- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper observes that temporal variation of activation magnitudes alone cannot reflect quantization vulnerability, and the vulnerability is concentrated on a few layers and channels. It also finds that errors are propagated across transformer blocks, but conventional PTQ methods perform calibration on full-precision inputs. To this end, this paper proposes a trajectory-aware PTQ framework for MDLMs, dubbed TempoQuant. It directly estimates discrepancies of block-wise outputs before and after quantization to estimate the quantization vulnerability of each channel, and uses the vulnerability to learn quantization parameters. It also progressively calibrates blocks on quantized-prefix inputs. Experimental results demonstrate the empirical effectiveness of TempoQuant.
Critical strengths
(+) The authors show the quantization vulnerability of MDLMs through several empirical observations.
(+) Experimental results demonstrate the empirical effectiveness of TempoQuant.
Critical weaknesses
[Novelty]
(-) The progressive quantized-prefix calibration in Eq. (9) appears closely related to existing block-wise reconstruction PTQ methods, such as QDrop, which already calibrate blocks using quantized intermediate representations. It is also conceptually related to prior diffusion PTQ methods that explicitly account for accumulated quantization errors, e.g., [A, B]. The paper should more clearly explain what is specifically new in this calibration strategy beyond adapting sequential reconstruction to MDLM trajectories.
(-) The rotation matrix introduced in Sec. 3.1. is already introduced in prior works (e.g., [C, D]), so I think a related reference should be cited in Sec. 3.1. Since this component does not appear to be specific to TempoQuant, the paper should cite and clearly distinguish it from these prior works.
[Validity]
(-) The connection between the proposed vulnerability measure and the adaptation rule is not sufficiently justified. TempoQuant assigns weaker regularization on to channels with large , allowing their equivalent scales to deviate more from the SmoothQuant-style initialization. However, high target-bit distortion does not necessarily imply that a larger deviation from the initial equivalent scale is desirable. I think an analysis about the relationship between and the learned would strengthen this design choice.
[Related works]
(-) The paper does not provide a discussion of prior works related to the main components of TempoQuant.
[Experiments]
(-) The experiments are conducted only on LLaDA-8B-Instruct. Evaluation on additional masked diffusion language models would be helpful to demonstrate the generality of TempoQuant.
(-) The paper does not provide an ablation study for the individual loss terms in Eq. (10).
[A] AccuQuant: Simulating Multiple Denoising Steps for Quantizing Diffusion Models, NeurIPS 2025
[B] Error Propagation Mechanisms and Compensation Strategies for Quantized Diffusion Models, ICML 2026
[C] SpinQuant: LLM quantization with learned rotations, ICLR 2025
[D] Block Rotation is All You Need for MXFP4 Quantization, ICML 2026
Questions for authors
Please refer to the weaknesses. I will adjust my rating if the authors adequately resolve my concerns.
4 comments
Generalization Across MDLMs and Component-wise Ablation Analysis
W5. Generalization to Additional MDLMs
TempoQuant achieves the highest average accuracy among seven W4A4 quantization methods on Dream-v0-Instruct-7B, extending its evaluation beyond LLaDA-8B-Instruct. We evaluated seven benchmarks against six PTQ baselines under the same evaluation protocol.
