- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper tries to solve a problem, out-of-sight world evolution. When a subject is out of the camera view, it should still take part in and respond to the changes of the world. The paper proposes a full-stack pipeline spanning dataset curation, model architecture design, model training, and benchmark evaluation. SeerWorld mainly consists of a vision-language model (Qwen3.8-27B) and an autoregressive video generation model (LTX-2.5). The VLM serves to maintain world memory and infer plausible actions of out-of-sight subjects. The video generator is fine-tuned in two stages to learn reference anchors and reduce training-inference gaps for autoregressive generation.
Critical strengths
(a) The paper identifies the "out-of-sight world evolution" problem in current video world models and proposes a full-stack pipeline covering dataset construction, model design and training, and benchmark evaluation to solve the problem. Although the task setting is simplified in this paper, the dataset-model-evaluation paradigm is complete and reasonable. The dataset construction pipeline is inspiring. Leveraging powerful foundation generative models to obtain ground-truth data and performing multi-stage extraction and checking are useful to solve data scarcity problems in various controllable generation tasks.
(b) The quantitative and qualitative results, together with the video demos, verify the effectiveness of the proposed method.
Critical weaknesses
(a) Multi-turn and long-horizon video generation results are insufficient. In the "Limitations and Future Work" section, the paper recognizes that it currently focuses on a single event followed by a single subject reaction, while leaving long-horizon worlds in which multiple events interact, earlier reactions alter later conditions, or several entities respond over time, underexplored. It is reasonable to leave such more complex scenarios in future. However, the ability to generate multiple turns of "a single event followed by a single subject reaction" remains unclear in this paper. For example, in the "demo3_game.mp4" of supplementary materials, the player sees the enemy, then holds her sword. In the autoregressive manner, the enemy can also respond to the player's action as the next-turn out-of-sight evolution. However, the paper does not seem to show such multi-turn generation capabilities.
Questions for authors
(a) See Critical Weaknesses (a). Multi-turn and long-horizon generation are important in video world models. How long and faithful can the framework generate videos without obvious visual drift and unreasonable evolution?
(b) In the "Limitations and Future Work" section, the paper recognizes more complex camera trajectories, multi-event, and multi-reaction evolution as future directions. I am curious about the extensibility of the current framework. For example, the dataset construction pipeline requires a powerful commercial video generation model (e.g., Seedance 2.5) to create ground-truth video data. As the instructions (e.g., camera motions, number of entities, number of events) become more complicated, can the ground-truth data still be obtained with an acceptable success ratio and costs? Can the data annotation and checking pipeline be extended feasibly to annotate such complex videos?
6 comments
Response to Questions (a) & (b)
Question (a): Multi-turn generation question
Thanks for the question. In the additional experiment above, we evaluate multi-turn generation totaling 465 frames, or approximately 19.4 seconds at 24 fps. Within this tested horizon, SeerWorld achieves 95.8% multi-turn subject revisit success, 87.5% subject identity consistency, and 81.7% multi-turn causal plausibility. Across the complete rollout, it additionally obtains 89.2% background consistency.
These results indicate that the generated world can remain meaningfully faithful over several alternating subject–event revisits: the subject and background are generally preserved, and the later reaction usually remains causally consistent with the preceding event evolution. However, we do not claim drift-free generation over arbitrarily long horizons. Compared with the original single-reaction evaluation, both the causal plausibility and reaction quality decrease. This degradation reflects the accumulation of appearance, motion, and state errors across autoregressive turns.
Therefore, the current framework demonstrates meaningful multi-turn capability over the evaluated five-segment, around 20-second horizon. However, its reliability gradually weakens as additional states and transitions are introduced. In our qualitative long-horizon stress test, rollouts beyond approximately 30 seconds begin to exhibit noticeable visual drift and less accurate state evolution, which we attribute primarily to the accumulation of autoregressive errors in appearance, geometry, and motion as each generated segment becomes the conditioning context for subsequent segments. However, we believe SeerWorld can be extended to handle longer-horizon and more complex scenarios through targeted designs, such as constructing high-quality data with richer multi-entity and multi-event interactions and explicitly modeling multi-turn evolution during training. We will revise the paper to clarify that repeated state updates are already feasible within the current framework, while improving robustness over substantially longer horizons, more turns, multiple interacting events, and several evolving entities remains an important direction for future work.
