- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper studies incompatibility between independently trained CSI feedback encoders and a fixed base-station decoder. It proposes FastAdapter, which generates a reusable intermediate adapter from unlabeled support codewords while keeping both endpoints frozen. Offline, the method prepares supervised adapter targets using codeword refinement and reconstruction constraints, then aligns their hidden-unit permutations to obtain consistent parameter coordinates. A condition encoder combines raw codewords, Gram-matrix features, and parameter-position information. Contrastive pretraining and conditional diffusion subsequently learn to generate complete adapter parameters for unseen encoders.
The evaluation covers COST2100 indoor/outdoor, WAIR-D, and DeepMIMO, using held-out training configurations and leave-one-architecture-out experiments over seven encoder families. FastAdapter reports lower NMSE than the strongest generative baseline in all eight settings, with improvements of 0.34–2.07 dB for unseen training configurations and 0.17–1.17 dB for unseen architectures. Component ablations, functional-equivalence checks for parameter realignment, and an adaptation-time breakdown provide additional validation.
Critical strengths
1.
This work tackles a meaningful interoperability problem with a practical adaptation interface.
Generating adapters from received codewords is a compelling approach, particularly when encoders and decoders are trained independently and must remain fixed. The framework cleanly separates the paired supervision used for offline preparation from the unlabeled observations available when adapting a new encoder, and the resulting adapter can be reused for subsequent feedback. Consistent improvements across both training-configuration and architecture holdouts offer promising evidence that adaptation experience transfers across different encoder models. This is the core reason I see the problem formulation and proposed system as genuinely valuable.
2.
Key design choices are supported by targeted experiments and a dedicated correctness check.
The paper addresses parameter-coordinate inconsistency as a prerequisite for learning to generate adapter weights. Appendix A demonstrates that jointly permuting the two FFN weight matrices and the first-layer bias preserves the adapter function, and Table 4 confirms this result numerically. Table 2 further shows a substantial drop in reconstruction quality when ParamRealign is removed. The Gram and Raw branches, position-specific context, and contrastive pretraining also consistently boost performance across all evaluated settings. Taken together, these experiments make a solid case that both the target representation and conditioning design are meaningful contributors to the system’s performance.
Critical weaknesses
- The encoder population and the reliability of the reported generalization gains are insufficiently characterized.
Section 5.1 and Appendix F describe grouped splits and seven architecture families, but do not specify the actual training configurations varied or provide complete encoder counts for the main evaluations. These details are central because the method learns a mapping from codeword statistics to adapter parameters, so its generalization depends on the diversity and independence of the encoder tasks.
Furthermore, Table 1 reports aggregate point estimates without variability across support-set draws, diffusion initializations, or repeated generator training. Results for the individual held-out architecture families are also absent. This matters particularly for the smaller improvements of 0.17 dB and 0.34 dB. The current evidence does not establish whether these gains are reproducible or whether aggregate scores conceal substantial variation across encoder families. These omissions limit my confidence in the paper’s main generalization claim. References: Section 5.1 Table 1 Appendix F Section 6 also acknowledges unmeasured support-set effects and generation variability
- The incremental value of diffusion and its computational tradeoff are not adequately isolated
HyperTransformer is included, and the paper states that the baselines share target adapters and conditioning information. However, it does not document a matched deterministic predictor that retains the full Gram–Raw condition encoder, position-specific context, and target preparation while replacing only the diffusion generator. Consequently, the experiments do not clearly establish how much of the improvement requires diffusion rather than the proposed conditioning pipeline.
This comparison is consequential because 50-step DDIM sampling accounts for 4.48 seconds of the reported 5.99-second adaptation pipeline. Table 3 reports timings for adapter optimization, affine adaptation, and retrieval, but omits all four competing parameter generators. The paper therefore establishes an NMSE advantage over those generators without establishing the corresponding accuracy–latency tradeoff. A matched direct predictor and comparable generator timings would materially strengthen the justification for the additional generation cost.
my references: Section 5.1, Table 3, Appendix D, Table 8, Section 6.
