acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

How to Crack the Black Box of Emotion Generation? Interpretable Dual-Path Function Vectors for Token-Level Control

Abstract

Existing empathetic dialogue generation methods face limitations in the fine-grained control and cross-modal transfer of emotion expression, while generally lacking interpretability into the models’ internal emotion generation mechanisms. We propose an interpretable dual-path emotional functional vector framework, integrated with a token-level adaptive injection strategy, to achieve transparent and controllable empathetic dialogue generation. Specifically, we design a mean difference pathway to extract semantic emotional features and a singular value decomposition pathway to extract parameter-structural emotion features, achieving dual-path fusion via adaptive weights. The token-level strategy dynamically assigns regulation weights based on an attention mechanism, matching the differential contributions of different words in emotional transmission. Additionally, we construct a text-to-speech cross-modal evaluation system to verify the consistency of emotional information across multimodal scenarios.Experimental results on the ED and ESConv datasets demonstrate that the proposed method significantly outperforms all existing state-of-the-art baselines. When using Llama-3.1 as the backbone model, we achieve a 18.22% improvement in Acc2 and a 6.02% improvement in F_Bert. Our work provides an interpretable and efficient solution for controllable emotion generation in LLMs.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Emotion Vectors, Dual-Path Function Vectors, Token-Level Control

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_CCvQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a dual-path functional vector framework for interpretable and controllable emotion generation in large language models. The method combines mean difference (MD) and singular value decomposition (SVD) to extract emotion-related features from hidden representations and model parameters, respectively. A token-level adaptive injection strategy is introduced to enable fine-grained emotion control. The paper also incorporates a text-to-speech evaluation framework to assess cross-modal emotion consistency. Experiments on the ED and ESConv datasets, including comparisons with existing baselines and ablation studies, demonstrate improvements in emotion generation performance across text- and speech-level metrics.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper introduces a dual-path functional vector framework with token-level adaptive emotion control.
  2. The paper evaluates the method on two datasets with comprehensive experiments and ablation studies.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The causal relationship between the underlying assumptions and the experimental conclusions is not sufficiently clear in some parts of the paper.

  2. Some of the mathematical formulations and methodological descriptions could be further refined to improve clarity and rigor.

Questions for authors
  1. MD Path – Potential Confounding Factors: The difference between the mean representations does not necessarily reflect the distinction between emotional and non-emotional features. Instead, it may be largely influenced by confounding factors such as dialogue topics, linguistic styles, and contextual differences. The experimental design does not adequately disentangle emotion-specific differences from these potential confounding factors.

  2. MD Path – Justification of the Weighting Coefficients: Why are the weights for the core and extended emotion representations set to 0.7 and 0.3, respectively? Have the authors conducted experiments with other weighting coefficients to evaluate the sensitivity of the method to these hyperparameters?

  3. SVD Path – Optimization Procedure: What optimization method is used to solve the following rank-constrained minimization problem?

    \underset{\operatorname{rank}(\widehat W)\le r}{\arg\min} \left\|WX_{\text{in}}-\widehat WX_{\text{in}}\right\|_F^2$$ The paper does not clearly specify the optimization algorithm or the implementation details.
  4. SVD Path – Validity of Emotion-Related Directions: Why should the principal activation directions identified by SVD necessarily correspond to emotion-related directions? Fundamentally, SVD identifies the directions that capture the largest amount of energy in the output activations. These directions may contain entangled features associated with multiple factors rather than emotion-specific information. The paper does not sufficiently justify this assumption.

  5. SVD Path – Omission of Singular Values: Why does the construction of the final functional vector only incorporate the left and right singular vectors while ignoring the corresponding singular values? Since singular values characterize the strength of the transformations along different directions, the rationale for excluding them requires further clarification.

  6. SVD Path – Dimensional Consistency: The construction of VSVDV_{SVD} raises concerns regarding dimensional consistency. Specifically, Uemo-keyU_{\text{emo-key}} and Vemo-keyV_{\text{emo-key}} have dimensions dout×kd_{\text{out}}\times k and din×kd_{\text{in}}\times k, respectively, which do not directly yield a single doutd_{\text{out}}-dimensional vector. However, the subsequent fusion and injection operations require a vector whose dimensionality is compatible with the model's hidden representations. The authors should clarify how these singular vector sets are combined, aggregated, and mapped to the required dimensionality.

