yp4i
Thank you for recognizing the importance of telic instruction following and the practical value of State Forcing. We address your concerns and questions in detail below.
Weakness 1 / Question 4 — Methodological novelty and matched comparisons
Positioning and distinction from existing OPSD methods.
OPSD was originally formulated for LLM post-training (Zhao et al., 2026a), where a single model acts as teacher and student under different contexts: the teacher receives privileged information, such as reference reasoning traces, while the student retains its standard question context. Subsequent OPSD methods adapt this principle to different tasks and modalities through task-specific teacher-context construction. For example, Learning from the Self-future (Luo et al., 2026) uses self-generated answers as privileged suffix context for diffusion LLMs, while D-OPSD (Jiang et al., 2026) conditions the teacher on multimodal features incorporating the target image for diffusion-model adaptation. In these methods, the privileged context shapes the teacher’s predictions and therefore the corrective supervision provided along student-generated trajectories. Within this paradigm, State Forcing introduces verified terminal states as teacher privilege for telic instruction following. ADVANCE uses terminal-state evidence to guide unfinished execution toward completion, while HOLD constructs supervision for preserving the achieved consequence. Our contribution lies in identifying terminal-state evidence as a source of supervision and designing these complementary teacher conditions to address progression and retention in streaming generation. This follows the broader OPSD principle of transferring task-relevant privileged knowledge through on-policy supervision, with a distinct supervision design tailored to telic execution.
Distinction from OPSD-V
OPSD-V and State Forcing share the OPSD training paradigm but construct teacher supervision for different long-horizon failure modes. OPSD-V addresses error accumulation and weakened motion dynamics by providing cleaner temporal contexts derived from real long-video sequences. State Forcing addresses telic execution: completing a requested transition without regression and preserving its consequence afterward. The key distinction is the information supplied to the teacher and the corrective behavior it encourages. Motivated by our observation that verified terminal states can guide both progression and retention in a frozen generator, we construct two complementary conditions. ADVANCE supplies terminal-state evidence alongside unfinished execution, while HOLD isolates the achieved outcome under a consequent-state description. On-policy distillation transfers these signals to the student’s own trajectories.
Accordingly, we adapt OPSD with terminal-state-privileged supervision, where complementary teacher conditions jointly guide event progression and post-completion retention. This contribution focuses on the supervision design for telic instruction following rather than introducing a fundamentally new distillation framework.