Questions for authors
-
Clarification of the encoder-generalization protocol. What exactly varies across the “training configurations,” and how many independently trained encoder instances are included in each dataset, architecture family, and split? How are checkpoints or models derived from the same training run grouped? Please also provide the concrete codeword dimensions and compression ratios used in the main experiments.
-
Clarification of hyperparameter selection. Table 5 reports selected NMSE values of −21.49 and −21.18 dB, which exactly match the COST2100/in FastAdapter entries in Table 1. Which models and data splits produced the Appendix B scores: fitted target adapters or generated adapters, and validation or test encoders? Please clarify how the loss weights were selected and how the selection data were separated from the final evaluation.
-
Validation of reliable adaptation from unlabeled support. Does Table 1 evaluate a single generated adapter per encoder without CSI-based selection among multiple candidates? How do the results vary across support-set draws and diffusion initializations, particularly for the smallest reported gains? Since support codewords are drawn from each encoder’s training CSI split, do the results persist when support CSI is independently drawn and was not used to train that encoder?
-
Validation of the contribution of diffusion. With the target adapters, full condition encoder, position-specific context, and training budget held comparable, how does a deterministic parameter predictor perform in NMSE and adaptation time? What are the corresponding timings of HyperTransformer and the diffusion-based baselines on the same hardware?
3 comments
Response to Reviewer eyNq W2 & Q4
W2: The incremental value of diffusion and its computational tradeoff are not adequately isolated. [...] However, it does not document a matched deterministic predictor that retains the full Gram–Raw condition encoder, position-specific context, and target preparation while replacing only the diffusion generator. [...] Table 3 reports timings for adapter optimization, affine adaptation, and retrieval, but omits all four competing parameter generators.
Q4: Validation of the contribution of diffusion. With the target adapters, full condition encoder, position-specific context, and training budget held comparable, how does a deterministic parameter predictor perform in NMSE and adaptation time? What are the corresponding timings of HyperTransformer and the diffusion-based baselines on the same hardware?
Thank you for suggesting that we compare both generator accuracy and runtime. Under unseen training configurations, FastAdapter's mean NMSE is 7.43–8.35 dB lower than MLP-L's, but adaptation takes longer. Compared with Cond P-Diff, D2NWG, and RPG, FastAdapter has both accuracy and runtime advantages.
- Controls that replace only the generator directly test the contribution of the generation mechanism. MLP-S / MLP-L retain the full conditioning pipeline and replace only the generator, using the same training budget as FastAdapter. The HyperTransformer reimplementation is also deterministic: it predicts the Adapter parameters used in this work and produces the same output for the same model parameters and support codewords. All compared methods use comparable hyperparameter-tuning budgets, with configurations selected by validation performance.
- FastAdapter reconstructs CSI more accurately than MLP-L, with a longer adaptation time. On COST2100/in under unseen training configurations, FastAdapter takes 2.92 s longer than MLP-L and reduces mean NMSE by 8.35 dB. Tables 5 and 6 report the accuracy and runtime of each generative method.
Table 5. NMSE of parameter-generation methods under unseen training configurations (dB).
| Method | COST2100/in | COST2100/out | WAIR-D | DeepMIMO |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MLP-S | -2.16±0.15 | -1.18±0.27 | -1.00±0.22 | -0.43±0.31 |
| MLP-L | -13.16±0.16 | -7.34±0.14 | -12.83±0.15 | -13.67±0.23 |
| HyperTransformer | -16.15±0.07 | -9.71±0.15 | -17.04±0.13 | -17.51±0.14 |
| Cond P-Diff | -19.89±0.08 | -12.46±0.11 | -19.22±0.18 | -17.13±0.09 |
| D2NWG | -20.67±0.08 | -12.83±0.06 | -18.39±0.12 | -20.43±0.16 |
| RPG | -20.25±0.07 | -13.49±0.12 | -20.78±0.05 | -20.40±0.11 |
| Autoregressive | -13.23±0.15 | -7.09±0.13 | -12.27±0.20 | -12.86±0.19 |
| Flow Matching | -20.31±0.22 | -13.47±0.19 | -20.43±0.17 | -20.36±0.13 |
| FastAdapter-50 | -21.51±0.09 | -15.66±0.17 | -21.05±0.15 | -21.10±0.13 |
Table 6. Total adaptation time of generators under unseen training configurations (s).
