acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Endpoint Relations Extend Quantitative Readouts

Abstract

Reading familiar quantities is different from extending their scale. We study whether relations anchored to observed values can improve predictions beyond the range used to train a language-model readout. We learn a relation between distance from a source endpoint and nearby values, then use it to correct a global reader without new-range labels. Across four ordered tasks and 48 checkpoints, normalized absolute error decreases from 0.714 to 0.632, an 11.45% reduction, after selecting the global reader by its final prediction loss. The intact relation also outperforms controls that preserve the endpoint while disrupting the other pairings. Comparisons using the same features locate the useful ingredient: fitting the radius on all source values reduces error further to 0.529, and simple direct readers capture much of the gain. Controlled metric experiments then separate accessible quantity information from a distance that organizes it and a relation that continues across ranges. Together, these results show that quantitative extrapolation depends on the relation used to read a representation, and that endpoint relations can expose variation a global reader leaves unused.

Primary area:
interpretability and explainable AI
Keywords:
representation probing, quantitative extrapolation, language models, interpretability, representation geometry, readout probes

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_LECbOpenReview ↗
Rating
2(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2(+1)
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper presents an interesting perspective on quantitative extrapolation and includes careful experimental controls. However, the methodological contribution remains limited, as simpler regression alternatives achieve stronger performance and several components of the proposed correction are not convincingly justified. Furthermore, the main improvements are concentrated on a small set of numerical tasks and do not consistently transfer to more diverse quantitative representations.

Critical strengths
  1. The paper investigates whether endpoint-relative relationships can improve numerical predictions beyond the supervised range, providing an interesting perspective on quantitative information encoded in language-model representations.
  2. The distinction between information accessibility, distance alignment, and extrapolation provides useful insights into why recoverable numerical information does not necessarily translate into reliable out-of-range predictions.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The proposed approach primarily combines existing regression techniques with endpoint-relative distances and residual correction. More importantly, simpler alternatives such as direct radius regression and all-source fitting achieve substantially better performance, while removing residual detrending also improves the results, raising questions about the necessity of the proposed design.
  2. The proposed correction provides negligible improvements on entity attributes and even degrades performance on some unseen numerical notations, limiting the evidence that the approach generalizes beyond the specific experimental settings.
Questions for authors

1.Given that simpler direct regression methods outperform the proposed correction, what is the unique methodological advantage of the proposed framework? 2.What explains the substantial differences between the core numerical tasks and the entity-attribute and alternative-notation experiments? 3.How sensitive are the results to the global reader's extensive hyperparameter selection, particularly given the small number of source observations and pseudo-validation examples?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to LECb on baselines, task differences, and selection

Thank you for asking about the direct baselines and source selection. The revision measures what endpoint distance contributes to a particular reader and tests how that contribution changes across validation blocks.

Q1. What endpoint distance adds. Section 4 distinguishes scaling the reader’s existing gaps from adding a distinct pattern of gaps. In Table 1, the original correction improves pair nMAE relative to standalone boundary-radius ridge (0.5923 vs. 0.6048). The direct ridge gives point nMAE of 0.5349, compared with 0.6324 for the original correction. Fitting the radial component on all source items brings point and pair nMAE to 0.5289 and 0.5554. The variant without detrending gives 0.6216 and 0.5910. The point-error contrast between intact and permuted correspondence for the selected simple reader is +0.000747 (95% interval [−0.002565, +0.004731]). These comparisons show how the effect of an endpoint measurement depends on the starting reader and fitting support.

Q2. Differences across tasks. The Roman numeral and duration prompts state the target quantity explicitly. The entity prompts ask for a property of the named entity. In the notation panel, point nMAE is 0.5307 for the final-loss-selected reader and 0.5372 with the fixed correction. In the matched entity panel, replacing Euclidean distance with PLS raises the radial component’s mean gain from 0.000652 to 0.000749 for the ridge reader and changes it from 0.000288 to −0.000336 for the PLS reader (Table 2). In four upper birth- and death-year conditions, a probe trained within the held range recovers variation and beats the endpoint constant on both point and pair error. The source-trained probes have larger point errors than the constant in these four conditions. The matched comparison separates recoverability from transfer on the same representations.

