- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper discusses property-conditioned generators for scientific inverse design like material design. The authors claim to formalize controllability for tensor-valued targets by composing a generator with an independently specified scientific evaluator and qoutienting physical SO(3) symmetry. They experimentally evaluated their method comparing some baselines like EATGNN and GMTNet and show merits of their method.
Critical strengths
(S1) Control or guidance of generative modeling is important and interesting problem. Especially, considering the symmetry could be a starting point of the discussion. Also, the problem setting is understandable.
(S2) Qoutienting physical symmetry is straightforward and easy to understand.
Critical weaknesses
(W1) For me, the organization of paper is not clean. As a result, it is difficult to catch the motivation (e.g. example of target problems), contribution, and novelty.Thus, I struggle to understand the main concepts of this paper.
(W2) It would be quite appreciated if authors would clarify the novelty of the analytical contribution. In particular, to clarify the novelty and contribution of Theorem 1 might be important.
(W3) The figures are not so effectively used. For example, non-expert readers (like me) struggle to catch the main concept of this work from Figure 1. It would be better to reconsider the organization of components of Figure 1.
(W4) Experimental evidence is somehow limited.
(W5) Related to (W1), some sentences are not easy to read. For example, many sentences have specific numbers like numbers of dataset or accuracy. Personally, I think that kind of information is too detailed and reduces the readability.
Questions for authors
(Q1) Please explain again the motivation (e.g. target problem), main concept, and contribution in language that is easy to understand even for broad ML readers.
(Q2) Please reconsider the organization of this paper and refine the figures to clarify the concept of this work.
(Q3) Could you discuss the novelty of the analytical contribution (in particular Theorem 1) and physical meaning of the theorem. Since my understanding might be limited, I cannot judge how valuable and interesting the discussion in this work is.
I thank the authors for their effort to address my comments and concerns. I acknowledge the contribution of the decomposition and the added attribution of generation errors. But I still found this to be “one step away” from a real contribution. To my understanding, the physical-side error cannot be improved directly, since it comes from a real physical solver, so it would be super interesting if one could use this signal to guide better generator selection. My concern about case generalization also remains. Although the authors claim their formulation is case-irrelevant, I still recommend including another real case (even a very simple one) when aiming for an ML conference, especially considering the error decomposition can be totally different from case to case (the strong anisotropy shows that the case in the manuscript may be an extreme case for inverse design; please correct me if I’m wrong). Based on the above points, I don’t think the authors would make substantial improvements that may change my opinion in the discussion stage, and the score would remain (=2).