acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

ProVe: Proposer-Verifier Decoding

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Speculative decoding accelerates autoregressive (AR) language models by letting a small model draft tokens serially and a large model verify them in parallel. We reverse these roles. Starting from a standard AR checkpoint, we fine-tune the large model into a proposer that predicts a block of future tokens in a single forward pass, then use one additional forward pass to verify the proposed block. This gives ProVe, proposer-verifier decoding. The verifier can be a smaller AR model or the proposer itself; the latter gives ProVe-lossless, which reproduces the proposer's greedy AR decoding. Block proposals already provide substantial room for acceleration: with a block size of 16, the proposed block has an average AR-matching prefix of 6.6 tokens on GSM8K. Across six benchmarks with a 32B proposer, ProVe-lossless reaches average AR throughput without training a separate draft head. With a small 3B verifier, ProVe reaches average throughput at 2.6 accuracy points below AR on the six-task average, providing a controllable tradeoff between speed and accuracy.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
speculative decoding, LLM inference acceleration, multi-token generation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.80 over 5 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_LiqqOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

ProVe builds on MARS to fine-tune an autoregressive model for parallel block proposals, then adds a verification pass. It uses a smaller AR model and a confidence-product threshold to select the committed prefix; the lossless version uses the proposer itself to recover its greedy AR continuation. Experiments report 2.54× average throughput for ProVe-lossless and a speed–accuracy tradeoff for smaller verifiers across six benchmarks, with additional reasoning-model and concurrency experiments.

Critical strengths

The controlled comparison with MARS isolates the benefit of verification while holding the proposer fixed. The analysis provides useful evidence that proposal confidence alone does not fully identify the usable prefix.

The serving implementation demonstrates acceleration: ProVe-lossless achieves throughput comparable to a fine-tuned EAGLE-3 head without a separate draft network.

The evaluation setting is broad across different datasets.

Critical weaknesses

The incremental contribution is insufficiently distinguished from prior work. Block-proposal training is inherited from MARS. Parallel proposal followed by verification using the same model is already established in PaSS, while I-DLM also combines masked proposals with self-verification. The related-work discussion acknowledges these methods but does not clearly establish what ProVe-lossless adds beyond applying an existing verification procedure to the MARS proposer.

The motivation for reversing model roles is insufficiently justified, particularly given two sources of loss relative to the original target. First, MARS fine-tunes the large model, so its original distribution is no longer guaranteed to be preserved. “ProVe-lossless” is therefore lossless only with respect to the modified checkpoint’s greedy decoding. Second, using a smaller verifier introduces another source of loss through heuristic acceptance. Methods such as DFlash already eliminate serial drafting using a small parallel drafter while preserving the original target distribution. The paper does not sufficiently justify why reversing model roles and accepting these two sources of loss is preferable; at least a matched comparison with such methods is needed.

The practical value of smaller-model verification remain insufficiently established. Teacher-forced likelihood may detect local inconsistencies, but it is a heuristic proxy for agreement with the large model, and the detailed gating diagnostic is limited to GSM8K. Several configurations are slower and less accurate than ProVe-lossless on the reported six-task averages. The highlighted 3B configuration improves throughput from 2.54× to 2.72×—approximately 7%—while losing 2.6 accuracy points and requiring another model. Favorable reasoning results exist, but the evaluation does not establish when this tradeoff is reliably advantageous.

Questions for authors
  • What is the specific contribution of ProVe-lossless beyond combining the MARS proposer with established parallel self-verification procedures?
  • What motivates reversing model roles over using a small parallel drafter with exact target verification? Can the authors provide a matched comparison with a method such as DFlash, explicitly accounting for whether the original target checkpoint is preserved?
  • In which workloads does smaller-model verification provide a compelling advantage over ProVe-lossless at comparable task quality? The reported six-task averages show limited additional speedup, and several configurations are both slower and less accurate.
Reviewer_9sScOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper presents ProVe, a framework for accelerating LLM inference by reversing the traditional speculative decoding architecture. Instead of using a small model for drafting and a large model for verification, ProVe uses a large model to propose multiple tokens in parallel and a smaller model to verify them. The paper also introduces ProVe-Lossless, which uses the large model for self-verification to preserve greedy AR decoding outputs. Experiments show promising speedups across multiple benchmarks.

Critical strengths

The idea of reversing the roles of the proposer and verifier is interesting and provides a different perspective on speculative decoding.

The method achieves promising inference speedups while maintaining competitive accuracy, especially with ProVe-Lossless.

The experiments cover multiple benchmarks and include comparisons with established speculative decoding baselines such as EAGLE-3.