  7. Incorrect Appendix Reference: Section 3 contains an unresolved appendix reference (“Appendix ??”), which should be corrected.

  8. Baseline – Training Configuration of Llama-3.1: It is unclear whether the Llama-3.1 baseline was fully fine-tuned on the two evaluation datasets (ED and ESConv) or evaluated directly using its original instruction-tuned weights. The authors should clarify the training and fine-tuning configurations of the baseline to ensure a fair comparison with the proposed method.

Reviewer_psRROpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes methods for generating text and speech that incorporate emotion in dialogue systems. One method is the mean-difference emotion representation, and the second method involves decomposing a neural network's weights for emotion representation using SVD. Furthermore, the paper proposes token-level emotion injection. Experiments were conducted using ED and ESConv to verify the effectiveness of these methods.

Critical strengths
  1. Combining representation-level and parameter-level features for emotion control is an interesting approach.

  2. Token-level adaptive injection provides a potentially useful alternative to uniform vector injection.

  3. The experiments include multiple baselines, ablation studies, and both text- and speech-level evaluations.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The focus is on “Sentiment,” not “emotion.” This is confusing and should be clearly stated.
  2. In section 3, there are theorems, but a theorem requires a proof.
  3. “Dynamic weighting” is not actually dynamic. It appears to simply involve tuning using a standard development set.
  4. It is unclear what MD and SVD represent. A specific analysis of MD and SVD is necessary.
  5. The explanation regarding human evaluation is unclear. In particular, was the speech emotion verified via a hearing test?
Questions for authors
  1. Could you clarify how the paper distinguishes sentiment from emotion and state explicitly which of the two the study focuses on?
  2. Could you provide a proof of the stated theorem and specify the assumptions it relies on?
  3. What makes the weighting scheme “dynamic”? Are the weights tuned on a standard development set and then held fixed at inference, or do they adapt to individual inputs at inference time?
  4. What do MD and SVD represent in this study? Could you explain how each is computed and analyze what each reveals about the results?
  5. Could you describe the human evaluation protocol in more detail? In particular, did listeners hear the audio and judge whether it conveyed the intended emotion?
Reviewer_ZM9dOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
4(+1)
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2(+1)
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes an interpretable dual-path emotion function vector framework for empathetic dialogue generation, aiming to improve the controllability and fine-grained regulation of emotional expression in large language models. Specifically, the method extracts emotion semantic features from hidden representations via mean difference, and identifies structural features related to emotional expression from model parameters using singular value decomposition, then constructs a unified emotion function vector through weighted fusion. In addition, it designs a token-level adaptive injection strategy based on attention mechanisms to dynamically regulate the intensity of emotional intervention across different tokens, and further introduces a text-to-speech cross-modal evaluation framework. Experimental results report that the framework outperforms the compared baseline models on multiple metrics. However, the paper still has issues in the mathematical definition of the core method, the justification of interpretability, and the reproducibility of experiments, and the current evidence is insufficient to fully support its main conclusions.

