- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes FedSR-LFT, a federated tensor factorization framework for missing data recovery in wireless sensor networks. It combines multi-indicator modeling, spatial and temporal regularization, and adaptive indicator weights. Experiments on two real-world datasets report improved recovery accuracy and resistance to gradient inversion attacks.
Critical strengths
- Effective integration of spatiotemporal information. Jointly modeling multiple sensing indicators with spatial and temporal regularization is well motivated. The reported improvements over existing federated baselines are substantial, particularly under high missing rates.
- Reasonable experimental coverage. The paper includes comparisons with eight baselines, parameter sensitivity studies, and gradient inversion experiments. These provide useful evidence of the proposed framework's potential.
Critical weaknesses
- Questionable privacy guarantees. The framework requires clients to obtain neighboring sensors' latent vectors for spatial regularization, while simultaneously claiming that these representations remain private. This information-sharing mechanism is not sufficiently explained. Moreover, the privacy analysis mainly argues that exact reconstruction is underdetermined, which does not establish a rigorous privacy guarantee. The DLG experiments alone are insufficient to support the broader privacy claims.
- Limited novelty and experimental generalization. The proposed components largely build upon established tensor factorization, graph regularization, and federated optimization techniques. The experiments cover only two datasets with randomly simulated missing values. More importantly, the contribution of adaptive indicator weighting is not independently demonstrated through a dedicated ablation. These limitations make it difficult to establish the broader significance of the proposed approach.
Questions for authors
Q1. How are neighboring sensors' latent vectors exchanged without violating the claimed privacy constraints? Can the authors clarify the threat model and provide stronger privacy guarantees beyond the DLG evaluation?
Q2. Can the authors provide a dedicated ablation of adaptive indicator weighting and evaluate the method under structured missingness, such as consecutive sensor failures? These results would help establish the individual contributions and practical robustness of the proposed framework.
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the constructive feedback. We have addressed each weakness (W) and question (Q) through the responses and improvements detailed below. The corresponding discussions will also be incorporated into the revised manuscript.
W1.1 & Q1.1 Regional communication mechanism. FedSR-LFT assumes mutual trust among sensors within each region. Each sensor obtains the latent factors needed for spatial regularization from other sensors in its region. These factors are shared and retained within the region, without being uploaded to the central server. Raw sensing data remain at their respective sensors. The server sends the shared matrices V and W and indicator weights to sensors, and receives V,W gradients and indicator-wise aggregated absolute errors. Thus, sensor latent factors remain private with respect to the central server while being available for spatial regularization within the trusted region.
W1.2 & Q1.2 Clarification of the threat model In the DLG-based attack, the attacker initializes dummy sensing data and sensor factors, computes dummy time and indicator gradients, and jointly minimizes their discrepancies from the uploaded gradients. It also matches the dummy data's total absolute error to the sum of uploaded total absolute errors. We agree that an underdetermined reconstruction problem does not establish a rigorous privacy guarantee, and our wording overstated this conclusion. We will revise the privacy claims to reflect the evidence from the evaluated attacks and clarify the threat model and attack settings. The appendix also evaluates clipping and Gaussian perturbation as additional protection: each time-gradient row is clipped to an L2 norm of at most C, then perturbed with independent Gaussian noise of standard deviation nm×C. Under the reported DLG setting, this increases attack reconstruction RMSE and MAE while maintaining competitive recovery accuracy. These results demonstrate an empirical privacy–accuracy trade-off.
W2.1 & Q2.1 Technical contributions and learnable indicator-loss weights. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify the technical contributions of FedSR-LFT, which lie in two key ideas: (1) FedSR-LFT introduces indicator factors to model a sensor–time–indicator tensor within a sensor-level federated framework, explicitly capturing cross-indicator dependencies, and accordingly develops learnable indicator-loss weights to balance indicator contributions during collaborative recovery. (2) We innovatively propose a regional spatiotemporal regularization strategy specifically designed for multi-indicator WSN data recovery under the proposed sensor-level federated tensor framework.
Furthermore, we have conducted an ablation experiment to assess the contribution of the learnable indicator-loss weights. We fixed the indicator-loss weights at${1,1,1}$ while keeping all other experimental settings unchanged. The results below report the overall RMSE and MAE under the two weight settings.
The learnable indicator-loss weights achieve lower overall RMSE and MAE in all four settings. These consistent improvements support the contribution of dynamically adjusting indicator-loss weights to recovery accuracy.
W2.2 & Q2.2 Evaluate the method under structured missingness. Starting from both datasets at$\rho=0.01$, we constructed two missingness patterns: (1) Contiguous temporal gap: removing training data within a contiguous window covering 50% of the time slots for each of 20% of sensor–indicator sequences; and (2) Sensor outage: removing training data for all indicators within a common contiguous window covering 50% of the time slots for each of 20% of sensors. The results below show that FedSR-LFT achieves lower RMSE and MAE than FLFL in all 24 comparisons, demonstrating that its performance advantage persists under both structured missingness patterns.