acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

VerNav: Verifier-First Low-Latency Vision-and-Language Navigation

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) requires an agent to navigate through unseen 3D environments according to natural-language instructions. Explicit reasoning can improve instruction understanding and semantic grounding, but autoregressive generation at every step accumulates large decision-stage latency over multi-step navigation. We propose VerNav, a verifier-first framework for low-latency LLM-based VLN. The verifier reduces decision-stage latency by replacing per-step autoregressive generation with batched action verification, while an entropy-based adaptive generator is invoked only for uncertain decisions to produce compact state evidence. To further improve navigation performance with the verifier, we introduce a two-stage alignment scheme: (i) VPO improves local action-preference alignment in static verifier training, and (ii) step-level reinforcement fine-tuning provides dense progress rewards over multi-step navigation rollouts during dynamic task execution. Experiments on the Room-to-Room (R2R) benchmark show that the verifier-only decision path of VerNav achieves competitive navigation performance among representative LLM-based VLN agents and reduces decision-stage LLM latency by approximately 52.9× relative to NavGPT with the same backbone.

Primary area:
applications to robotics, autonomy, planning
Keywords:
vision-and-language navigation, embodied AI, large language models, reinforcement fine-tuning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.60 over 5 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_bG3MOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

VerNav reduces LLM decision latency in vision-and-language navigation by scoring candidate actions in a batch with a Qwen2.5-3B verifier. It converts visual observations into text descriptions and invokes DeepSeek-V4-Pro when candidate-score entropy exceeds a threshold. The generator summarizes the same textual context, and the verifier then scores the actions again. Training combines pairwise preference optimization with rollout-based reinforcement fine-tuning. On R2R val-unseen, the verifier-only model achieves 39.63% success at a reported decision latency of 0.08 seconds per step. The adaptive generator is evaluated through additional analyses, including a 100-instruction subset.

Critical strengths

The paper gives a simple, practical way to reduce repeated autoregressive generation. It follows a similar idea as Speculative Decoding. Batched candidate scoring provides a fast decision path, while occasional state summaries allow additional computation on difficult steps. The distinction between verifier-only and adaptive inference is clearly described.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The image-to-text interface creates a visual information bottleneck that the adaptive generator shares. Both models receive the instruction, action history, and prepared view descriptions. For example, an instruction may ask for "the door behind the sofa," while two different candidate images are both captioned "a living room with a sofa and a door." The relation needed to choose the correct door has been lost. Further reasoning over those captions has no visual evidence with which to resolve the ambiguity. A caption error can also make the verifier confidently prefer the wrong action, so entropy may fail to trigger assistance. The paper gives little detail on the captioner, its configuration, or how its descriptions preserve instruction-relevant spatial information. It also leaves the benefit of this interface over a comparably sized multimodal backbone untested. This is a central design trade-off: the speed gain depends partly on how much perceptual work and information the text interface leaves out.

  2. The comparisons leave the full system's accuracy-latency trade-off and the benefit of the verifier interface unresolved. The 52.9x speedup uses the verifier-only path and excludes image captioning. The adaptive path takes 0.294 seconds per step, while its reported success improvement comes from a 100-instruction subset. Table 4 matches backbones for timing but gives no corresponding navigation results for those baseline configurations. A full-split comparison under one configuration, including captioning and generator costs, is needed to judge the deployment benefit. A small LLM trained to output a candidate identifier directly is also a natural low-latency baseline. Since selective reasoning already appears in AdaNav, R3, and SFCo-Nav, the paper needs stronger evidence that batched verification improves on these simpler or closely related alternatives.

Questions for authors
  1. Which captioning model and configuration produce the view descriptions? Are the descriptions conditioned on the navigation instruction, and is the captioner adapted to the task? Please include an example where a required spatial relation is lost in the caption and explain how VerNav handles it.

  2. What motivates the text-only interface over a comparably sized multimodal model with a short action output? A comparison under matched training and inference budgets would help quantify the information-cost trade-off and the specific benefit of candidate verification.

  3. Can you report SR, SPL, generator invocation rate, and complete perception-to-decision latency on the full val-unseen split for a fixed threshold? Please separate captioning, verification, generator calls, and re-scoring, and report accuracy for the same baseline configurations used in the timing comparison.

