- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper examines how the entry of AI-generated books reshapes the market for self-published genre fiction, shifting attention from individual books’ quality or sales to market dilution and outcomes for human authors. Combining full-text AI detection for 14,419 titles with daily sales and ranking data from a publisher panel, it finds that books with substantial detected AI content sell less individually but increasingly occupy top-ranking positions. Within the observed sample, the number of selling titles grows faster than revenue, while revenue per title also declines among books with no detected AI text, particularly in genres with greater AI penetration. These observational findings provide evidence relevant to the market-dilution question raised in Kadrey v. Meta, although they do not establish a causal effect of AI entry on human authors’ earnings.
Critical strengths
S1: The paper examines a fresh question on market-level consequences of AI-generated books, with clear relevance to copyright disputes and platform governance.
S2: Broad empirical coverage. The analyses connect AI diffusion, ranking dynamics, per-title revenue, author output, and textual overlap, providing complementary perspectives on market changes.
S3: The authors explicitly characterize the findings as associational and recognize that increased variety and lower prices may benefit consumers, leaving the net welfare effect uncertain.
Critical weaknesses
W1: The zero-price imputation is not rational. Section 2.1 replaces missing or non-positive prices with the title’s median valid launch-window price. However, zero prices may represent genuine free promotions rather than missing data. If free downloads are included in recorded unit sales, this procedure would assign positive revenue to transactions that generated none, potentially biasing revenue rankings and comparisons across AI-content groups. The authors should report the prevalence of zero-price observations, and test robustness to retaining valid zero prices.
W2: The growth comparison might not reflect the market dilution. Because the sample includes only titles released from 2023 onward, later quarters accumulate additional publication cohorts. Older titles may continue to count as selling books even as their revenue declines. Thus, the 19.2-fold increase in selling titles versus 8.9-fold revenue growth may partly reflect cohort accumulation and book-age effects rather than AI-driven competition.
W3: Figure 2D appears to contradict the displacement narrative. The caption and Section 3.2 state that fewer no-AI bestsellers remain in the Top-25 each quarter. However, the retention curve in Figure 2D appears to dip early and then rise steadily, ending above its starting level. Read at face value, incumbent no-AI books became more entrenched in the top ranks toward the end of the period, not less. The authors should reconcile the text with the figure, or explain why rising retention is still consistent with displacement.
W4: Limited reproducibility. The code has not been released, making it difficult to verify the data-processing pipeline, metric construction, and robustness analyses. Also, given the proprietary sales data, releasing the analysis code and a suitably anonymized or synthetic example dataset would substantially improve transparency and reproducibility.
Questions for authors
Please address the points that directly correspond to the concerns raised in the Weaknesses section. No new experiments are required. I would consider a higher rating if the authors could clarify these.
2 comments
I thank the authors for their clarification. The paper’s large-scale data analysis quantifies the impact of AI adoption on the book market and draws attention to its implications. However, I still find the paper’s contribution limited and believe it may be a better fit for a conference such as SIGMETRICS or IMC. I therefore lean toward keeping my original score.
Response to your 9AgT comments
Thanks for you review.
Criticism W1: We did not have any data points in our panel where the quantity was nonzero but it had a recorded price of 0 dollars. However there were very few (0.39%) missing post-release days which didn’t have any quantity or price. We didn’t change their quantity and kept it at 0 but used the title’s median valid price as a fallback when filling the price field. Since revenue is quantity X price, the days with imputed price contributed 0 dollars and the results are unchanged.
Criticism W2 : The 19.2X and 8.9X numbers are quarterly (Fig.3A). All comparisons in Fig 3B-3D rely on release cohorts over the same launch window. This includes any preorders + sales from day 1 to day 90. From 2023 to 2025 cohort the revenue / selling title with no detected AI text dropped from 23877 USD to 19739 USD which is 17.3%. Because based on our design each title can only contribute to its own release cohort the concern about older titles carrying over is not relevant here.
Criticism W3: The way we calculate Top25 depends on how many of its previous titles are retained and how many new titles enter. As mentioned in Section 3.2 (lines 212–215), the % of last quarter’s no-AI books that stayed in the Top 25 moved from 44.1% to 28.2% to 62.5%. But if we look carefully we see that by 2026 Q1 books having substantial AI text made up for 30.7% of entrants into the quarterly Top25 sets. This is a very large increase from the first comparable quarter which was only 3.3%. This also means that no-AI books held fewer spots overall. Infact, Fig 2B shows that share of no-AI book declined from 90.7% to 59.6% while books with substantial AI text increased from 1.2% to 23.3% of the spots. We will make this clearer in camera ready.
We present a simple example
Criticism W4 : ICLR does not strictly require authors to release code at the time of submission. Our data is huge in GBs and sharing it without due diligence and care might compromise anonymity. We will release all code, scripts and anonymized data for reproducibility upon paper acceptance.
We hope our responses have addressed your concerns. We would really appreciate an increase in overall rating and soundness