acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Coverage-Preserving Recasting and Hierarchical Visual Token Pruning for Efficient Multimodel LLMs

Abstract

Multimodal Large Language Models increasingly rely on long visual token sequences, making token pruning essential for reducing inference overhead. However, existing methods often suffer from accuracy degradation under stringent token budgets since they insufficiently account for the spatial distribution of visual evidence and the layer-dependent characteristics of multimodal representations. Therefore, we investigate the mechanisms underlying effective token reduction and find that visual token importance in the encoder should be assessed through complementary visual cues together with crop-wise allocation to avoid overlooking informative regions, while instruction-conditioned relevance becomes reliable as visual semantics mature across decoder layers. Motivated by these findings, we propose Layered-Crop Holistic Token Pruning called LCHTP, a training-free two-stage framework that integrates spatially aware selection with layer-sensitive compression. We further develop a theoretical formulation that links pruning-induced representation distortion to prediction stability and inference complexity, which provides a principled account of the accuracy–efficiency trade-off. Extensive evaluations across diverse MLLMs and benchmarks demonstrate that LCHTP consistently preserves strong predictive performance while delivering inference acceleration.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Large Vision-Language Models, Visual Token Pruning, Coverage-Preserving Recasting, Efficient Inference

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_5x2jOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes LCHTP, a training-free two-stage visual token pruning method for MLLMs. To preserve spatially distributed evidence, LCHTP selects tokens within each region before the LLM, merging the discarded tokens into the retained ones. It then prunes visual tokens at an intermediate decoder layer using the query averaged over the instruction.

Critical strengths

LCHTP outperforms existing methods consistently across image and video MLLMs over a wide range of token budgets. The advantage remains under aggressive pruning, where several methods degrade sharply.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Limited novelty of the analysis and the method.

  • The analysis restates findings reported in prior work. For the vision encoder, Fig. 2 of VScan already shows the shift from local to global attention across the encoder depth (Fig. 2). The benefit of distributing the budget over regions (Fig. 5) is also the premise of HiRED [A] and HoloV [B]. For the language decoder, the analysis in Fig. 3 differs little from that in prior work.
    • (Left) The positional bias of the attention in shallow layers is widely known, for example, from Fig. 3 of VScan [C].
    • (Middle) The logit lens analysis follows a protocol similar to that in Fig. 4 of VScan [C].
    • (Right) The difference between the two queries looks marginal.
  • The method combines existing components with minor modifications. It adopts the budget allocation over windows from HoloV and the two-stage design from VScan [C].
  • The two-stage schedule keeps more tokens in the early layers of the LLM and fewer in the deeper layers, favoring the method over the single-stage baselines. Thus, the comparison should include recent two-stage methods such as VScan [C], Nüwa [D], and VisionTrim [E].

W2. Assumptions and error terms.

  • The theoretical analysis rests on several assumptions and bounds the logit perturbation through error terms that accumulate over the two pruning stages. This paper, however, reports no measured value for these constants and error terms, leaving unclear whether the assumptions hold and whether the error terms are small enough for the bounds to be informative in actual MLLMs. Reporting measurable quantities would make the theoretical analysis more convincing. For example,
    • Eq. (80) states that the prediction is preserved when the logit margin of the unpruned model exceeds twice the bound on the logit perturbation. Both the margin m(x,T)\mathfrak{m}(x,T) and the actual perturbation ∥z−z^∥∞\|z-\hat z\|_\infty are directly measurable.
    • The total discarded influence in Eq. (59) is bounded by ϵ11(K1)+2K1ξ1\epsilon_{11}(K_1)+2K_1\xi_1, which is informative only when ξ1<1/(2K1)\xi_1<1/(2K_1), since the influence weights sum to one.

[A] HiRED: Attention-Guided Token Dropping for Efficient Inference of High-Resolution Vision-Language Models, AAAI 2025
[B] Don't Just Chase "Highlighted Tokens" in MLLMs: Revisiting Visual Holistic Context Retention, NeurIPS 2025
[C] VScan: Rethinking Visual Token Reduction for Efficient Large Vision-Language Models, TMLR 2026
[D] Nüwa: Mending the Spatial Integrity Torn by VLM Token Pruning, ICLR 2026
[E] VisionTrim: Unified Vision Token Compression for Training-Free MLLM Acceleration, ICLR 2026

Questions for authors

Please see weaknesses.

Reviewer_2qAoOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
4
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes LCHTP, a training-free method for reducing visual tokens in multimodal language models. Before the language model, it selects tokens within spatial regions using shallow attention, deep attention, and feature diversity, then merges discarded information into retained tokens with text-dependent weights. It further prunes tokens at an intermediate decoder layer using an instruction-mean query.

Experiments cover several image and video models, with favorable performance retention and measured inference speedups. The paper also presents an analysis connecting representation distortion, prediction stability, and computational cost.

Critical strengths
  1. The method addresses a practical problem without additional training. Combining spatially distributed selection with later instruction-guided pruning provides a useful way to reduce computation while retaining visual evidence.

  2. Performance gains are consistent across several architectures. At the most restrictive reported image budgets, normalized average performance retention reaches about 96% on LLaVA-1.5, LLaVA-NeXT, and Qwen2.5-VL, exceeding the strongest listed comparators by 0.9 to 1.8 percentage points. Video results provide further evidence of applicability.

  3. The efficiency gains are measured in actual inference. In the 64-token setting of Table 1, total runtime improves by about 1.33 times and prefill by about 1.54 times relative to the corresponding full-model reference. These results support the practical value of the method.