$ $
Question (b): Extensibility of data construction
Thank you for the question. As discussed in our response to Critical Weakness (a), the current data and model already exhibit a certain degree of multi-turn capability. Supporting substantially more complex scenarios, however, would require extending the data-construction pipeline. In particular, story scripts should explicitly specify multiple entities, their evolving states, event dependencies, and camera trajectories.
Current commercial and open-source video generators, including Seedance and MiniMax-H3, can generate such complex scenarios. However, as complexity increases, the acceptance rate is likely to decrease and more fine-grained filtering will be required. The current annotation and checking pipeline can be extended accordingly by adding turn-level and cross-turn checks for entity identity, state persistence, event order, causal consistency, and camera motion.
The pipeline is not restricted to expensive commercial models. Our preliminary experiments with the open-source MiniMax-H3 model produce satisfactory results at relatively lower inference cost. Nevertheless, maintaining high data quality for substantially more complex multi-entity and multi-event scenarios remains an important research and engineering challenge and a promising direction for future work.
We greatly appreciate your positive assessment of our work and thanks again for your valuable comments which help improve our paper!
Thank you for your detailed rebuttal and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns. But I still have two questions:
(a) The new multi-turn evaluation provides encouraging quantitative results. But I also would like to see some visualization cases of multi-turn long videos, for example, some screenshots of a long video.
(b) The authors suggest that longer-horizon generation could be improved by constructing richer multi-entity and multi-event training data and explicitly modeling multi-turn evolution. However, I do not fully confirm that these approaches alone can effectively address error accumulation and visual quality degradation in autoregressive long video generation. These issues may also arise from the training-inference gap and accumulated errors in contexts, rather than simply insufficient training data length and complexity. I think there should be some further clarification and discussion.
Response to Weakness (a)
Thank you for the valuable feedback, here are our responses to all the concerns (weaknesses and questions).
Weakness (a): Multi-turn generation
Thank you for the comment. As acknowledged in our limitations, this paper primarily studies a single out-of-sight event followed by one subject reaction, rather than explicitly focusing on extended multi-turn evolution. Nevertheless, the autoregressive design of SeerWorld permits the generated state to be propagated into subsequent turns. To directly evaluate this capability, we now conduct an additional multi-turn evaluation over all 120 SeerWorld-Bench cases:
subject → event → reaction → same event evolves → next reaction evolution
This evaluation directly covers the type of suggested continuation: after the subject reacts to an event, the camera revisits the same event entity and observes its subsequent evolution, before returning to the subject for another reaction.
Here is an example: In the game domain, the camera pans away from a marsh ranger and reveals a spectral knight materializing from the mist on the opposite bank. When the camera returns, the ranger has risen from her crouched pose and drawn her sword into a defensive stance. The camera then revisits the same spectral knight, which preserves its identity, raises its sword, and advances in response. On the next return, the ranger retains her drawn-sword state, steps behind a nearby tree, and lowers into a defensive crouch rather than resetting to her initial pose.
These multi-turn autoregressive videos contain 465 frames, corresponding to approximately 19.4 seconds at 24 fps. We use the same checkpoint as the full SeerWorld method reported in the paper, without any additional training specifically for this multi-turn experiment. Importantly, each later event or subject-reaction segment is conditioned on its corresponding previously generated state rather than the initial observation. The event therefore evolves from its previously generated event state, while the later subject reaction evolves from the previously generated post-reaction subject state. We evaluate the consistency and the casual plausibility. The main results are as follows:
These results show that SeerWorld can recover a previously observed subject across repeated revisits while largely preserving its identity and generating a causally appropriate subsequent reaction. In particular, the identity consistency shows that the subject is usually recognizable and consistent after multiple camera movements and state changes. The multi-turn event result shows that the event can usually evolve successfully in the next turn. The 81.7% multi-turn causal plausibility further demonstrates that later behavior can remain consistent with the preceding event and accumulated state, rather than simply reproducing the initial reaction.
Notably, despite the more difficult multi-turn setting, SeerWorld’s multi-turn causal plausibility remains higher than the single-turn causal-plausibility results of all baseline methods reported in the main paper (e.g., 32.9% causal plausibility for Evoke). We believe that these results demonstrate the multi-turn capability of SeerWorld to a certain degree. We will add these quantitative results and related discussion to the final version.