- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a dual-path functional vector framework for interpretable and controllable emotion generation in large language models. The method combines mean difference (MD) and singular value decomposition (SVD) to extract emotion-related features from hidden representations and model parameters, respectively. A token-level adaptive injection strategy is introduced to enable fine-grained emotion control. The paper also incorporates a text-to-speech evaluation framework to assess cross-modal emotion consistency. Experiments on the ED and ESConv datasets, including comparisons with existing baselines and ablation studies, demonstrate improvements in emotion generation performance across text- and speech-level metrics.
Critical strengths
- The paper introduces a dual-path functional vector framework with token-level adaptive emotion control.
- The paper evaluates the method on two datasets with comprehensive experiments and ablation studies.
Critical weaknesses
-
The causal relationship between the underlying assumptions and the experimental conclusions is not sufficiently clear in some parts of the paper.
-
Some of the mathematical formulations and methodological descriptions could be further refined to improve clarity and rigor.
Questions for authors
-
MD Path – Potential Confounding Factors: The difference between the mean representations does not necessarily reflect the distinction between emotional and non-emotional features. Instead, it may be largely influenced by confounding factors such as dialogue topics, linguistic styles, and contextual differences. The experimental design does not adequately disentangle emotion-specific differences from these potential confounding factors.
-
MD Path – Justification of the Weighting Coefficients: Why are the weights for the core and extended emotion representations set to 0.7 and 0.3, respectively? Have the authors conducted experiments with other weighting coefficients to evaluate the sensitivity of the method to these hyperparameters?
-
SVD Path – Optimization Procedure: What optimization method is used to solve the following rank-constrained minimization problem?
\underset{\operatorname{rank}(\widehat W)\le r}{\arg\min} \left\|WX_{\text{in}}-\widehat WX_{\text{in}}\right\|_F^2$$ The paper does not clearly specify the optimization algorithm or the implementation details. -
SVD Path – Validity of Emotion-Related Directions: Why should the principal activation directions identified by SVD necessarily correspond to emotion-related directions? Fundamentally, SVD identifies the directions that capture the largest amount of energy in the output activations. These directions may contain entangled features associated with multiple factors rather than emotion-specific information. The paper does not sufficiently justify this assumption.
-
SVD Path – Omission of Singular Values: Why does the construction of the final functional vector only incorporate the left and right singular vectors while ignoring the corresponding singular values? Since singular values characterize the strength of the transformations along different directions, the rationale for excluding them requires further clarification.
-
SVD Path – Dimensional Consistency: The construction of raises concerns regarding dimensional consistency. Specifically, and have dimensions and , respectively, which do not directly yield a single -dimensional vector. However, the subsequent fusion and injection operations require a vector whose dimensionality is compatible with the model's hidden representations. The authors should clarify how these singular vector sets are combined, aggregated, and mapped to the required dimensionality.
-
Incorrect Appendix Reference: Section 3 contains an unresolved appendix reference (“Appendix ??”), which should be corrected.
-
Baseline – Training Configuration of Llama-3.1: It is unclear whether the Llama-3.1 baseline was fully fine-tuned on the two evaluation datasets (ED and ESConv) or evaluated directly using its original instruction-tuned weights. The authors should clarify the training and fine-tuning configurations of the baseline to ensure a fair comparison with the proposed method.
I have already updated the revisions.