- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposed a nonlinear functional DAG model for multivariate functional data. They use basis expansion and impose a nonlinear DAG model on each basis coefficient. The identifiability is largely based on existing nonlinear DAG result, which seems almost immediate to me. Then they propose an estimation method with consistency results.
Critical strengths
The consistency results appear rigorous.
Critical weaknesses
My main concern is the lack of methodological novelty. While the nonlinear functional DAG is new (if I have not missed any existing relevant work), its formulation is quite straightforward and expected. It seems to be really just applying ANM (in fact, it should be CAM because ANM allows non-additive causes, but this paper doesn't) multiple times, once to each basis coefficient, and taking the union of each individual resulting DAG. Although they do provide an estimation procedure and its associated consistency result, I don't think this clears the bar of this conference.
Questions for authors
In addition to concern about novelty, a few other questions I had while reading the paper are below.
- The paper assumes independence basis coefficients. Is that something implied from orthonormal basis or it is an additional assumption? If it is the latter, how to justify such assumption.
- The authors mentioned in Remark 1 that "We assume that the model is not directly formulated as an arbitrary ANM in the time domain as Equation 1, but rather under a partial separability basis as Equations 4 and 5". What's the connection between these two formulations?
- The union rule in (7) and (8) seems prone to false discoveries.
- Is it reasonable to assume X and E live in the same space given the nonlinear mapping?