| Method | Bits | TruthfulQA | ARC-C | HellaSwag | WinoGrande | PIQA | MMLU | C-EVAL | Average |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| RTN | W4A4 | 53.12 | 25.26 | 24.28 | 49.49 | 49.29 | 26.24 | 23.85 | 35.93 |
| AWQ | W4A4 | 54.83 | 23.38 | 25.39 | 51.22 | 50.82 | 25.72 | 23.70 | 36.44 |
| QuaRot | W4A4 | 46.39 | 24.40 | 24.57 | 48.62 | 49.89 | 25.06 | 25.85 | 34.97 |
| STaR-Quant | W4A4 | 48.59 | 23.29 | 24.64 | 49.72 | 51.14 | 26.31 | 25.26 | 35.56 |
| DLLMQuant+ | W4A4 | 54.10 | 23.89 | 23.87 | 50.43 | 50.05 | 26.43 | 25.85 | 36.37 |
| DLLMQuant++ | W4A4 | 50.18 | 22.18 | 25.02 | 49.01 | 49.18 | 25.57 | 24.74 | 35.13 |
| TempoQuant | W4A4 | 42.84 | 36.77 | 29.67 | 50.51 | 53.86 | 31.52 | 26.97 | 38.88 |
TempoQuant outperforms all six baselines in seven-task average accuracy, improving by 3.75 percentage points over DLLMQuant++ and 2.44 points over AWQ, the strongest competing method. It achieves the best performance on five benchmarks (ARC-C, HellaSwag, PIQA, MMLU, and C-EVAL), although improvements are not uniform across tasks.
These results provide evidence that TempoQuant's masking-aware calibration framework is applicable beyond LLaDA under aggressive W4A4 quantization. The framework estimates target-bit vulnerability for each model and consolidates calibrated equivalent scales and clipping ratios into fixed inference parameters, without requiring timestep-dependent quantizers.
W6. Component-wise and Loss-Term Ablations
Additional W4A4 ablations identify rotation as the dominant contributor to average accuracy, while quantifying the smaller effects of vulnerability-guided adaptation and the CVaR objective. All experiments use LLaDA-8B-Instruct.
| Configuration | Average Accuracy (%) |
|---|---|
| w/o Rotation | 36.52 |
| w/o V-guided Clipping | 50.56 |
| Uniform Regularization (matched) | 50.49 |
| w/o CVaR | 51.15 |
| TempoQuant (Full) | 50.88 |
Removing rotation reduces average accuracy by 14.36 percentage points, confirming the importance of the quantization-friendly representation under W4A4. Removing vulnerability-guided clipping reduces accuracy by 0.32 points, while replacing vulnerability-dependent regularization with strength-matched uniform weights reduces it by 0.39 points.
CVaR targets a different aspect of calibration: high-error reconstruction states rather than average downstream benchmark accuracy. Removing CVaR yields 51.15% versus 50.88% for the full model. Thus, the current results do not establish an independent average-accuracy benefit from CVaR; its intended role is to complement mean reconstruction by explicitly penalizing the upper tail of calibration errors.
Eq. (10) combines mean reconstruction, CVaR, scale regularization, and clipping regularization. The additional experiments assess the CVaR term and vulnerability-dependent regularization, alongside the rotation backbone, rather than independently removing every loss term. We will include these results and clarify the distinct optimization roles and observed accuracy contributions of the components.
Revisions. We will clarify TempoQuant's methodological novelty relative to prior PTQ methods (W1–W2), expand the analysis of vulnerability-guided adaptation and its comparison with uniform regularization (W3), and strengthen the Related Work discussion (W4).
We will also incorporate the additional Dream results (W5) and component-wise ablations (W6), clarifying the distinct roles and empirical contributions of rotation, vulnerability-guided regularization, and CVaR. Throughout the manuscript, we will refine the exposition to improve methodological clarity and readability.
Thank you for the detailed responses and additional experiments. I appreciate the authors' efforts to address my concerns, which adequately address my concerns regarding W2, W4, and W5.
However, my main concerns remain unresolved. In particular, the additional ablation results show that Rotation-only (52.06%) outperforms the full TempoQuant framework (50.88%), while removing CVaR further improves accuracy to 51.15%. Moreover, vulnerability-guided regularization provides only a modest improvement (+0.39%p) over uniform regularization.
As the authors acknowledge that rotation and progressive quantized-prefix calibration build upon existing PTQ techniques, the novelty of TempoQuant primarily lies in its vulnerability-guided adaptation. However, the additional experiments do not sufficiently demonstrate the effectiveness of this component, suggesting that the overall methodological contribution is rather limited.