Q3. Sensitivity to source selection. The global reader’s mean point nMAE improves under both final-loss selection (0.7141 to 0.6324) and upstream-loss selection (0.7189 to 0.6345). The two objectives select different nominal configurations in 376 of 384 conditions. In the re-extraction, changing which items enter the validation score changes the held forecast in 29 of 50 single-item deletions for the global reader and 32 of 50 for the simple reader, with candidate fits fixed (Appendix G). In upper percentages, the gain of joint ridge over pooled direct prediction is +0.2582 on a near-boundary block and −0.5963 farther inside, with four training labels and three validation items in each block (Section 5.5). The matched counts show that the choice of validation items matters in its own right.

Thanks for your constructive answers. I have increased my score correspondingly.

Reviewer_wXqoOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

The authors propose a method to extend linear probe readouts out of distribution. They leverage Euclidean distances to known numerical endpoints' representations to do this. This technique shows an 11.45% improvement over a global baseline without a correction.

Critical strengths

The paper carefully documents experimental protocols, controls, etc. It appears to be much more reproducible than average.

Critical weaknesses
  • This paper is very poorly written, with no narrative arc or point of view. I believe it to be fully AI-generated. In particular, no reason is given why the reader should care about this line of research, technique, or results presented within.
  • The results are underwhelming: 11.45% improvement over the global baseline, but simple regression on the radial feature beats the authors' proposed correction.
Questions for authors

N/A

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to wXqo on the motivation and main findings

The revised introduction starts with a concrete reason to study numerical differences. In the vehicle panel, shifting every prediction by the same amount lowers point nMAE from 1.3342 to 1.2020 and preserves every predicted gap. When a reader is used to compare two vehicles, the predicted gap is itself an outcome worth measuring.

Section 4 shows how endpoint distance can rescale existing gaps or add a new pattern of gaps. Section 5 tests whether the relation still measures differences across a numerical boundary. On the same frozen representations in one upper death-year condition, PLS trained within the held range obtains 0.156 pair nMAE under blocked cross-validation. The source-trained fit gives 0.445 and the endpoint constant gives 0.177 (Table 3). Four upper birth- and death-year conditions show the same separation between held-local recoverability and source-to-held transfer. This gives a direct test of how much numerical variation the representation supports and how much a readout trained on another range recovers.

Table 1 puts the direct radius reader and the correction side by side. Direct radius regression gives 0.5349 point nMAE, compared with 0.6324 for the original correction. The original correction gives 0.5923 pair nMAE, compared with 0.6048 for direct radius regression. Table 4 extends the comparison to joint direct readers given the same additional observations. The gains in mean pair nMAE for Pythia and SmolLM2 are 0.0068 and 0.0129, respectively, with both 95% intervals spanning zero. The appendices describe the experimental protocols and provenance.

Reviewer_DWNTOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates whether endpoint-relative relations can improve quantitative extrapolation from frozen language-model representations beyond the numerical range used for probe supervision. The authors propose a source-only correction that fits a relation between representation distance from an observed endpoint and nearby target values, removes the source-linear component of its disagreement with a global reader, and adds the resulting residual to the global prediction.

Across four ordered tasks and 48 checkpoints, the proposed correction reduces normalized MAE from 0.7141 to 0.6324 (an 11.45% relative reduction), improving 358 out of 384 evaluated conditions. Endpoint-preserving permutation controls suggest that the correspondence among source observations contributes information beyond the endpoint anchor itself.

The paper further compares the method with stronger direct readers and alternative fitting supports. These experiments show that fitting the radius using all source observations and employing simpler readout models can achieve substantially lower errors. Additional geometry experiments distinguish quantity information accessible in representations, its alignment with a particular distance metric, and the ability of a learned relation to extrapolate beyond the source range.

Overall, the paper provides a controlled empirical investigation of how readout choices affect quantitative extrapolation, while also identifying important limitations in the generality of the proposed correction.