Critical strengths
  1. Studying emotion control from the perspective of internal model representations is a valuable direction. Most existing research on empathetic dialogue generation focuses on emotion understanding and generation quality, while discussion of the model's internal emotion representations and control mechanisms remains insufficient. The authors achieve controllable emotion generation by extracting and intervening on emotion function vectors, which helps clarify the relationship between the internal emotion representations and generation behavior of large language models.
  2. The research motivation is relatively clear, and it balances emotional expression with the preservation of general capabilities. The authors use the MD path to extract emotion semantic features and introduce a joint scoring mechanism on the SVD path that combines emotion relevance and general capability preservation to select directions more suitable for emotion control. This shows that the authors have paid attention to the performance trade-off issue in model control.
  3. The ablation experiments cover MD, SVD, injection methods, and fusion methods, and correspond well to the design of the core method. The authors analyze the performance changes after removing MD, SVD, and the token-level injection module, and also compare different fusion approaches and injection strategies. They provide a preliminary evaluation of the contribution of each module, and the experiments can support the effectiveness of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The paper does not explain the SVD path clearly enough. It does not specify how the selected singular vectors are aggregated, how they are mapped to the residual space, or how vector normalization and sign ambiguity are handled. The SVD path and the MD path produce outputs in different forms, yet Equation (5) directly takes a weighted sum of the two. This makes the core method hard to understand and reproduce.
  2. Theorem 1 lacks sufficient theoretical grounding. The theorem claims that there exists a unique optimal fusion weight that makes the fused result strictly better than either path alone. However, the paper neither defines a mathematical objective for emotion regulation performance nor gives conditions that guarantee uniqueness and strict improvement. For example, when the two paths produce the same vector, the fused result does not change with the weight. As currently stated, the theoretical conclusion is not well supported.
  3. The conclusion of Theorem 2 is too broad and lacks the necessary definitions and argumentation. The theorem holds that core emotion words always contribute more than modifiers and function words, and that this relationship remains stable across emotion types. However, the paper does not define how to measure the emotion contribution of a token, nor does it discuss cases such as negation and contrast that may alter emotional expression. The conclusion is therefore not sufficiently supported at present.
  4. The evaluation metrics and the human evaluation protocol are not sufficiently explained. Although the paper reports multiple text, speech, and human evaluation metrics, the definitions and calculation methods of some metrics are unclear. The human evaluation also lacks information such as sample size, number of annotators, scoring criteria, and consistency analysis. These omissions make it difficult to judge the reliability of the main experimental results.
  5. The XTTS module lacks key implementation details. Section 4.3 not only uses XTTS to convert text to speech but also mentions enhancing emotion embeddings and fine-tuning emotion alignment parameters. However, the paper does not specify which modules were modified or provide the corresponding training data and optimization objectives. This makes the cross-modal part difficult to reproduce.
  6. The relationship between the method and existing work needs further clarification. CAA already constructs control directions from differences in residual activations between positive and negative samples, and Gu et al. (ACL 2025) already use low-rank projections of task-related and general capabilities to select singular vectors via importance differences. The MD path and Equations (2)–(4) in this paper are relatively close to these methods. The authors need to explain the technical differences more clearly and provide corresponding comparisons to support the novelty of the method.
  7. There is a lack of direct validation of what the emotion function vectors represent. When low-rank approximation is performed on activations from emotion corpora, the retained principal directions of variation may also reflect non-emotional factors such as topic and sentence structure. The paper has not yet demonstrated that these directions indeed correspond to emotion features, nor does it provide evidence that the MD and SVD paths capture the claimed semantic and structural information, respectively. The current experiments are therefore insufficient to support the interpretability claims.
  8. The dialogue example in Figure 2 does not match the context. The user expresses conflict with their father and fear of going home for the holidays, but the system response in the figure is a congratulatory expression, which clearly does not fit the current dialogue situation. The authors should clarify whether this response is an actual generated result and explain its relationship to the empathetic dialogue generation task.
Questions for authors
  1. On the construction of SVD function vectors and dimension matching. In Equations (4)–(7), what is the specific shape of VSVDV_{\mathrm{SVD}}? How are the selected left and right singular vectors aggregated and converted into a vector with the same dimension as the residual hidden states, so that they can be used for dual-path fusion and token-level injection?
  2. On the theoretical basis of the two theorems. What are the complete assumptions and proofs of Theorem 1 and Theorem 2? In particular, how does Theorem 1 define the optimization objective for emotion regulation performance and guarantee the uniqueness of the optimal fusion weight? How does Theorem 2 define and measure the emotion contribution of different tokens?
  3. On the calculation of token-level weights. Along which dimension is the Softmax in Equation (6) computed? During autoregressive decoding, how are the token weights calculated and updated? Is this implementation consistent with the one used in the experimental evaluation?
  4. On the reproducibility of the experimental evaluation. Could the authors supplement the definitions and calculation methods of the main evaluation metrics, as well as the sample size, scoring criteria, and inter-annotator agreement of the human evaluation? In addition, do all methods in the speech evaluation use the same TTS model and synthesis conditions to ensure a fair comparison?
1 comment

I have already updated the revisions.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.