- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
This paper introduces SFB-GNN, a self-regulating Fourier–Bayesian graph neural network designed to directly control this perturbation-induced assignment drift. SFB-GNN combines bounded polynomial spectral filtering, Bayesian epistemic uncertainty estimation, and uncertainty-aware adaptive message gating within a closed-loop stability framework. The spectral component limits perturbation amplification during graph propagation, while uncertainty estimates identify structurally vulnerable regions and selectively regulate message passing. To directly stabilize community assignments, we further introduce a permutation-invariant co-assignment consistency objective between clean and perturbed graph views. Experiments on real-world attributed graphs and synthetic graphs with controlled spectral gaps show that SFB-GNN substantially reduces assignment drift under structural and feature perturbations while preserving competitive clustering quality. Ablation and sensitivity analyses confirm that spectral regulation, uncertainty estimation, and adaptive gating provide complementary contributions to stability without inducing representation collapse. These results show that explicitly regulating perturbation propagation and assignment consistency provides an effective approach to reliable community detection under noisy and uncertain graph observations.
Critical strengths
No strengths.
Critical weaknesses
There are a lot of AI-generated content in this manuscript, for example, the large language model prompts the residue of words, the garbled code and low-level spelling errors in the image and text generation, and the most serious false references, as well as unclear experimental results. My advice is to directly desk reject
Questions for authors
No questions.
Response to Reviewer dvwZ
We would verify each remaining reference’s authors, title, publication details and relevance to the cited claim. 3. Experimental traceability. The five appendix seed rows reproduce NMI .512±.011, ARI .421±.010 and AD .087±.006. The table needs the dataset, split, fitted K, perturbation type and severity, and configuration. We would tie each headline value to its run IDs, predictions and aggregation script, including the two no-gate AD results of .096±.007 and .124±.008. The figures and tables should be regenerated from these records. Technical follow-up on the PAT feedback
- Prior work. GraphCL, DCRN and HSAN already use augmented views or cross-view learning. Eq. (9) specifically compares sampled pairwise co-memberships. MetaGC and Zhao et al.’s RAGC are direct robust clustering comparators. DCRN is also relevant to the representation-collapse claim. These comparisons should appear alongside the existing baseline families.
- Implementation. Define Aˉ=D+−1/2(A+I)D+−1/2 and P as the learned assignment projection. Separate sampled hidden states, averaged probe embeddings and gated outputs. Eq. (7) forms a view-level gate from cross-sample statistics, so its index in Eq. (8) should reflect sharing across draws. The appendix describes a0,a1,a2 as learnable. Monotone attenuation requires a1,a2≥0, and the manuscript should specify how their signs are handled. Report the gate schedule, prior variance, temperature, threshold, exact loss weights and the mapping from the grouped spectral weight to Eq. (10). The appendix reports M=20. State whether Eq. (3) used the exact quadratic maximum or a grid.
- Metrics and perturbations.
AD(ρ)=1−NMI(y^clean,y^ρ),ΔNMI(ρ)=NMI(yref,y^clean)−NMI(yref,y^ρ).Specify NMI normalization, VI log base and ECE confidence/correctness. Training views for Eq. (9) are generated from the base graph. Evaluation views use independent draws. Test perturbation Severities Edge rewiring 5%, 10%, 20% Edge dropout 5%, 10%, 20% Gaussian feature noise SD .05, .10, .20 Feature masking 10%, 20%, 30%
Ten test realizations per severity are averaged within each of five training seeds. The appendix reports this rewiring sensitivity. Variant 5% AD↓ 10% AD↓ 20% AD↓ SFB-GNN .052±.004 .087±.006 .154±.011 Without spectral regulation .076±.006 .132±.010 .231±.016 Without Bayesian modeling .069±.005 .118±.009 .209±.015 Without both .091±.008 .161±.013 .274±.021
Section 5.4 should link slope claims to per-severity results for each named method and perturbation. Section 5.5 should cite the corresponding matched table. Table 2 needs its severity or aggregation rule. The 10% structural ablation needs the dataset and exact perturbation type. The DMoN comparison with identical augmentations and Eq. (9) remains open. 4. Version checks. The current Figure 2 shows vertex-time heatmaps. A fixed-graph comparison within each spectral regime is still needed. The current Ethics and Reproducibility Statements name SFB-GNN. We would link reproducibility claims to specific configurations, outputs and scripts, delete the retained-figure wording, and correct Table 2’s dataset header.