Critical strengths

S1. Carefully controlled evidence for reader-dependent extrapolation improvements.

The paper provides a systematic evaluation across 48 checkpoints, four ordered tasks, and both extrapolation directions. The primary result shows an 11.45% relative reduction in normalized MAE, with improvements in 358/384 conditions. Importantly, the authors select the global baseline using its complete prediction loss and introduce endpoint-preserving permutation controls. The intact relation outperforms this control (0.6324 vs. 0.6453 nMAE), providing evidence that non-endpoint correspondences contribute useful information for the tested global reader. These controls make the empirical observation more convincing than a simple baseline comparison.

S2. Informative analysis separating representation information, measurement geometry, and extrapolation.

A particularly valuable aspect of the paper is its investigation of why a quantity may be recoverable from a representation without being reliably extrapolated by a particular reading rule. The comparisons with direct readers, broader fitting support, and alternative distance metrics reveal important dependencies on the starting reader and measurement geometry. The authors also report negative and inconclusive results, including the limited correspondence-specific advantage over stronger readers and unsuccessful transfer to some new task families. These analyses provide useful insights into the limitations of quantitative probing and help distinguish information accessibility from extrapolation capability.

Critical weaknesses

W1. Limited incremental contribution beyond simpler strong baselines and restricted evidence of transfer.

Although the proposed endpoint correction improves the selected global reader, the stronger comparisons substantially narrow its methodological contribution. In Table 2, the headline correction achieves 0.6324 nMAE, whereas standalone boundary-radius ridge achieves 0.5349 and the selected simple reader achieves 0.5311. Moreover, the intact relation does not establish a correspondence-specific advantage over the endpoint-preserving control when applied to the stronger simple reader (0.512280 vs. 0.511533, with a confidence interval including zero). Table 6 further shows that removing detrending improves nMAE from 0.632372 to 0.621606, raising questions about the predictive necessity of this component.

The authors acknowledge these results, and they do not invalidate the demonstrated improvement over the original global reader. Nevertheless, they suggest that much of the benefit may arise from introducing a useful radial measurement rather than from the specific residual-correction construction.

The external validity of the main result is also limited. The core evaluation contains only four short ordered task lists, and additional checkpoints do not introduce independent task identities. The fixed correction slightly worsens the final-loss-selected notation result (0.530745 to 0.537236), while its improvement on the matched entity-attribute panel is small and statistically unresolved. Stronger evidence is needed to establish when the proposed relation transfers beyond the original controlled setting.

W2. Insufficient specification of important geometry statistics and the original hyperparameter-selection protocol.

The geometry analysis in Figure 5B and Table 17 reports distance-attribute Spearman correlations, but the manuscript does not explicitly define whether these correlations use raw target values, absolute displacement from the endpoint, or direction-adjusted targets. This distinction matters because source and held observations occupy opposite sides of the endpoint. Even in a perfectly monotonic scalar representation, correlating unsigned endpoint distance with raw target values can produce opposite signs on the source and extrapolation sides. Without a precise definition and direction-wise results, it is difficult to determine how much of the reported loss of alignment reflects genuine geometric failure rather than the chosen correlation convention. The same issue may affect interpretation of the source-correlation gate in Appendix F.2.

Additionally, Section 4.1 states that the frozen local configuration was selected using 17 other task identities, but the manuscript does not clearly document the original task roster, candidate grid, selection objective, or aggregation procedure. These details are important for assessing the separation between development and evaluation and for reproducing the frozen configuration. Both concerns appear potentially resolvable through clarification and additional experimental documentation.

Questions for authors

Q1. Clarification of the geometry statistics.

Could the authors provide the exact mathematical definition of the "distance-attribute Spearman" statistic reported in Figure 5B and Table 17? In particular, is endpoint distance correlated with the raw target, absolute endpoint displacement, or a direction-adjusted target? Please report the correlations separately for lower- and upper-range extrapolation and clarify whether the correlation gate in Appendix F.2 uses the same convention. This would help establish whether the observed loss of held-range alignment reflects a failure of geometric continuation rather than a sign-convention artifact.