Reviewer_2534OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

VerNav proposes a verifier-first approach to vision-and-language navigation. At each step, a Qwen2.5-3B verifier scores the executable actions, including STOP, using the logit of a single “Yes” token; candidate queries are evaluated in a batch. The verifier is trained with pairwise action preferences (VPO) and then refined on navigation rollouts. When its action scores are uncertain, an entropy trigger calls a larger model to produce state evidence before the actions are rescored. On R2R val-unseen, the verifier-only policy achieves 39.63% SR and 34.13% SPL at a reported decision-stage latency of 0.08 seconds per step. The paper offers a useful way to reduce repeated LLM generation, but its efficiency claim and the novelty of its verification interface need clearer positioning.

  • The decision-stage speedup over generative LLM agents is useful. The incomplete latency scope, baseline-setting concern, and limited discussion of verification-based predecessors currently make the broader efficiency and novelty claims difficult to assess. I would be happy to reconsider my score if the authors address these concerns in their response.
Critical strengths
  • Batched, single-token action scoring is a simple and effective response to the latency of autoregressive LLM navigation.

  • The paper separates local preference training from rollout-based refinement, and its ablations show that both stages improve navigation success.

  • The adaptive evidence mechanism has a clear trigger and is compared with random and fixed-interval triggering at comparable call rates.

Critical weaknesses
  • The efficiency comparison is too narrow. VerNav is compared mainly with generative LLM agents. Smaller VLN policies such as RecBERT and DUET use substantially less model capacity and already provide strong navigation results. Beating LLM agents on decision latency does not establish a speed advantage over conventional VLN policies. This point can be addressed by appropriately scoping the claim and discussing existing results; it does not require retraining those methods.

  • The reported latency covers only part of the pipeline. The 0.08-second figure excludes the visual captioning needed to construct VerNav’s textual observations. As a result, it characterizes the verifier’s decision stage rather than the latency of a complete navigation step.

  • Limited positioning against related work. The paper does not adequately discuss prior candidate-scoring and verification methods, including DV-VLN (arXiv:2601.18492), VeGAS (2605.12620), MG-VLN (2308.03244), , and VidAssist (2409.20557). These methods differ from VerNav in their tasks and inference procedures, but together they show that verification-based candidate scoring is an established idea. The paper should identify more precisely what is new about its online, batched verifier-first implementation.

Questions for authors
  • How should readers interpret the speed claim relative to smaller VLN policies such as RecBERT and DUET? What fraction of a complete navigation step is covered by the reported latency once visual description generation is included?

  • What is the specific methodological advance over DV-VLN, VeGAS, MG-VLN, and VidAssist? In particular, which part of VerNav’s gain comes from making verification the default online decision path?

Reviewer_k6tROpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

VerNav combines batched action verification, entropy-triggered evidence generation, and preference/RL training to reduce LLM decision latency. Experiments evaluate graph-based R2R navigation.

Critical strengths

Reducing repeated autoregressive generation addresses a relevant computational bottleneck. The verifier-only results suggest a potentially useful efficiency–performance trade-off.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Lack of demonstrated novelty. The method combines established ingredients: candidate scoring, entropy-based triggering, pairwise ranking, and reward-based fine-tuning. Its distinction from existing discriminative navigation approaches, including NavGPT-2, is insufficiently established. Without matched action-classification or ranking baselines, the added value of the verifier interface remains unclear.

  2. Incomplete empirical support and reproducibility. Table 4 reports latency but not navigation performance for the shared-backbone baselines. Adaptive performance comparisons are limited to 100 instructions, whereas Tables 3 and 5 report verifier-only performance. The supplementary release also omits the core training, inference, and timing implementations, limiting verification of the complete method’s performance–latency advantage.

Questions for authors
  1. Complete evaluation: Table 3 already reports verifier-only SR/SPL and latency (0.08 s/step). Can you provide full val-unseen SR/SPL for the adaptive method timed at 0.294 s/step in Table 4, beyond Figure 6’s 100-instruction subset? Please also report SR/SPL for Table 4’s Qwen2.5-3B baselines, since their Table 3 results use different backbones and cannot be paired with these timings.

  2. Real-world validation: The paper lacks real-world robot experiments. Can you provide deployment evidence, or clarify how this limits the practical implications of the latency results?