Although the authors have clarified the role of vulnerability in controlling adaptation freedom, the additional analyses do not sufficiently demonstrate its efficiency. Therefore, I will maintain my original rating.
We thank the reviewer for their careful reassessment and for acknowledging that our additional experiments address W2, W4, and W5.
We recognize the remaining concern regarding the contribution of vulnerability-guided adaptation. While its accuracy gains are modest and not consistent across all configurations, our intended contribution is a masking-state-aware calibration framework that explicitly incorporates quantization vulnerability across denoising states. We will clarify its distinction from existing PTQ techniques, transparently report the limitations, and moderate our claims accordingly. We appreciate the reviewer's constructive feedback throughout the discussion.
Clarification of Novelty, Vulnerability-Guided Adaptation, and Related Work
W1–W2. Novelty and Relationship to Prior PTQ Methods
TempoQuant's contribution lies in target-bit vulnerability-guided calibration across MDLM masking states, rather than rotation or progressive reconstruction individually. The fixed block-Hadamard rotation and quantized-prefix reconstruction build on established PTQ techniques, including SpinQuant, Block Rotation, QDrop, AccuQuant, and diffusion error-compensation methods.
The key distinction is how MDLM-specific quantization vulnerability is measured and used. TempoQuant directly measures channel-wise computation distortion under joint target-bit weight–activation quantization across masking ratios and masked/unmasked token groups (Eqs. 4–5). Unlike activation-statistics-based indicators, this measure captures the actual target-bit computation discrepancy. On held-out trajectories, its Spearman correlation with deployment distortion reaches 0.7774 (W8A8) and 0.7506 (W4A4), versus 0.6335 and 0.6152 for temporal variation.
This vulnerability guides equivalent-scale and clipping regularization (Eqs. 6–8), while progressive calibration reconstructs full-precision block outputs from quantized-prefix inputs (Eq. 9). The latter addresses upstream error propagation; Figure 5 reports representation-gap reductions of 26.1% and 24.0% at masking ratios 0.3 and 0.5.
Together, these mechanisms incorporate heterogeneous masking-state information into a single static quantization configuration, without timestep-dependent parameter selection at inference. We will clarify that the novelty lies in the MDLM-specific vulnerability formulation and its integration into calibration, not in rotation or sequential reconstruction alone.
W3. Validity of Vulnerability-Guided Adaptation
Vulnerability guidance relaxes the constraint on scale adaptation without prescribing the direction or magnitude of the update. In Eqs. (6–7), higher vulnerability reduces the regularization weight on the scale residual, while reconstruction determines the learned adjustment. Thus, high vulnerability does not imply that a larger deviation from initialization is necessarily optimal.
We examined vulnerability, learned scale deviation, and relative distortion reduction on LLaDA-8B-Instruct under W4A4.
The results distinguish vulnerability estimation from the adaptation it permits. Learned scale deviations show negligible monotonic correlation with vulnerability, consistent with reconstruction-driven rather than prescribed adjustments. Relative distortion reduction generally increases from low- to high-vulnerability deciles, but similar trends persist under uniform regularization. This supports an association between vulnerability and channel-level distortion response without attributing the trend solely to guided weighting.
To assess its downstream contribution, we compared TempoQuant with a strength-matched uniform-regularization control, which preserves aggregate regularization strength while removing vulnerability-dependent weights. TempoQuant achieves 50.88% versus 50.49% average accuracy, providing a modest empirical advantage for guided weighting within the complete framework.
We will incorporate these analyses and clarify that vulnerability determines adaptation freedom, while reconstruction determines the learned scale adjustments.
W4. Related Work
We will expand the Related Work discussion to explicitly position TempoQuant against rotation-based PTQ, block-wise reconstruction, diffusion error compensation, and existing MDLM quantization methods, distinguishing established techniques from our target-bit vulnerability formulation and masking-state-aware calibration.