Q2. Reproducibility of the original configuration selection.

Section 4.1 mentions 17 development task identities used to choose the frozen local configuration. Could the authors specify these tasks, the original hyperparameter search space, the validation objective, and the aggregation procedure across tasks and checkpoints? Were any of the later notation or entity-attribute evaluations included in this development roster? A reference to the relevant supplementary records would be sufficient if these details are already available.

Q3. Distinctive contribution of the residual correction.

Given that standalone radial readers substantially outperform the headline correction and that removing detrending improves the primary nMAE, what empirical advantage is specifically attributable to the proposed residual-detrending construction? Is detrending primarily intended to provide a more interpretable decomposition, or does it improve a measurable prediction or robustness property under some conditions? Clarifying this distinction would substantially strengthen the contribution and its positioning relative to simpler readout approaches.

Q4. Generalization and evidence supporting a stronger recommendation.

Can the authors provide additional evidence that endpoint-relative correspondence remains useful beyond the original short-list tasks or when combined with a strong starting reader? A focused evaluation using a frozen, source-only selection protocol and competitive direct-readout baselines would be particularly valuable. Alternatively, a convincing demonstration of when the intact relation offers a reproducible advantage over endpoint-preserving controls for stronger readers could strengthen the mechanistic contribution.

I am currently leaning toward acceptance and would be willing to reconsider my recommendation upward if the rebuttal resolves the statistical and methodological ambiguities and provides convincing evidence that strengthens either the generalization or the distinctive contribution of the proposed relation.

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to DWNT on geometry, development, and transfer

Thank you for the detailed questions. The revised geometry analysis shows a clear directional pattern, and the development appendix documents the retained configuration and selection records.

Q1. Geometry statistic. We compute the Spearman correlation of endpoint distance with absolute target displacement from the endpoint, using average ranks for ties. We exclude the endpoint itself from the source statistic. The original gate applies the same statistic to the remaining items in the Euclidean fitting tail and uses a threshold of 0.5.

The fresh extraction gives Euclidean and PLS correlations of 0.0565 and 0.0559 in lower extrapolation, and 0.1049 and −0.0860 in upper extrapolation. In the upper range, the mean absolute correlation increases from 0.1736 to 0.1922, and the change in sign reveals a shift in orientation. Refitting the metric within each fold gives mean signed correlations of 0.1927 and 0.3831 in random source validation and 0.0230 and −0.0486 in directional source validation, for Euclidean and PLS respectively. Section 5.1 and Appendix E report the fresh directional analyses alongside the historical pooled results.

Q2. Development selection. Appendix F lists the 17 development tasks, 15 checkpoint IDs, retained objective and selected configuration, and the predecessor grid. The predecessor implementation averages checkpoints and directions within each task and minimizes the worst task mean. The development roster is separate from the four core tasks and the later notation and entity-attribute tasks. The historical final-selection record consists of the selected configuration and its scores. The grid and aggregation are documented for the predecessor.

Q3. Detrending. With the variance floor inactive, detrending makes the source update orthogonal to the starting score. Section 4's decomposition applies to both settings. Table 1 gives point and pair nMAE of 0.6324 and 0.5923 for the original correction, and 0.6216 and 0.5910 for the variant without detrending.

Q4. Correspondence and transfer. On the original global reader, intact correspondence lowers pair nMAE from 0.6015 under endpoint-preserving permutation to 0.5923. On park acreage, the gain against matched permutations is 0.0186 (95% interval [0.0033, 0.0338]). The gain against the selected direct reader is 0.0044 (95% interval [−0.0126, 0.0204]). On the original four lists, the Pythia and SmolLM2 blends both improve lower numbers and upper percentages relative to pooled direct prediction. Their mean gains over joint ridge with the same observations are 0.0068 (95% interval [−0.0408, 0.0427]) and 0.0129 ([−0.0282, 0.0440]), respectively (Table 4). We fixed the blend rule after scoring Pythia and used it for SmolLM2 on the same tasks.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.