- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes ConcordFlow, a training-free and mask-free single-round 3D asset editing framework designed to address the task of complex 3D asset editing conditioned on multi-view images. To tackle the issues of error accumulation and corruption of irrelevant regions that plague existing multi-round editing methods, the framework introduces Trajectory-Guided Spatial Weighting (TGSW), Disagreement-Guided Reweighting (DGR), and Disagreement-Visibility Adaptive Fusion (DVAF) into the sparse-structure and latent-feature generation stages of TRELLIS, respectively. This enables efficient joint coordination of multi-view editing conditions and precise local control, substantially improving editing quality and preserving source-asset integrity while greatly reducing computational overhead. Qualitative and quantitative experiments demonstrate that ConcordFlow outperforms existing mainstream multi-round editing baselines.
Critical strengths
S1. The paper explicitly points out that conventional multi-round serial editing is prone to error accumulation and mutual interference between successive modifications, making the topic highly practical and forward-looking.
S2. The method is elegantly designed, complete, and theoretically sound.
S3. The framework requires no fine-tuning of the underlying diffusion model, and through single-round joint generation it avoids the substantial computational overhead of repeatedly performing 150-view rendering in TRELLIS multi-round editing, yielding a clear inference-speed advantage.
S4. This paper brings comprehensive experimental evaluation and a benchmarking contribution.
Critical weaknesses
W1. Strong dependence on 2D image editing quality: ConcordFlow depends on the upstream 2D editing model. If the upstream model fails to produce reasonable results, the editing results will likewise degrade.
W2. Struggle to handle order-dependent edits. if the complex instruction contains causal/sequential dependencies, independently generated multi-view 2D target images may exhibit severe spatial-structural conflicts, and the framework currently struggles to handle such order-dependent edits
W3. Hyperparameter sensitivity and the setting of temperature coefficients: The framework introduces several temperature-coefficient hyperparameters () as well as step-truncation parameters . Although the appendix provides step-sensitivity tests for and (Table 8), there is no discussion of the sensitivity of the Softmax temperature coefficients . If is too small, the weights may concentrate excessively on a single view; if too large, the scheme degenerates to uniform averaging.
Questions for authors
Although the paper claims to perform single-round editing, I would like to ask whether the proposed framework can also support multi-round editing. I think the proposed method is also able to do multi-round editing. If so, how does your method perform on such cases? Furthermore, do you have any ideas for addressing such order-dependent edits? How does the proposed method can be expanded to such cases?
4 comments
Follow-up on Additional Experiments and Clarifications
Dear Reviewer,
Thank you again for your thoughtful feedback. May we ask whether our additional experiments and clarifications have addressed your concerns? Briefly:
- Order-dependent editing: We clarify how ConcordFlow can be applied in successive rounds and provide a two-round example in which later edits build on the hat and camera produced in the first round.
- Temperature sensitivity: Across the tested temperature settings, Local DINO-I ranges from 0.760 to 0.767 and CLIP-T from 0.252 to 0.255, supporting robustness within the tested range.
- Upstream editing quality: We acknowledge that dependence on 2D target-image quality is a shared limitation of 3D editing methods conditioned on edited images. ConcordFlow coordinates view-specific conditions but does not correct errors introduced by the upstream editor.
The two-round visualization and temperature analysis are included in the revised manuscript. Please let us know if any concerns remain. We would be happy to clarify them.
Best regards,
The Authors
Thank you for your detailed explain. I decide to keep my score.
Thank you for your time and constructive feedback. Your suggestions have helped us improve the paper, and we appreciate your consideration of our responses.
Your suggestions prompted us to examine temperature sensitivity and clarify how ConcordFlow can handle order-dependent edits. Changes in the revised manuscript are highlighted in orange.
W1. Strong dependence on upstream 2D editing quality
We agree that ConcordFlow depends on the quality of the edited 2D target images. This limitation is shared by 3D editing methods that use edited images to condition an image-to-3D generator: missing or incorrect edits in the target images can carry over to the final 3D asset. ConcordFlow coordinates edits across views, but is not designed to correct errors introduced by the upstream 2D editor.
W2 & Q. Can ConcordFlow handle order-dependent edits over multiple rounds, and if so, how?
Order-dependent instructions do not necessarily require multiple editing rounds if their image conditions can be constructed in advance. The limitation in Sec. 5 concerns our single-round framework: conditions requiring intermediate edited results cannot be handled within that round. For such cases, we can apply ConcordFlow repeatedly in a multi-round workflow, organizing edits into successive rounds according to their dependencies. Each invocation remains a single-round joint edit, and its result becomes the source for constructing the next round's conditions. In our two-round example, the first round replaces the hat and cup, while the second adds details to the resulting hat and camera. We have added this workflow and the visualization to Appendix D.12.
W3. Missing analysis of softmax temperature sensitivity
To assess how sensitive editing performance is to the choice of softmax temperature, we vary one module’s temperature at a time while keeping the other two at their defaults. Across the tested temperature settings, Local DINO-I ranges from 0.760 to 0.767 and CLIP-T from 0.252 to 0.255, indicating that condition alignment is robust to temperature variations within this range. We have added these results to Appendix D.13.
TGSW temperature (DGR = 1.0, DVAF = 1.0).
DGR temperature (TGSW = 0.5, DVAF = 1.0).
DVAF temperature (TGSW = 0.5, DGR = 1.0).