Critical weaknesses

Limited novelty. Self-speculative decoding has already been explored in previous works such as LayerSkip [1]. Moreover, the block proposal mechanism is inherited from MARS. The paper does not provide a direct comparison with existing self-speculative decoding methods, making it difficult to assess the novelty and advantages of ProVe.

Missing comparison with DFlash. The authors do not compare against DFlash [2], a recent and highly competitive speculative decoding method that also supports parallel block drafting. Given its strong performance, DFlash is an important baseline for evaluating the effectiveness of ProVe.

Unclear motivation for using a large model as the proposer. The paper does not sufficiently explain the unique advantages of using a large model for drafting rather than verification. In particular, ProVe-Lossless requires two full forward passes of the large model, which introduces substantial computational overhead. It remains unclear whether the benefits of using a large proposer justify this additional cost compared to lightweight parallel drafting approaches. [1] Elhoushi, Mostafa, et al. "Layerskip: Enabling early exit inference and self-speculative decoding." Proceedings of the 62nd Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics (Volume 1: Long Papers). 2024.

Questions for authors

My main question is about addressing the novelty and strength of the proposed method.

Reviewer_b86YOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ProVe (Proposer-Verifier Decoding), which reverses the conventional role assignment of speculative decoding. Building on MARS (Jin et al., 2026), a large model is fine-tuned into a block proposer that predicts the next B tokens in a single forward pass using a block of [MASK] placeholders. A second forward pass then lets a verifier read the realized proposed block before deciding how many tokens to commit. Two variants are introduced: (1)ProVe: a smaller model (3B/7B) serves as the verifier, providing a tunable speed–accuracy tradeoff;(2)ProVe-lossless: the proposer verifies its own block, reproducing its greedy AR decoding token-for-token (exactly lossless). Main experiments (32B Qwen2.5 proposer, six benchmarks): ProVe-lossless reaches 2.54× AR throughput on average. The headline claim is that no separately trained draft head is needed at inference time.

Critical strengths
  1. Clear motivation and clean control. Using MARS as a fixed baseline provides a controlled comparison that isolates the incremental value of the verification step; the methodology is sound.
  2. The losslessness of ProVe-lossless is rigorously argued with an induction proof, and Appendix D verifies the "algorithmically exact" claim via bf16 token-by-token checking. The measurement is credible.
  3. Transparent writing: the Limitations and Measurement Validity sections candidly discuss concurrency degradation, bf16 tie-breaking, and undertraining.
Critical weaknesses

1.Novelty is incremental. The block-proposal capability is inherited from MARS, and the propose-then-verify structure overlaps heavily with concurrent work (IDLM, DFlash, DSpark). The paper does not clearly position its two-pass immediate verification against IDLM's single-pass introspection.

  1. Results measured in a favorable regime. Headline speedups come from single-request latency-bound settings and drop sharply under concurrency (from 3.2× to 1.6× at C=32), limiting representativeness for real serving.

3.Unfair cost comparison and missing baselines. ProVe requires hundreds of GPU-hours to fine-tune the 32B proposer, while EAGLE-3 only trains a small draft head; the "no draft head" framing under-emphasizes this one-time training cost. Moreover, no comparison is made with DSpark or IDLM, both closely related: DSpark and MARS commit on the model's own confidence, while IDLM fuses proposal and verification into a single pass. It is therefore unclear whether ProVe's extra verification pass offers a real advantage over confidence-based block drafting (DSpark/MARS) or single-pass introspection (IDLM).

Questions for authors

NA

Reviewer_8JbBOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes ProVe, a proposer-verifier decoding framework that reverses the conventional roles in speculative decoding. Building upon MARS, a large language model generates multiple candidate tokens in a single forward pass, which are then verified either by a smaller model (ProVe) or by the proposer itself (ProVe-lossless). The authors evaluate both variants across multiple benchmarks, reporting decoding speedups over autoregressive decoding, with ProVe-lossless preserving the original greedy decoding behavior and ProVe allowing a configurable tradeoff between throughput and accuracy.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper explores reversing the conventional proposer-verifier roles in speculative decoding, providing an interesting alternative to small-model drafting.
  2. The authors conduct experiments across multiple benchmarks and investigate several aspects of the proposed method, including verifier size, acceptance thresholds, and serving concurrency.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The block proposal mechanism is directly inherited from MARS, while the verification process largely follows established speculative decoding principles. The main contribution appears to be combining existing block prediction with an additional verification pass and a simple confidence-based acceptance rule. It is unclear whether this represents a sufficiently substantial methodological advancement.

