acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Behavioral Traits as Privileged Supervision for Self-Distilled Reasoning

Abstract

Behavioral traits are commonly studied as alignment targets for large language models. These general dispositions also shape how models approach reasoning and problem solving, motivating their use as reusable teaching principles. We propose trait-guided on-policy self-distillation (-OPSD), which converts behavioral traits into privileged supervision for reasoning. A trait-conditioned self-teacher provides dense token-level guidance on student-generated trajectories, enabling the student to learn from these qualities without retaining trait instructions at inference. We instantiate the framework with truthfulness, encouraging justified inference, uncertainty checking, and self-correction. To adapt this guidance, -OPSD uses hard-sample learning to provide local-progress instructions for budget-exhausted trajectories and an outcome-aware stance gate to reinforce, suppress, or exclude supervision according to its consistency with task outcomes. Reference answers are used only for verification and never enter the teacher context. Across Qwen3 models from 1.7B to 8B, -OPSD achieves the highest average mathematical accuracy among the compared methods and improves abstention under insufficient evidence. Gains with additional behavioral traits, including planning and exploration, demonstrate that the framework generalizes beyond truthfulness.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
large language models, on-policy self-distillation, reasoning, privileged information, behavioral priors

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 49%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.33 over 3 reviews, above 51% of the others.
Reviewer_Ec9WOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces τ-OPSD, using behavioral traits as privileged supervision with hard-sample learning and outcome-aware stance gating. Experiments on Qwen3-1.7B, 4B, and 8B report improvements in mathematical reasoning and abstention under insufficient evidence.

Critical strengths

Reusable behavioral traits offer a practical source of privileged supervision without providing per-problem solutions to the teacher. Gains in mathematical reasoning across three Qwen3 scales, alongside improvements in both abstention F1 and answerable accuracy, provide meaningful empirical support for the proposed framework.

Critical weaknesses

Although the paper emphasizes behavioral traits as privileged supervision, outcome correctness also regulates the distillation updates. The gate ablation jointly removes stance and correctness-dependent weighting, so a matched outcome-only control is needed to clarify the added value of trait-induced stance.

Questions for authors

Can the existing ablations distinguish the contribution of trait-induced stance from that of outcome-only weighting under matched training settings?

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer Ec9W

We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the practical value of reusable behavioral traits as privileged supervision and the consistent improvements in mathematical reasoning and abstention across model scales. We appreciate the constructive suggestion to better isolate the contribution of trait-induced stance.

To W & Q. Disentangling Trait-Induced Stance from Outcome-Based Weighting

The gate ablation jointly removes stance and correctness-dependent weighting.

Can the existing ablations distinguish the contribution of trait-induced stance from that of outcome-only weighting under matched training settings?

We agree that the original w/o stance gate ablation alone cannot disentangle these effects. To address this, we introduce two additional controls under the same τ\tau-OPSD training configuration on Qwen3-1.7B.

  • Correct-only uses outcome correctness to select supervision, without trait-induced stance.
  • Outcome-only applies outcome-dependent signed weighting without trait-induced stance.

We compare these controls with the original uniform-weight ablation and the full τ\tau-OPSD method.

MethodAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
w/o stance gate75.5046.9434.4452.29
Correct-only75.2048.3335.5653.03
Outcome-only76.80‾\underline{76.80}49.17‾\underline{49.17}37.50‾\underline{37.50}54.49‾\underline{54.49}
τ\tau-OPSD (ours)78.3151.3938.0655.92

The results demonstrate complementary contributions from outcome-based weighting and trait-induced stance. Correct-only improves average accuracy over uniform weighting by 0.74 points, while outcome-only further improves it by 1.46 points. Crucially, the full τ\tau-OPSD achieves an additional 1.43 points gain over outcome-only, outperforming it on all three benchmarks. The overall improvement over uniform weighting reaches 3.63 points.

These matched comparisons provide direct empirical evidence that trait-induced stance contributes beyond correctness-based supervision alone, rather than attributing the entire gain to outcome-aware weighting.

Furthermore, Appendix A.3.5 (Figures 6–7) provides complementary training-dynamics analyses of positive/negative supervision, hard-sample weight allocation, and effective sample size, illustrating how the stance gate adaptively regulates supervision throughout training.

