acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Layered Game Engine: A Compositional Architecture for Executable Game Worlds

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

23 views

Abstract

Game engines typically combine multiple concerns, including world representation, game state, mechanics, execution, and presentation, into tightly coupled systems. This coupling can make it difficult to reuse game logic, modify individual aspects of a game, or reason about game behavior at different levels of abstraction. We present a layered game engine architecture that explicitly separates these concerns into distinct computational layers while maintaining an executable representation of the game. The architecture is designed around the idea that game behavior can be represented and transformed at different levels of abstraction while remaining composable and executable. We implement a prototype engine capable of running a complete game using this layered representation. This work investigates whether explicit layering can provide a useful abstraction for constructing and modifying interactive environments. We study the effects of the architecture on modularity, component reuse, modification cost, execution overhead, and scalability compared with conventional game-engine organization. The prototype provides a basis for evaluating whether layered representations can make game environments more structured, composable, and amenable to automated reasoning and learning. We release the architecture and prototype implementation as a foundation for further investigation of structured game representations and their use in learning-based interactive environments.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
game engines, game systems, layered architecture, compositionality, game development, interactive environments, modular systems

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 2%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.33 over 3 reviews, above 2% of the others.
Reviewer_kFXrOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents Layered Game Engine (LGE), an architecture that represents game behavior through executable rules with explicit stages, scopes, and dependencies. A compiled dependency graph determines execution order, while an observation-driven planner selects spatially relevant entities and a dependency-closed set of rules. A VisualField abstraction separates semantic state from visual processing. The authors describe a C++20 prototype and evaluate full, selective, and cached-selective execution on synthetic worlds. At 100K entities, cached-selective execution reduces runtime from approximately 33.50 to 7.61 ms/tick, although its cost still increases substantially with total world population.

Critical strengths
  1. The architecture separates several concerns clearly. Distinguishing execution stage, semantic scope, spatial organization, and rule dependencies provides a coherent framework for observation-driven execution. Sharing state representations and rule bodies between full and selective execution is a useful design choice: it allows execution selection to change without maintaining separate implementations of the underlying behaviors.

  2. The empirical conclusions are appropriately restrained. The paper explicitly recognizes that a fixed semantic active set does not produce population-independent execution cost. It also acknowledges the limitations of the cross-engine workloads and avoids treating their timings as evidence of general performance superiority. This makes the reported scaling limitation a useful observation about the prototype.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The architectural novelty relative to existing ECS scheduling mechanisms is insufficiently established. Sections 2.4 and 10.2 emphasize explicit stages, dependencies, and a compiled execution graph as distinguishing features. However, existing systems such as Bevy already expose explicit scheduling metadata and dependency graphs; see the Bevy ScheduleGraph documentation. The potentially distinctive contribution, therefore, appears to be the integration of observation-driven spatial selection with dependency closure. The paper does not explain precisely what this integration enables beyond an ECS scheduler combined with spatial queries. A concrete comparison or worked example would be important for establishing the contribution’s significance.

  2. The evidence is too preliminary to establish the value of the proposed composition and selection mechanisms. The main quantitative result relies on cached selective execution, but the manuscript does not define what is cached, when it is refreshed, or whether cache construction and maintenance are included in the timings. The benchmark also leaves the seven active rules and their actual computational workload unspecified. Consequently, the reported speedup is difficult to attribute to particular architectural choices. Meanwhile, compositionality is supported mainly by brief descriptions of shared mechanisms, such as water and jelly-like behavior using the same primitive. Without a worked rule definition, dependency graph, and resulting execution plan, these examples provide limited evidence of the benefits of the proposed architecture. The authors acknowledge several limitations, but the remaining evidence does not yet establish a sufficiently substantial research contribution.

Questions for authors
  1. What specific capability does LGE provide beyond an existing ECS with explicit scheduling dependencies and spatial queries? Could you demonstrate this through one concrete example showing how changing the observation or composing behaviors changes execution without modifying the rule bodies?

  2. What exactly does cached selective cache, and what triggers an update? During the 120-tick benchmark, do the observation, region membership, or active entities change? Please specify the seven rules, the work they perform, and which planning and maintenance operations are included in the reported timings.

  3. What behavior is intended for inactive entities and interactions across the selected spatial boundary? Section 2.3 appropriately avoids claiming general equivalence to full execution, but a concrete example explaining the implemented semantics would help establish when selective execution is useful.

1 comment

Thank you for the detailed review. I particularly appreciated your engagement with the architecture and the specific questions you raised.

Your observation that the integration of observation-driven spatial selection with dependency closure may be the more distinctive aspect of LGE was especially useful. I also found your questions concerning cache construction and maintenance, execution semantics across spatial boundaries, and concrete demonstrations of compositionality valuable.

These are precisely the kinds of questions I was hoping to obtain feedback on when submitting this early exploration. They helped me better understand which aspects of the architecture require stronger foundations and where its potential contribution might actually lie.

Since submission, my thinking has evolved considerably, and I am now investigating a substantially different formulation. I do not believe the current manuscript adequately represents that direction, so I have decided to withdraw it rather than continue with a rebuttal.

I sincerely appreciate the time you spent understanding the architecture and providing such specific feedback. I intend to carry these questions and perspectives forward into future work.

