- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper focuses on the task of traffic expansion flow forecasting, focusing on the more challenging few-shot and zero-shot Settings. For this task, the authors propose SemProtoST. This method uses sensor metadata to construct representations that can be generalized to unseen nodes, and models traffic patterns through dual spatio-temporal pattern prototypes and cross-attention query shared prototypes, and enhances the generalization ability to unseen nodes with semantic consistency constraints. In the few-shot adaptation stage, knowledge distillation is used to alleviate the forgetting of existing nodes when adapting new nodes. Compared with multi-class prediction and expansion methods on four traffic datasets including ESD, EGBA, EGLA and ECA, the average performance of the proposed method in unseen node is improved under few-shot and zero-shot Settings.
Critical strengths
- This paper focuses on few-shot and zero-shot Traffic Expansion Flow Forecasting tasks, points out the forgetting problem in fixed node ID representation and few-shot adaptation, and performs targeted metadata representation and knowledge distillation to solve it. It has promoted the development of this field to a certain extent.
- This paper conducts a large number of experiments on four real-world datasets to compare with a variety of baselines, covering fewshot and zero-shot Settings, and exploring different traffic expansion scenarios, with a relatively comprehensive experimental design.
Critical weaknesses
- This paper only reports the fixed loss-weight settings, but lacks corresponding experiments on the parameter sensitivity of the three key loss-weight hyperparameters, λortho, λsem and λdistill. This results in insufficient basis for weight selection and an inability to reflect the impact of different values on the model performance.
- Although the paper emphasizes its application scenario of rapid prediction after the new sensor is put into use, it did not provide specific comparisons with other representative baselines in terms of efficiency indicators such as actual inference delay, throughput, and memory usage to intuitively demonstrate the efficiency advantage.
Questions for authors
- Could the authors conduct experiments on the sensitivity of the three Loss weight hyperparameters with respect to the supplementary parameters of the dataset to illustrate the impact of different values?
- Could the authors provide efficiency experiments comparing the actual reasoning delay, throughput, and memory usage of SemProtoST with representative baselines on the corresponding datasets?
- The paper reports the average improvement results of Overall metrics and under the settings of few-shot and zero-shot learning, but does not clearly state the aggregation formula of Overall, nor does it clarify what exactly the baseline, metrics, and average method of data sets being compared for the average improvement are. Could the authors explain this and clarify it in the paper?
- The value of λortho is 1000, which is significantly different from the other weight scales. Could the author explain the reason for this?
Response to Reviewer G4t6
Dear Reviewer G4t6,
We sincerely thank the reviewer for the insightful comments and constructive suggestions. Below, we provide a point-by-point response to each concern.
Response to W1/Q1:
We have added MoGERNN [1], an inductive traffic predictor supporting newly added sensors without retraining, and UniST [2], a universal spatio-temporal model with zero-shot generalization across scenarios. We evaluate both methods on our zero-shot TEFF task.
OOM denotes that the models incur out-of-memory issue even when we set batch size to 1.
Compared with these two methods, SemProtoST offers the following advantages:
Higher accuracy on both unseen and seen sensors. SemProtoST achieves the lowest MAE and RMSE for Unseen, Seen, and Overall in every available comparison. Against the better-performing available baseline among these two methods for each dataset and metric, unseen node MAE decreases by 14.58%–26.41% and RMSE by 9.83%–23.79%. The corresponding unweighted mean reductions across the four datasets are 18.55% and 14.65%, respectively.
Metadata-conditioned transfer tailored to new sensors. MoGERNN [1] transfers information through graph aggregation, while UniST [2] learns transferable knowledge through spatio-temporal pretraining and knowledge-guided prompting. SemProtoST explicitly uses sensor metadata to query shared spatial prototypes and temporal representations to query a separate temporal prototype bank. This design connects sensor characteristics with reusable traffic patterns without requiring observations from new sensors for model training or adaptation.
Deployment without an explicit sensor graph. SemProtoST constructs node representations from metadata and composes shared prototypes without constructing or updating a sensor graph, simplifying the integration of newly deployed sensors when graph information is unavailable. On ECA, with 8,600 sensors, SemProtoST completes the experiment, whereas MoGERNN encounters OOM under the tested configuration. This demonstrates feasibility at this network size.
References
[1] Zhou, Qishen, et al. "MoGERNN: An inductive traffic predictor for unobserved locations." Transportation Research Part C: Emerging Technologies 174 (2025): 105080.
[2] Yuan, Yuan, et al. "Unist: A prompt-empowered universal model for urban spatio-temporal prediction." SIGKDD, 2024.