We have incorporated the new controlled ablations and analyses into revised Section 4.2 (page 8) and Appendix A.3.1 (page 20). Together, these results support the distinct empirical contribution of trait-induced stance within our framework.

Reviewer_dfbZOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper proposes τ-OPSD, a framework that uses behavioral traits as privileged supervision for on-policy self-distillation. It combines trait-conditioned guidance, hard-sample learning, and outcome-aware stance gating to improve reasoning. Experiments on Qwen3 models show improvements in mathematical reasoning and abstention performance.

Critical strengths
  • Interesting Idea: Using behavioral traits as privileged supervision provides an interesting direction for improving LLM reasoning.
  • Consistent Improvements: The method achieves strong results across different model scales and improves both mathematical reasoning and abstention.
  • Detailed Analysis: The paper includes component ablations, sensitivity analysis, and experiments with different behavioral traits.
Critical weaknesses
  • Unclear Contribution of Behavioral Traits: The performance gains may also come from outcome-aware weighting and other training components. The current ablations do not fully isolate the benefit of behavioral traits from general instruction-based supervision.
  • Evaluation Protocol: The authors select the best checkpoint based on AMC23, AIME24, and AIME25, which are also used for final evaluation. This may introduce selection bias and overestimate performance. Checkpoint selection should use a separate validation set.
  • Baseline Comparison: The baselines use different rollout counts, training objectives, and teacher update strategies (Table 5). Without compute-matched comparisons, it is difficult to determine how much improvement comes from the proposed method.
  • Limited Generalization: Most experiments focus on mathematical reasoning with Qwen3 models. The effectiveness of behavioral traits on other reasoning tasks and model families remains unclear.
Questions for authors
  1. Can the authors provide a control experiment using general instructions without specific behavioral traits?
  2. Can the authors select checkpoints on a separate validation set and report results across multiple training seeds?
  3. Can the authors provide compute-matched comparisons with existing self-distillation methods?
  4. Does the method generalize to other reasoning tasks, such as coding or scientific reasoning?

I am willing to adjust my score according to the rebuttal.

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer dfbZ (1/2)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for recognizing the potential of behavioral traits as privileged supervision, the consistent improvements across model scales, and our detailed experimental analyses.

To W1 & Q1. Isolating the Contribution of Behavioral Traits

The current ablations do not fully isolate the benefit of behavioral traits from general instruction-based supervision.

Can the authors provide a control experiment using general instructions without specific behavioral traits?

New fine-grained PI ablations. To directly address this concern, we conduct three additional controlled experiments on Qwen3-1.7B, replacing truthfulness PI with length-comparable instructions, including Generic Reasoning (structured problem solving), Verification (calculation and consistency checking), and Presentation (clarity and organization). All other training settings, including the stance gate and hard-sample guidance, remain unchanged.

PI VariantAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
Generic Reasoning76.9149.1735.0053.69
Verification77.5147.5035.5653.52
Presentation75.9048.0636.1153.36
Full Truthfulness (τ\tau-OPSD)78.3151.3938.0655.92

Full truthfulness outperforms all three controls across every benchmark, improving average accuracy by 2.23, 2.40, and 2.56 percentage points, respectively. In particular, the gain over Verification suggests that the benefit extends beyond calculation checking to broader epistemic guidance, including justification, uncertainty management, and avoiding unsupported conclusions.

Since only the PI content changes, these matched comparisons provide direct evidence for the additional value of truthfulness-based supervision beyond generic reasoning instructions, rather than improvements attributable solely to the training recipe. We have incorporated these experiments and analyses into revised Section 4.3 (page 9), with the exact PI instructions provided in Appendix A.4.3 (page 27).

To W2 & Q2. Independent Validation and Multi-Run Robustness

Checkpoint selection should use a separate validation set.

Can the authors select checkpoints on a separate validation set and report results across multiple training seeds?

Independent validation-based checkpoint selection. To address potential selection bias, we construct an independent validation set of 512 held-out DeepMath problems unseen during training. We select checkpoints across four methods and three model scales solely by validation pass@1.

The table below shows selected checkpoints and avg@12 test accuracy (%).