| Method | COST2100/in | COST2100/out | WAIR-D | DeepMIMO |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| MLP-S | 1.71±0.12 | 1.72±0.13 | 1.82±0.12 | 1.76±0.15 |
| MLP-L | 2.83±0.07 | 2.86±0.13 | 3.14±0.20 | 3.08±0.15 |
| HyperTransformer | 2.91±0.81 | 2.86±0.77 | 3.51±0.92 | 3.14±0.89 |
| Cond P-Diff | 45.98±5.41 | 42.45±4.36 | 50.09±4.92 | 46.79±4.54 |
| D2NWG | 92.98±7.44 | 89.04±8.03 | 88.76±7.46 | 91.09±7.45 |
| RPG | 103.92±7.89 | 99.53±8.41 | 120.72±10.49 | 115.64±9.38 |
| Autoregressive | 15.63±1.47 | 14.28±1.83 | 18.74±2.29 | 17.52±1.94 |
| Flow Matching | 34.72±3.91 | 32.14±3.47 | 39.83±4.28 | 37.56±4.01 |
| FastAdapter-50 | 5.75±0.18 | 6.08±0.15 | 6.16±0.18 | 6.06±0.29 |
Under unseen training configurations, FastAdapter takes 5.75–6.16 s, compared with 2.86–3.51 s for HyperTransformer and 42.45–120.72 s for Cond P-Diff, D2NWG, and RPG. On COST2100/in under unseen training configurations, DDIM takes 4.33±0.16 s out of a total adaptation time of 5.75±0.18 s, making sampling the main cost. Generation is performed when adapting to a new encoder, and subsequent feedback reuses the Adapter. All methods are timed on the same RTX 4090, from support-codeword encoding to the completion of Adapter loading. In the uploaded revised manuscript, Appendix G.3 describes the new deterministic controls, and Appendices G.2 and G.5 report accuracy and the new generator timings, respectively, for both protocols.
Response to Reviewer eyNq Q2 & Q3
Q2: Clarification of hyperparameter selection. Appendix B/Table 5 reports selected NMSE values of −21.49 and −21.18 dB, which exactly match the COST2100/in FastAdapter entries in Table 1. Which models and data splits produced the Appendix B scores: fitted target adapters or generated adapters, and validation or test encoders? Please clarify how the loss weights were selected and how the selection data were separated from the final evaluation.
We apologize for the confusion caused by our description of hyperparameter selection and the displayed results. The weights are selected using validation encoders; the 55-cell grid evaluates the NMSE of FastAdapter-generated Adapters on test encoders. In the uploaded revised manuscript, Appendix B and Section 5.2 report the same test evaluation for the selected weights, hence the identical NMSE.
For each candidate loss-weight configuration, we first prepare the corresponding target Adapters and train the generator. We then generate Adapters from the support codewords of validation encoders and select the weights by reconstruction NMSE. After selection, we fix the configuration and evaluate it on independent test encoders. The evaluation measures generated Adapters, not fitted target Adapters.
Table 7. Validation selection and test evaluation of generated Adapters, NMSE (dB).
| Protocol | Best validation-grid NMSE | Test mean±std |
|---|---|---|
| Unseen training configurations | -21.82 | -21.51±0.09 |
| Unseen architectures | -21.32 | -21.16±0.14 |
Appendix G.7 of the uploaded revised manuscript gives the expanded validation grid of 77 configurations per protocol. Among all configurations searched for each protocol, the lowest validation NMSE for both protocols is attained at . WAIR-D and DeepMIMO reuse these weights without a separate search over target-loss weights. After all target Adapters have been trained, we use seed 0 to fix the split of encoder tasks into training, validation, and test sets. All parameter-generation methods use the same split and are supervised by the target Adapter parameters corresponding to the training-set encoders.
Q3: Validation of reliable adaptation from unlabeled support. Does Table 1 evaluate a single generated adapter per encoder without CSI-based selection among multiple candidates? How do the results vary across support-set draws and diffusion initializations, particularly for the smallest reported gains? Since support codewords are drawn from each encoder’s training CSI split, do the results persist when support CSI is independently drawn and was not used to train that encoder?
