acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Detecting Implicit Sarcasm in Speech by Cross-modal Reasoning with Multi-source Knowledge

Abstract

This paper focuses on detecting complex sarcasm emotions in speech. Simple emotions like happiness can be directly judged based on acoustic signals in speech. By contrast, sarcasm involves a conflict between surface features and underlying intention, e.g., using positive words to convey sadness. That is hard to detect by the sound or words alone. Moreover, implicit sarcasm often involves external knowledge related to commonsense, plots, scenes, etc., which is not presented in the given speech, resulting in insufficient clues for inferring the conflict. To solve these issues, we propose a new reasonable framework. We first encode the text and acoustic features in speech, and grasp their subtle correlations. That helps to find potential sarcastic conflicts in the heterogeneous space. We then retrieve the missing textual and prosodic knowledge related to the speech. They are necessary clues for inferring conflicts and are used to build an emotional graph. Based on it, we deduce a conflict chain between the literal words, true intention, and knowledge constraints by reinforced multi-hop inference. This chain can help to identify implicit sarcasm more accurately and explainably. Moreover, we create a large-scale dataset called AEbSD to conduct extensive evaluations. The results show our effectiveness and reliability.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
Speech processing, sarcastic emotional speech, cross-modal Reasoning

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_YyN7OpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper focuses on the problem of detecting implicit sarcasm in speech. In such cases, the speaker's true attitude may not be consistent with the text content and the phonetic rhythm, and the necessary background information may not be directly presented in the speech. The framework proposed by the authors combines text and acoustic representations, decouples rhythm, integrates enhanced text and rhythm knowledge through retrieval, and employs graph-structured multi-hop conflict reasoning optimized by reinforcement learning. The authors also constructed the AEbSD dataset, which contains 10,834 audio-text samples sorted from audio books, with a relatively balanced category distribution. The experimental report shows the improvement of this method over the baseline on AEbSD, the ablation results of each module, and the evaluation results on IEMOCAP, MELD, and MUStARD++.

Critical strengths
  1. This paper focuses on the problem of implicit sarcasm detection in speech and accordingly creates the AEbSD dataset for this task, providing 10,834 audio-text samples, which has promoted the research on this task.
  2. The method proposed in this paper treats acoustic-text interaction, external knowledge, and conflict reasoning as interrelated components, thereby more accurately inferring the implicit sarcastic emotions. This method is compared with multiple baselines, and ablation analyses are conducted for prosodic decoupling, token-level correlation acquisition, RAG module, and reinforced reasoning module. These results preliminarily support the role of the proposed modules.
Critical weaknesses
  1. This paper reports the general hardware configuration, training duration and inference time on the test set, but no systematic efficiency experiments have been conducted yet. This method involves various components such as frozen LLM, LoRA reinforcement learning strategy, external knowledge retrieval, etc. The computational cost should not be low. Currently, there is a lack of comparison with the baseline in terms of parameter quantity, GPU memory usage, FLOPs, end-to-end latency, throughput, and external LLM/retrieval call costs, and the actual deployment cost remains unclear.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide more detailed efficiency experiments, including model parameters, peak memory, FLOPs, single-sample end-to-end delay, throughput, and time overhead of modules such as knowledge retrieval, LLM knowledge generation, and graph construction?
  2. Can the author provide a concise name for the method?
Reviewer_XYGXOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes a knowledge-augmented framework for detecting implicit sarcasm in speech through text–audio conflict modeling and reinforced graph reasoning, and introduces an dataset for speech sarcasm detection evaluation.

Critical strengths

The authors introduce a large speech sarcasm detection dataset, and propose a method that incorporates commonsense knowledge to detect implicit sarcasm in speech. The paper presents substantial workload and basically supports the proposed idea.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The introduction part is not well structured. Problem formulation and motivation are vague and repetitive, and the contributions are not clearly articulated. The paper introduces the proposed method before clearly establishing the speech sarcasm detection task and its motivation, which makes the presentation confusing. Also, the two challenges identified by the authors: implicitness and the need for commonsense knowledge, also exist in textual and multimodal sarcasm detection and have been extensively studied, yet the authors do not discuss these relevant methods.
  2. The paper lacks comparisons with closely related work. Existing benchmarks such as PodSarc [1], MCSD [2], and MuSaG [3] also foucus on speech sarcasm detection. However, the authors neither explain the differences between AEbSD and these benchmarks nor evaluate their proposed method on them.
  3. The task provides models with both audio and transcript text, but the authors do not conduct modality ablations to isolate their respective contributions. Since the paper introduces a task in addition to a method, modality ablations are needed at both the model and dataset levels to establish how the proposed model and task depend on information from each modality.
  4. A minor concern is that many claims and descriptions of prior approaches in the introduction lack supporting citations.

[1] Li, Z., Zhang, Y., Gao, X., Nayak, S., & Coler, M. (2025). Leveraging large language models for sarcastic speech annotation in sarcasm detection. arXiv preprint arXiv:2506.00955.