  4. The empirical analyses help explain the design. The paraphrase-consistency comparison and evidence-coverage analysis provide useful evidence for averaging instruction queries and protecting spatial regions. These observations make the paper informative beyond its final benchmark scores.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The incremental contribution needs clearer evidence. VScan already discussed in the appendix, combines local and global visual selection, token merging, and intermediate decoder pruning, but is absent from the experiments. FEATHER [2] also combines early spatial coverage with later pruning, while SCOPE [3] jointly models saliency and coverage. The latter two are not discussed. These connections narrow the novelty to the specific scoring, recasting weights, and query aggregation used here.

  2. The component studies do not fully establish the benefit of those modifications. The parameter sweeps exclude removing text weighting or the diversity term, and improved query consistency does not by itself establish improved answer quality. Focused comparisons with ordinary similarity merging and a last-token query would clarify the source of the gains.

  3. The theoretical guarantee has an unresolved step. Eqs. (72) to (74) bound a weighted value-aggregation error, but Eq. (138) uses this bound for the difference between full hidden sequences. That implication requires justification. The score-calibration and semantic-stabilization assumptions also remain unverified. These issues limit the claimed prediction guarantee, although they do not invalidate the reported empirical results.

  4. Some implementation details affect interpretation of the results. It is unclear whether internal-pruning baseline budgets refer to final or layer-average token counts, and the timing protocol and attention backend are underspecified. The method also relies on a CLS-based score without explaining its replacement in Qwen2.5-VL, whose visual encoder has no CLS token. These omissions make the efficiency and cross-model results harder to reproduce.

  5. The theoretical part in the appendix is extremely long, with 100+ equations. Is it necessary? Is it AI generated? Can the authors provide a shorter and simpler theoretical derivations?

Questions for authors
  1. How does LCHTP compare with VScan under the same evaluation protocol and comparable computational budgets? This would help establish the value of the specific changes proposed here.

  2. Can you quantify the task-level gains from text-weighted recasting and the instruction-mean query relative to ordinary similarity merging and a last-token query at a restrictive budget? A focused comparison on representative tasks would be sufficient.

  3. What justifies using the aggregation-error bound in Eq. (74) as a hidden-sequence error bound in Eq. (138)? If additional assumptions are needed, how do they restrict the prediction-preservation claim?

  4. What replaces the CLS-based score for Qwen2.5-VL, and how are token budgets and timing measured consistently across methods?

1 comment

There seems no rebuttal submitted. Thus, I will keep my original rating.

Reviewer_M8RhOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes LCHTP, a training-free two-stage visual token pruning method. Based on an analysis of how attention evolves in the encoder/decoder and of missed salient evidence, Stage 1 fuses three signals before the LLM (local attention, global [CLS] attention, and diversity), selects tokens with per-crop quotas, and recasts discarded tokens into retained ones; Stage 2 prunes globally at the middle decoder layers using the instruction-averaged query, with the budget unified by the layer-average token load. The authors also provide a stability theorem based on Lipschitz propagation and the logit margin. Experiments cover LLaVA-1.5/NeXT, Qwen2.5-VL and Video-LLaVA, with relative performance holding up well at high pruning ratios (96.0% on LLaVA-NeXT with 320 tokens).

Critical strengths

Fairly comprehensive evaluation: About ten image benchmarks (VQAv2, GQA, MMBench/CN, MME, POPE, VizWiz, SQA, TextVQA, MM-Vet) plus two video benchmarks, against 11 baselines; LLaVA-NeXT-7B with 320 tokens has the highest average relative performance (96.0%), and Video-LLaVA at 50% retention exceeds both the unpruned model and all compared methods. Intuitive design: Fig. 5 shows that 46.4% of critical-evidence crops are not among the top 8 by saliency, and that a minimum per-crop quota markedly reduces the miss rate, providing empirical grounding for crop-level quotas; in actual latency, with 64 tokens retained on LLaVA-1.5-7B LCHTP takes 0.1090 s, below FastV's 0.1180 s and HiRED's 0.1302 s, with higher Acc./F1 (84.11/85.00) than both.

Critical weaknesses

Limited novelty, small gains, and no component-level validation of key designs. The method combines existing components (encoder-attention/diversity scoring, partition-wise budgets, middle-layer text-guided pruning, token recasting). In Table 2, 96.0% is only 0.9–1.4 points above HiRED (95.1%), FasterVLM (94.8%) and HoloV (94.6%), and it is best on only six of nine benchmarks (TextVQA 58.4 is below SparseVLM's 60.1 and HiRED's 59.8, and 6.4 below the unpruned 64.8; SQA and VQAv2 are also slightly below FastV and HiRED). The crop-number ablation in Table 4 shows very small differences (e.g., 90.021–90.306 at 88.9% pruning), and neither the main text nor the appendix contains accuracy ablations of the three scoring signals, the recasting, or the second stage (only the Fig. 1 crop-wise vs. global ranking comparison, hyperparameter sensitivity, and analysis figures). In Table 1, LCHTP's prefill (192 tokens: 51.89 ms; 64 tokens: 46.6 ms) is slower than FastV (42.66/35.6 ms) and HiRED (40.09/33.5 ms); its latency advantage lies mainly in overall latency (at 192 tokens, 0.1255 s vs. HiRED's 0.1273 s, a gap of only 1.4%), and no variance is reported.

Questions for authors

Please provide accuracy–latency/FLOPs curves against FastV, VisionZip, DART, HoloV and HiRED under the same code path, and break down LCHTP's extra overhead (scoring, recasting, crop-level top-k).

Is the budget alignment fair to the baselines? Please give a control with a fixed B tokens at every layer.

Please add ablations of the three signals, the recasting, and the second stage; were the hyperparameters selected on data independent of the test sets?

For vision encoders without [CLS] (e.g., Qwen2.5-VL), how is the global relevance s_glob computed?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.