  2. Table 1 shows that fine-tuned EAGLE-3 with a tree of 60 outperforms ProVe-lossless on five out of six benchmarks and achieves slightly higher average throughput (2.58× vs. 2.54×). Although ProVe avoids training a separate draft head, it still requires block-specific fine-tuning of the large proposer. The overall advantage over existing approaches is therefore not sufficiently demonstrated.

  3. Several ProVe configurations using a smaller verifier achieve lower throughput than ProVe-lossless while sacrificing exactness and requiring an additional model. Although more aggressive configurations provide higher throughput, they also introduce accuracy degradation. The practical benefit of small-model verification over self-verification remains insufficiently justified.

  4. Insufficient comparison with existing MTP-based decoding approaches. ProVe-lossless shares a similar design philosophy with existing multi-token prediction (MTP) approaches, where the large model generates multiple candidate tokens and verifies them using its own predictions. However, the paper does not provide sufficient comparisons with representative MTP-based decoding methods under comparable training and inference conditions. Such comparisons would help clarify the novelty and practical advantages of the proposed approach.

  5. Appendix D shows that ProVe's acceleration decreases substantially as concurrency increases. For example, the 3B-verifier configuration drops to approximately 1.3× speedup at 32 concurrent requests. This raises concerns about its effectiveness in practical throughput-oriented LLM serving.

  6. Several figures contain overlapping text, symbols, or annotations, which reduces their readability and overall visual clarity.

Questions for authors
  1. Under what conditions is using a smaller verifier preferable to ProVe-lossless? In particular, how do the authors justify the additional model and potential accuracy degradation when several small-verifier configurations deliver lower throughput than self-verification?

  2. Given that fine-tuned EAGLE-3 achieves slightly higher average throughput and outperforms ProVe-lossless on five of six benchmarks, what are the practical advantages of ProVe in terms of training cost, memory consumption, and deployment complexity?

  3. Could the authors provide a more comprehensive throughput–accuracy Pareto comparison against MARS and other approximate MTP-based decoding methods, particularly under matched accuracy or token-divergence constraints?

If the authors adequately address the above concerns, I would consider raising my rating.

Reviewer_dV8MOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces ProVe, a decoding method that builds on the MARS block proposer. A fine-tuned AR checkpoint proposes a block of tokens in one forward pass. A smaller autoregressive verifier scores each candidate conditioned on the preceding proposed tokens, and a threshold on the product of the two models’ probabilities determines the committed prefix. ProVe-lossless uses the proposer itself to verify the block against its greedy predictions and correct the first mismatch. Across six benchmarks, the paper reports mean throughput of 2.54× greedy AR for ProVe-lossless and 2.72× for ProVe with a stock 3B verifier at the loosest tested threshold, with a 2.6-percentage-point mean task-score drop for the latter.

Critical strengths
  1. Paradigm-Shift in Role Assignment Standard speculative decoding relies on small models for drafting and large models for verification. This paper breaks that convention by assigning parallel block proposals to a fine-tuned target model while offloading verification to a lightweight component.

  2. Dual-Track Verification Design The authors introduce a versatile verification framework that accommodates both strict and flexible operational constraints. ProVe-lossless guarantees exact target equivalence through self-verification, while the thresholded verifier trades a negligible drop in accuracy for substantial throughput gains.

Critical weaknesses

1.The core motivation attribution is not clear: The paper fails to fundamentally explain why it must be "large model proposal and small model verification", rather than directly using the mature paradigm of small model parallel proposal (such as DFlash) combined with large model verification, which is more in line with computational efficiency.

2.The length study lacks a matched MARS baseline. Table 4 varies the number of serial draft steps for standard speculative decoding. Appendix A varies the parallel proposal window only for ProVe-lossless on GSM8K. Table 1 includes MARS at (B=16), but there is no comparison between MARS and small-verifier ProVe across proposal lengths.

3.The ablation experiment on proposal block length lacks a control group: When exploring the impact of proposal window length (Block Size) on throughput, the paper only measured ProVe-lossless and failed to provide a matching comparison of the MARS baseline under the same window.

Questions for authors

1.In formulas and pictures, x≤t is used many times. May I ask, what exactly does t refer to?

2.How are the specific calculation formulas for the probabilities p and q in formulas 1 and 2 derived?

3.Could you provide the main experimental results with Dflash or Dspark as the baseline.

4.Could the comparison of block sizes be refined? For example, the comparison between blocksize = 4,8,16,24 and MARS as the baseline.

5.Could EAGLE-3, Dflash, and Dspark be added as baselines for comparison in the Speculative draft length ablation experiment

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.