  3. Insufficient ablations and controls: Table 5 isolates training stages but not the benefits of the verifier interface or dense rewards. Can you provide a matched direct action-prediction or listwise-classification baseline and an outcome-only RFT ablation, controlling the backbone, observations, training data, and budget?

  4. Outdated baselines: Table 3 mainly compares older methods. Although missing timing results may complicate comparisons with newer work, EvolveNav (TPAMI 2026) reports CoT-generation times and corresponding navigation metrics (§4.3, arXiv v3, p. 9, below Table 7). Why was it omitted, and can you include a comparison under a consistent timing protocol?

I am willing to increase the score if the author addresses all my concerns.

Reviewer_vLarOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the high decision latency caused by step-by-step autoregressive reasoning in VLN and proposes a low-latency navigation framework named VerNav. Specifically, the Verifier-First Action Interface formulates candidate action selection as independent binary verification tasks for each executable action. In addition, the authors introduce an entropy-based Generator-Verifier Collaboration mechanism, which uses normalized entropy to quantify decision uncertainty and determine when additional state evidence is needed. The authors conduct experiments to evaluate the proposed framework and report positive effects on verifier scoring and navigation success rates.

Critical strengths

This paper reformulates candidate action selection as a batch binary classification verification problem, avoiding the token-by-token autoregressive decoding process inherent in traditional generative decision-making, which effectively reduces the serial generation overhead during the decision phase. The two-stage training strategy is reasonably sound, balancing local action preferences with long-term navigation goals. The distinct modules have relatively clear responsibilities, though there is still room for further improvement.

Critical weaknesses

I believe the paper suffers from several issues, primarily concerning insufficient experiments and a lack of efficiency:

  1. The paper only evaluates the complete adaptive system on a Val-Unseen subset of 100 instructions, which is insufficient to effectively validate model performance.
  2. I consider using entropy as an uncertainty metric to be unreasonable, as identical normalized entropy does not necessarily correspond to the same actual decision error probability. Raw logits do not naturally possess probability calibration properties, and their numerical scales may vary with model training, prompt templates, and the distribution of candidate actions.
  3. The reported 0.08 second latency is merely the latency of the verifier-only decision stage rather than the complete system latency. Furthermore, it lacks analysis of computational costs or memory overhead advantages. The authors should focus on end-to-end navigation efficiency comparisons rather than a single isolated module.
  4. The experiments are conducted solely in the R2R scenario, lacking results and analysis on the important RxR dataset.
Questions for authors

In addition to the points mentioned in the weaknesses, the authors should address the following:

  1. How sensitive is the proposed entropy-based triggering mechanism to logit calibration and the number of candidate actions?
  2. Could the authors provide more details about how the chosen-rejected action pairs are constructed in VPO?
  3. Can the proposed method generalize to other VLN datasets beyond R2R?
Reviewer_oqj6OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a model for vision-and-language navigation based on VLM backbones that aims to reduce the decision latency of LLM/VLM-based navigation agents. Rather than generating actions through autoregressive reasoning at every navigation step, they use their trained verifier and ask a question to score possible action. If the entropy of the scores is high they switch to autoregressive generation. The authors argue that this design significantly reduces inference latency while maintaining competitive navigation performance.

Critical strengths

-The paper deals with an important problem that is the latency of the VLM models in the VLN setting that we need real-time actions. -The approach is sound and they can bypass the step by step chain of thought generation by using their trained verifier that is a smaller model with efficient decision making. They improve latency of decision making for actions. -Using entropy for measuring the uncertainty and switching to reasoning approach makes sense.

Critical weaknesses

Weakness: 1- May major concern in evaluation that is done on only R2R, there are more challenging variation like R4R, RXR, and more. Even just sticking to discrete environment, more tests and evaluations are needed, specially to see if the performance stays competitive. 2- The performance in general does not improve compared to VLM-based models though we are using a specialized trained verifier. And the performance results are much lower than specialized models such as DUET. 3- One more concern/question is measuring the latency that is done in text-based setting only. Are the improvements remain significant when we have to process the visual input at each step for the verifier?

Questions for authors

-Have you evaluated your uncertainty quantification? is there a strong correlation between uncertainty and action correctness? -If we use a larger models for verifier, can we improve the performance while doing better still in latency? -Can you discuss the failure modes of the verifier?

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.