- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
EEG recordings vary across datasets, and differences in sleep-stage proportions can affect spectral alignment during adaptation. This paper proposes PASF, which uses predicted sleep-stage probabilities and source-stage spectral templates to estimate a recording-specific filter at test time. The method corrects spectral differences shared across stages while keeping the prediction model fixed. The paper evaluates this approach across four sleep datasets and two model architectures, with additional experiments examining its mechanism and limitations.
Critical strengths
The cross-dataset evaluations and controlled experiments provide useful evidence for the proposed approach. The method improves average performance without updating model parameters or requiring target labels. The detailed ablations and reporting of negative results also help clarify when spectral correction may be useful and where its assumptions fail.
Critical weaknesses
- The practical contribution of target-stage conditioning is not clearly established by the main results. How much the of the real-data improvements comes from target-stage conditioning?
- The assumption that differences shared across stages are suitable for correction needs clearer conditions of applicability.
- The evaluation does not establish whether the gains extend to stronger pretrained sleep models which targets the generalization problem.
Questions for authors
- Why frequency-domain is the best part to learn the adaptation, is there any experiments to support the claim or just follow the previous research?
- How these task-relevant physiological state will affect the adaptation?
- In line 81, how to identify the task-relevant physiological states from the training data using state labels?
- In the related work, i understand the overcorrection under label shift? how about other real-world shift problems and how this framework can solve other shift conditions?
- There are a lot of sleep foundation models such as sleepFM[1], OSF[2], why not choosing them as the evaluation models or such generalization problem is less challenging for those settings?
[1]. Thapa, Rahul et al. “A multimodal sleep foundation model for disease prediction.” Nature Medicine 32 (2026): 752 - 762. [2]. Shuai, Zi-Tao et al. “OSF: On Pre-training and Scaling of Sleep Foundation Models.” ICML 2026
Response to the Reviewer TAyN
Response to the Reviewer
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments. We appreciate the opportunity to clarify the choice of the frequency domain, the role of physiological states, the scope of the correction framework, and its applicability to sleep foundation models.
We address the specific questions below.
Q1. Why perform adaptation in the frequency domain?
Response: Our choice of the frequency domain is supported by both theoretical motivation and prior empirical evidence. CMMN connects spectral alignment to convolutional corrections under stationary-signal assumptions and demonstrates improvements over conventional normalization in sleep staging [1]. Moreover, FMM directly compares Fourier-space and input-space moment matching using the same architecture: on Sleep-EDF, Fourier-space matching achieves 74.1% accuracy versus 65.4% for input-space matching [2]. Building on this evidence, PASF focuses on identifying which spectral discrepancies should be corrected.
[1] Gnassounou, T., Flamary, R., and Gramfort, A. Convolutional Monge Mapping Normalization for Learning on Sleep Data. In Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, vol. 36, 2023.
[2] Krishnamachari, K., Ng, S.-K., and Foo, C.-S. Mitigating Real-World Distribution Shifts in the Fourier Domain. Transactions on Machine Learning Research, 2023.
Q2. How these task-relevant physiological state will affect the adaptation?
Response: Different sleep stages have distinct spectral characteristics, so changes in stage proportions can alter the overall spectrum even when acquisition conditions remain unchanged. Ignoring these states may lead to physiological variation being mistaken for domain-related distortion. PASF uses predicted stage probabilities to compare target signals with stage-specific source templates, then identifies the component shared across the resulting state-conditioned residuals. This helps distinguish spectral differences due to stage-composition changes from candidate recording-level shifts.
Q3. How to identify the task-relevant physiological states from the training data using state labels?
Response: We use the provided source labels to group EEG epochs into the five sleep stages and compute the mean log-power spectrum within each group as its initial state-specific template.
Q4. Which real-world shifts can PASF address beyond label shift?
Response: PASF targets the structure of a shift rather than its origin. Whether a shift arises from devices, populations, or environmental conditions, PASF aims to correct its spectral component that remains stable within a recording and is shared across states. Its scope therefore extends beyond label shift, but does not cover shifts outside this structural assumption.
Q5. Does PASF provide additional benefits for sleep foundation models?
Response: We evaluated PASF with SleepFM and OSF on four target datasets. PASF improves mean BAcc by 2.60 and 2.29 percentage points, respectively. Each model improves on three of the four datasets, with ISRUC as the exception. The full per-dataset results are in item 4, “Stronger pretrained backbones,” of our Response to the Area Chair (1/2).