Thank you for your attention to the reliability of adaptation from unlabeled support. Yes, we generate only one Adapter per encoder in each evaluation, without using query CSI to select among multiple candidates. When we instead use independent support CSI that was used neither for encoder training nor for checkpoint selection, the absolute change in mean NMSE is no greater than 0.09 dB across the four datasets under unseen training configurations.
- We generate only one Adapter per encoder in each evaluation and repeat the evaluation to assess the effects of support sampling and initial noise. For each test encoder, we draw 128 support codewords, sample the initial noise once, and use DDIM to generate one Adapter; query CSI is used only to compute the final NMSE. Each of the three repeats follows this procedure, jointly varying support sampling, initial denoising noise, and generator training. Under unseen training configurations, FastAdapter's standard deviations across the three repeats are 0.09–0.17 dB. The aggregation procedure and repeated results for the small margins are provided in our response to W1-2 and in Table 4.
- Independent support still achieves accuracy close to that of the main experiments. The independent support pool is used neither for encoder training nor for checkpoint selection and does not overlap with the query set. Under unseen training configurations, mean NMSE changes by +0.02 to +0.09 dB, and the standard deviations with independent support are 0.10–0.21 dB. In the in-distribution evaluation on these datasets, support sets formed from CSI outside encoder training and checkpoint selection still enable effective adaptation.
Table 8. NMSE with different support CSI sources under unseen training configurations (dB).
| Dataset | Training-CSI support | Independent-CSI support |
|---|---|---|
| COST2100/in | -21.51±0.09 | -21.46±0.10 |
| COST2100/out | -15.66±0.17 | -15.64±0.18 |
| WAIR-D | -21.05±0.15 | -20.98±0.17 |
| DeepMIMO | -21.10±0.13 | -21.01±0.21 |
In the uploaded revised manuscript, Appendix G.1 describes the single-Adapter evaluation and repeat protocol, Appendix G.6 reports the new independent-support experiment under both protocols, and Section 6 discusses the implications for deployment.
Response to Reviewer eyNq W1-1/Q1 & W1-2
Thank you for your thoughtful review and valuable feedback. We appreciate your recognition of the practical value of encoder interoperability and our reusable Adapter interface. Below are our responses to your comments (your comments are highlighted in italics).
Thank you for asking how we count independent encoders. We select one checkpoint per run by validation performance. Its target Adapter and codewords share its split.
In preliminary tests within each family and dataset, the training seed had the largest effect. We vary it, fixing batch size, peak learning rate, schedule, and optimizer. Each dataset has 1213 encoders per family (8491 total). We hold out instances within families or one family per fold (Table 1). No Adapter yields 23.07–29.32 dB on unseen configurations.
Table 1. Encoders per dataset.
Table 2. CSI and codeword dimensions and compression ratios.
In CR=C/(2HW), the two channels are real and imaginary. All families in a dataset share the codeword dimension and decoder interface.
Thank you for suggesting repeated runs and per-family results. Across three new runs, FastAdapter has the lowest mean NMSE among the compared generators in all eight settings.
The repeats cover training and generation. Seeds 42, 2026, and 3407 vary generator initialization and training, support and query draws, and DDIM initial noise. We fix the split (seed 0), encoders, target Adapters, alignment reference, and standardization statistics. Each repeat generates one Adapter per test encoder. For each encoder, we sum error and channel energies over queries and convert their ratio to dB. We average within families, then equally across families, and report mean±std over repeats.
NMSE varies by held-out family. TransNet and Attention-CNN reach -16.60 and -8.99 dB on COST2100/out (Table 3).
The small gains persist on average. Gains over RPG are 0.17 dB on COST2100/out (unseen architectures) and 0.27 dB on WAIR-D (unseen configurations). On DeepMIMO, the gains over D2NWG are 0.67 dB (unseen configurations) and 0.59 dB (unseen architectures), with a 0.22 dB lead over Flow Matching in the latter case (Table 4).
Table 3. FastAdapter-50 NMSE by held-out family (dB).
Table 4. NMSE and mean gains (dB).
In the uploaded revised manuscript, see Appendix G.1 for the protocol and G.2 for three-run and per-family NMSE.