ScaleMethodDeepMath pass@1Best StepAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
1.7BGRPO76.56‾\underline{76.56}14076.10‾\underline{76.10}48.3335.2853.24
OPSD76.172075.3048.89‾\underline{48.89}35.56‾\underline{35.56}53.25‾\underline{53.25}
SDPO76.56‾\underline{76.56}2074.7046.6732.6751.34
τ\tau-OPSD77.348076.5151.3937.2255.04
4BGRPO88.8718088.5571.6763.6174.61
OPSD86.722088.4573.3365.5675.78
SDPO88.48‾\underline{88.48}6089.6673.61‾\underline{73.61}66.67‾\underline{66.67}76.65‾\underline{76.65}
τ\tau-OPSD87.898089.36‾\underline{89.36}73.8967.7877.01
8BGRPO87.1116090.12‾\underline{90.12}74.0068.0077.37
OPSD87.50‾\underline{87.50}2089.4675.83‾\underline{75.83}70.2878.52‾\underline{78.52}
SDPO86.336088.3573.8969.72‾\underline{69.72}77.32
τ\tau-OPSD87.7018091.1676.9469.72‾\underline{69.72}79.27

Results. With independently selected checkpoints, τ\tau-OPSD consistently achieves the highest average accuracy across all three scales, outperforming the strongest baselines by 1.79, 0.36, and 0.75 percentage points at 1.7B, 4B, and 8B, respectively. This confirms that our improvements persist without test-set-based checkpoint selection.

Robustness across training runs. We additionally repeat Qwen3-1.7B training with two random seeds (1024 and 333). Combining these with the original training run, we report the mean accuracy and standard deviation across three runs.

MethodAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
GRPO76.10‾\underline{76.10}48.3335.2853.24
OPSD75.3048.89‾\underline{48.89}35.56‾\underline{35.56}53.25‾\underline{53.25}
SDPO74.7046.6732.6751.34
τ\tau-OPSD78.01 (±0.36)49.81 (±1.43)37.50 (±0.96)55.11 (±0.70)

Across the three runs, τ\tau-OPSD maintains a consistent advantage, achieving 55.11 ± 0.70% average accuracy. These results provide additional evidence of robustness across independent training runs.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer dfbZ (2/2)

To W3 & Q3. Controlled Comparisons with Self-Distillation Baselines

The baselines use different rollout counts, training objectives, and teacher update strategies.

Can the authors provide compute-matched comparisons with existing self-distillation methods?

Additional controlled experiments. To address this concern, we conduct additional experiments on Qwen3-1.7B, progressively aligning rollout counts, optimizer updates, training objectives, and teacher update strategies with τ\tau-OPSD.

  • SDPO. We increase the mini-batch size to 64 and reduce optimizer updates from 4 to 1, while retaining its original multi-rollout sampling and training objective to preserve its algorithmic formulation.
  • OPSD. We first reduce rollouts from 8 to 1 while retaining 4 updates, then increase the mini-batch size to 64 with 1 update. Finally, we further align its optimization recipe by adopting EMA teacher updates, JSD, no clipping, and sequence-level normalization.

The following table summarizes the results using avg@12 accuracy (%) on Qwen3-1.7B.

MethodRolloutsUpdatesAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
SDPO (original)8473.5946.3934.4451.47
SDPO (single-update)8174.3048.0635.2852.55
OPSD (original)8475.3048.8935.5653.25
OPSD (single-rollout)1475.8048.8934.4453.05
OPSD (single-update)1175.90‾\underline{75.90}49.4435.83‾\underline{35.83}53.72‾\underline{53.72}
OPSD (recipe-aligned)1175.5050.28‾\underline{50.28}34.1753.32
τ\tau-OPSD (ours)1178.3151.3938.0655.92

Results. Under the aligned optimization recipe, τ\tau-OPSD outperforms OPSD by 2.60 points (55.92% vs. 53.32%). It also exceeds single-update SDPO by 3.37 points (55.92% vs. 52.55%). Notably, adjusting rollout and update schedules yields only modest changes in OPSD performance, while τ\tau-OPSD consistently achieves higher accuracy.

These controlled comparisons provide further evidence that the improvements of τ\tau-OPSD extend beyond differences in rollout counts, optimizer update schedules, and general optimization choices.

To W4 & Q4. Generalization Beyond Mathematical Reasoning

Most experiments focus on mathematical reasoning with Qwen3 models.

Does the method generalize to other reasoning tasks, such as coding or scientific reasoning?