[2] Gao, X., Wang, B. X., Zhang, M., Huang, S., Li, Z., Nayak, S., & Coler, M. (2025). A multimodal chinese dataset for cross-lingual sarcasm detection. In 26th Interspeech Conference 2025 (pp. 3968-3972). ISCA.

[3] Scott, A., Züfle, M., & Niehues, J. (2026, May). Musag: A multimodal german sarcasm dataset with full-modal annotations. In Proceedings of the Fifteenth Language Resources and Evaluation Conference (LREC 2026) (Vol. 11, No. 16, pp. 372-392).

Questions for authors
  • How does AEbSD differ from existing speech sarcasm detection datasets? Why is constructing another dataset necessary rather than evaluating the proposed method on existing datasets?
  • The authors claim interpretability as one of their main contributions, but this aspect is insufficiently explained in the methodology. Which specific components make the method interpretable, and how do they provide that interpretability?
Reviewer_C9FLOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses implicit sarcasm detection in speech by combining text, acoustic cues, and external commonsense knowledge. The framework includes fine-grained text-prosody incongruity modeling, retrieval-augmented LLM knowledge generation, emotion-graph construction, and PPO-based multi-hop reasoning to derive a sarcastic conflict chain. The authors also introduce AEbSD, an audiobook-derived dataset of 10,834 speech-text pairs built from LibriVox recordings and Project Gutenberg transcripts. Experiments show gains over several baselines, supported by ablations, results on IEMOCAP, MELD, and MUStARD++, human evaluation of reasoning chains and retrieved knowledge, and case studies.

Critical strengths
  1. Implicit sarcasm in speech requires reasoning beyond surface words and tone, which is a meaningful problem for multimodal language understanding.
  2. Integrating text-prosody incongruity, multi-source knowledge, emotion graphs, and reinforced path selection is an ambitious and interpretable design.
  3. The model achieves 76.20 F1 on AEbSD, compared with 69.71 for Qwen-Audio and 69.15 for GPT-4o, and reports gains on IEMOCAP, MELD, and MUStARD++ (Tables 1-2).
  4. The paper includes ablations, sensitivity studies, knowledge-source comparisons, human evaluations of chains and knowledge, and an honest failure-case analysis.
Critical weaknesses
  1. Positives are defined by cross-modal incongruity and knowledge dependency, which are exactly what the method models. Appendix B is contradictory: cases identifiable without knowledge are "excluded", but any candidate failing a criterion is labeled "non-sarcastic", so explicit sarcasm may sit in the negative class. In addition, the GPT-4o pre-filter rewards "exaggerated intonation" and text that "contains ironic elements" (Prompt 2), which conflicts with the definition of implicit sarcasm. Audiobook prosody also reflects the volunteer reader's interpretation rather than a speaker's intention; the main case study (Figure 4, "They were careless people") reads as literal criticism or understatement rather than sarcasm.

  2. The 7:2:1 split is not stated to be disjoint by audiobook, reader, or story, although the data come from only 247 books. Because the sources are famous public-domain novels and knowledge is retrieved from Wikipedia and LLMs, retrieved plot summaries and literary interpretations may reveal the intended reading, so gains may partly reflect book recall rather than sarcasm detection.

  3. The proposed model uses retrieved knowledge (and possibly the Stage 4 speaker and relation metadata), while GPT-4o and Qwen-Audio receive only raw audio and transcripts. It is also unclear whether the other baselines were trained on AEbSD; the LTU-AS details describe its original pretraining. GPT-4o is used both to build the dataset and as a baseline. Knowledge-matched LLM baselines are needed to isolate the contribution of the graph and reasoning components.

  4. Replacing PPO-based chains with full-graph input lowers accuracy by only about 1.8 points (76.85 to 75.03, Figure 3a), and no simpler path-selection alternatives are tested. Removing part of the retrieval module (71.76) hurts more than removing all of it (72.29), which is counterintuitive. The chain evaluation measures plausibility rather than faithfulness, and its "path completeness" criterion checks for coverage of words, knowledge, and prosody, the structure the method enforces by design (Appendix C).

  5. In Table 2, SpeechPrompt v2 reports weighted precision 78.33, recall 58.06, and F1 73.47. Under standard weighted definitions, weighted F1 cannot exceed the average of weighted precision and recall (about 68.2), so these values are impossible. Copied baselines are reported with standard deviations "over 5 independent runs"; PredGaze has identical P/R/F1 (71.06), and the model's MUStARD++ precision (75.77) exactly matches its AEbSD precision in Table 1.

Questions for authors
  1. Are the AEbSD splits disjoint by audiobook, reader, and story? Can you report results on a book-disjoint split, and on non-literary speech?
  2. Were explicit sarcastic cases excluded or labeled non-sarcastic? How were irony, understatement, and the reader's prosody (vs the character's intent) handled during annotation?
  3. Can you evaluate GPT-4o or another strong multimodal LLM given the same retrieved knowledge, context, and metadata as your model, and clarify how each baseline was trained on AEbSD?
  4. How does PPO-based reasoning compare with greedy, beam-search, or relevance-ranked path selection under identical conditions, and how are graph paths converted into natural-language chains?
  5. How were the weighted metrics in Table 2 computed, and were the baseline numbers and standard deviations rerun or copied from prior work?

