- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces a work aiming for addressing the degradatins in audio--visual question answeing task. In addition to proposing a framework, the paper also brings a benchmark on the extension of previous MUSIC-AVQA.
Critical strengths
The motivation is quite clear, addressing the degradation issues in audio--visual question answering.
Critical weaknesses
From my side, there are several critical weaknesses of this paper, including presetation, literature, model design, experiments. I DO NOT believe the current version is suitable for this submission. Here follow the details.
- Figure 1 c. I respectively do not think the generated icons by AI models help improve the presentation of the illustration. Even worse, readers may not know the exact meaning of them.
- Related work is not sufficient for supporting the current literature, which affects the completeness of the research in this domain, for example, AVQA, AVS, and robust learning methods. Here, I do not list specific ones as there are too many left.
- The presentation is not good. Here in Figure 2, one cannot see the details of the text as the front size is too small. Again, I do not believe the AI-generated figure clearly show the intention that the authors want to present, and even worse, leading to unclear misunderstanding to the paper.
- In section 3.1, the authors design several modules for different degradation. I clearly do not see how the authors combine them into the framework. In addition, how did the authors address the claimed 'question-dependent' issue?
- As for the dataset, why not select real degradation cases rather than transformation on the clean ones? I do not believe the transformation could represent the degradations probably.
- The experimental section is extremely limited, lacking sufficient experiments to support the research.
Questions for authors
See the weaknesses above.