Reviewer_9peQOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This is a brief technical document describing a C++ prototype of what the authors call a Layered Game Engine, essentially a rules-focused game engine similar to the kind of engines created from Lua in the recent past.

Critical strengths

None

Critical weaknesses

This is not an ICLR paper, but a brief technical document. There is no engagement with prior work, no description of the approach with sufficient detail to allow for replication, and no meaningful evaluation. The authors would be well served to read prior ICLR papers to better understand the expectations of an ICLR submission.

Questions for authors

N/A

1 comment

Thank you for reviewing my submission and for your feedback.

I understand your concerns regarding the manuscript's technical depth, engagement with prior work, reproducibility, and evaluation. Looking back, I recognize that the submission was considerably more exploratory than a mature research contribution, and that I had not sufficiently established its relationship to existing literature or demonstrated its significance.

The submission was partly intended as an opportunity to obtain feedback and better understand how the architectural idea relates to established research in the field. Your comments have helped me recognize the gap between the initial implementation and the level of development required for a meaningful contribution.

My thinking has since evolved substantially, and I am pursuing a different formulation of the architecture. Consequently, I have decided to withdraw the current submission rather than continue with a rebuttal.

I appreciate your direct feedback and the perspective it provided on the work's current limitations.

Reviewer_HPnNOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

abstraction for constructing and modifying interactive environments. prototype provides a basis for evaluating whether layered representations can make game environments more structured, composable, and amenable to automated reasoning and learning.

The paper presents Layered Game Engine (LGE), a proof-of-concept game engine for interactive environments where game-world behaviour is represented through rules with explicit dependencies, scopes, and execution stages. Also, world state, spatial organization, simulation, and visual processing are explicitly separated and a dependency graph determines execution orders.

The authors implement a prototype and evaluate a fixed active set of 64 entities while scaling the game world up to 100,000 entities. Cached selective execution reduces runtime cost, although performance remains substantially slower than simpler C++ object control code.

Critical strengths

The paper proposes an explicit computational representation rather than a conventional procedural engine architecture. The distinction between spatial organization, execution dependencies, and semantic rule scopes is conceptually interesting.

The authors also deserve credit for acknowledging limitations and avoiding unsupported performance-superiority claims. The deterministic execution checks and headless evaluation infrastructure can provide a useful basis for further experimentation.

Critical weaknesses

W1. The scientific novelty is insufficiently established

Explicit dependencies, rule scheduling, execution graphs, scoped computation, and data-oriented entity processing are well-established concepts. The proposed combination may be useful, but the paper does not convincingly demonstrate which property is difficult or impossible to achieve using entity-component systems, reactive programming, dependency-graph scheduling, or incremental computation mechanisms, for example. It currently reads more like a technical report on an architecture than demonstrated research advances.

W2. Selective execution is not shown to preserve correct world evolution

This can be the critical technical issue in the work. Selective execution is defined through spatial reachability and rule-dependency closure. However, it does not establish under what conditions excluding entities and rule executions preserves the relevant behaviour of the complete world.

The authors explicitly acknowledge that declared rule dependencies do not guarantee omitted work is independent. For an interactive world, entities outside the observation horizon may still influence future states through delayed interactions, global dynamics, or changes that eventually propagate into the active region.

W3. Lack of evidence such mechanisms can make game environments more structured, composable, and amenable to automated reasoning and learning

The level of detail on the implementation and the experiments performed seem to focus only on the system level and do not support this claimed goal of the work, which is key to its relevance to a venue like ICLR.

W4. Experimental comparisons are insufficiently

The existing are not feature-equivalent and the authors correctly acknowledge this, but it leaves limited evidence to assess if the proposed execution model has practical advantages over existing alternatives. Also, the benchmark uses a synthetic fixed active set, only five timing repetitions, and lacks sufficient hardware/build metadata.

Questions for authors
  • What is the genuinely novel mechanism proposed here? It should be compared then with equivalent implementations using an established framework. The comparison should demonstrate what the new representation enables, not merely describe structural differences.

  • Under what formal conditions does selective execution preserve the same relevant state transitions as full execution?

  • What is specifically enabled by LGE that cannot be achieved through an existing ECS with dependency-aware scheduling?

  • How much runtime is spent maintaining world-global structures despite the fixed active set?

  • Lastly, but key... How exactly does the architecture make it easier for an automated agent to inspect, modify, or generate executable worlds?

The ideas seem worth exploring, but to me it seems too preliminary and not ready for publication.

1 comment

Thank you for taking the time to review my submission.

I particularly appreciate your questions regarding selective execution semantics, world-global structures, and the conditions under which omitted computations can affect future world evolution. These are important issues that I had not sufficiently formalized in the current implementation.

Your comments regarding the relationship between LGE and existing ECS, dependency scheduling, and incremental computation are also valuable. They helped me recognize that distinguishing an architectural organization from a demonstrably new computational capability requires substantially more work.

This submission was exploratory for me, and part of my motivation was to obtain feedback from researchers familiar with the field. Since submitting, my understanding of the direction has evolved considerably, and I am now exploring a different formulation of the architecture.

I have therefore decided to withdraw the submission rather than continue with a rebuttal for a manuscript that no longer represents the direction I intend to pursue.

Thank you again for engaging with the ideas and identifying questions that I intend to carry forward into future work.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.