Comments on the paper

3 comments

Thank you for the clarification. However, the authors did not directly answer my questions, and my main concerns still remain largely unresolved.

  1. PDis and CroA experiments are component ablations rather than modality ablations. Removing a prosody-processing or cross-modal-alignment module does not remove the audio modality. The paper still lacks text-only, audio-only, and text+audio comparisons, as well as the requested dataset-level analysis showing whether AEbSD genuinely requires information from both modalities rather than lexical, work-, speaker-, or narrator-specific cues.

  2. Describing PodSarc, MCSD, MuSaG, and AEbSD as coming from different domains does not establish why another dataset is necessary. A systematic comparison of their modalities, context, annotation criteria, sarcasm types, speakers, splits, and scale is still missing. The MUStARD++ experiment is useful, but it does not replace evaluation on, or a concrete explanation for not evaluating on, the three closely related spoken-sarcasm benchmarks raised in the review.

  3. Pointing to citations in the Related Work section does not address the unsupported claims about prior approaches made in the Introduction, nor does the response resolve the organizational and novelty concerns about the task motivation.

  4. The response explains that the selected graph path is exposed to readers and provides a human evaluation of path completeness, conflict validity, and coherence. This partially clarifies the intended interpretability. However, these metrics primarily measure explanation plausibility, not faithfulness to the model's decision. The reported κ measures annotator agreement rather than explanation correctness. Intervention-based evidence, such as path sufficiency/comprehensiveness or removing critical path nodes, would be needed to support the stronger interpretability claim.

Thank you for further clarifying your concerns. We respond as follows.

  1. To directly examine the respective roles of text and audio, we conducted additional text-only, audio-only, and text+audio comparisons. Using the same data splits and consistent training settings, the three configurations achieved F1 scores of 71.20, 68.40, and 76.18, respectively. Joint input improved F1 over the two unimodal configurations by 4.98% and 7.78%, respectively. These results could not be presented in detail in the main text due to space constraints, so we provide them here. These comparisons examine the information contributed by each modality, while the PDis and CroA ablations in Figure 3a further examine the contributions of prosodic processing and word–prosody correlation. Therefore, these two sets of experiments support our design for jointly using text and audio to detect implicit sarcasm at the levels of input information and processing mechanisms, respectively.

  2. The annotation criteria of existing datasets make it difficult to directly support targeted training and evaluation for our task. PodSarc provides general sarcasm annotations, MCSD further considers annotation certainty, and MuSaG provides modality-specific judgments. However, their existing labels do not directly distinguish whether sarcasm recognition depends on cross-modal incongruity and background knowledge beyond the clip. Our task requires both conditions to be explicitly annotated so that we can examine whether a model identifies implicit attitudes by combining speech, text, and background information. We therefore aligned audiobook recordings with their source texts and incorporated cross-modal incongruity and knowledge dependency into manual screening, constructing AEbSD with 10,834 samples. Thus, AEbSD provides training and evaluation data consistent with our task definition, while MUStARD++ provides further validation in an external setting.

  3. In Related Work, we traced the development of textual and spoken sarcasm detection methods. Traditional text-based methods primarily identify semantic and emotional incongruity through lexical and syntactic features, context, and commonsense knowledge. Speech-based methods introduce acoustic information such as intonation, stress, and speaking rate for feature matching and classification, but primarily target explicit sarcasm characterized by clear sarcastic wording or exaggerated intonation. However, in real-world applications, people often express themselves indirectly: both wording and intonation may appear ordinary, and understanding the sarcastic meaning requires background context. This requires understanding multiple aspects, including specific words, local prosody, and background knowledge, to infer the implicit conflict between the surface expression and the underlying intention. Yet such complex scenarios remain less studied. To address this, we focused on this task, designed word–prosody correlation, knowledge augmentation, and conflict-path reasoning, and constructed AEbSD to provide corresponding evaluation conditions.

  4. Our interpretability claim concerns the traceability of the evidence used by the model and the quality of its explanations. Section 2.1 links words to their corresponding speech segments, and Section 2.3 encodes the selected path before passing it to the classifier. This allows readers to inspect the path used in the classification process and trace its word and prosodic nodes back to the original input. Appendix C.2 evaluates 200 samples, with path completeness, conflict validity, and coherence scores of 89.5, 85.0, and 95.0, respectively. The κ value of 0.79 reflects agreement among the three annotators. Therefore, the model structure and human evaluation provide evidence for traceability and explanation quality, respectively, jointly supporting our claims of path inspectability and explanation plausibility.

I appreciate the substantial effort invested in constructing the dataset and developing the proposed framework.

Nevertheless, I feel that the current version would benefit from further polishing and, more importantly, additional validation of the dataset's positioning, as well as cross-dataset generalizability before the main conclusions can be supported with sufficient confidence.

I therefore maintain my original score at this stage.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.