Scientific question answering. Our existing AbstentionBench evaluation includes GPQA-Abstain, which covers science-domain questions, alongside GSM8K-Abstain and MMLU-Math-Abstain. Beyond abstention F1, we also report accuracy on answerable questions, providing complementary evidence of generalization to evidence-sensitive question answering.

New coding evaluation. To further investigate cross-task generalization, we evaluate the trained models on HumanEval [1] and HumanEval+ [2], which share the same coding problems but use increasingly rigorous test suites. The results are reported as pass@1 accuracy (%).

MethodHumanEvalHumanEval+
Base65.8559.15
GRPO67.6862.20
OPSD68.29‾\underline{68.29}63.41‾\underline{63.41}
SDPO67.6862.80
τ\tau-OPSD (ours)69.5164.02

Results. τ\tau-OPSD achieves the best performance on both benchmarks, outperforming the strongest baseline by 1.22 and 0.61 points, respectively. These results provide further evidence that the benefits of trait-guided self-distillation extend beyond mathematical reasoning to code generation, while the existing abstention evaluations provide complementary evidence on science-domain question answering.

Together, these evaluations support the cross-task transferability of trait-guided supervision across mathematical reasoning, coding, and evidence-sensitive answering.

References

[1] Chen M, Tworek J, Jun H, et al. Evaluating Large Language Models Trained on Code. arXiv:2107.03374, 2021.

[2] Liu J, Xia C S, Wang Y, et al. Is Your Code Generated by ChatGPT Really Correct? Rigorous Evaluation of Large Language Models for Code Generation. NeurIPS 2023.

Reviewer_FWATOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper introduces trait-guided On-Policy Self-Distillation (τ-OPSD), which uses reusable behavioral instructions as privileged context for a self-teacher rather than conditioning the teacher on instance-specific reference solutions. A teacher scores student-generated trajectories with and without the instruction. The change in its support for the observed response, combined with final-answer correctness, determines a signed distillation weight. The method also routes budget-exhausted trajectories to local-progress guidance, and uses an EMA teacher and a JSD objective. Experiments on Qwen3 models from 1.7B to 8B report gains in mathematical reasoning and evidence-sensitive abstention, with component ablations, alternative behavioral instructions, and per-step timing measurements.

Critical strengths
  1. An interesting and practical direction for constructing privileged supervision.

Using reusable, task-agnostic instructions to condition a self-teacher is a worthwhile alternative to supplying a reference solution for each problem. The method scores the student's own prefixes without additional teacher-generated solution trajectories, and the resulting student does not need the instruction at inference time. The paper is clear about this operational distinction from solution-privileged OPSD.

  1. Substantive empirical validation, including targeted component and supervision-source controls.

The paper evaluates three model sizes and several complementary questions. At 1.7B, replacing truthfulness PI with the solution answer while holding the proposed training configuration fixed yields 54.37 versus 55.92 for τ-OPSD; removing the stance gate yields 52.29. The negative/zero/positive weighting comparison and the EMA, JSD, and hard-sample ablations provide further useful support. Planning and exploration instructions also outperform the untrained model and solution-conditioned OPSD at 1.7B. These results should be credited as evidence for the complete framework rather than dismissed as a lack of ablations.

  1. Encouraging results, with useful attention to evaluation scope and practical cost.

The mathematical macro-average exceeds the strongest reported baseline at each scale by 2.22, 0.54, and 1.07 percentage points, respectively. On abstention tasks, the authors report both abstention F1 and answerable accuracy, helping rule out the simplest explanation that the model merely refuses more often. The measured per-step speedup relative to OPSD is 1.94–2.66× under the tested configurations. Importantly, the paper explicitly distinguishes this measurement from compute-matched efficiency and limits the abstention conclusion to evidence-sensitive answering.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The central motivation is promising but remains exploratory, and the distinctive role of behavioral traits is not fully identified.

The broad proposal is that behavioral traits can become reusable privileged supervision for reasoning. However, the actual truthfulness instruction emphasizes checking uncertain steps, correcting mistakes, and avoiding unsupported conclusions. The planning and exploration variants likewise give concrete procedural reasoning advice. The current evidence therefore does not clearly distinguish learning a behavioral trait from distilling generally useful reasoning instructions. This matters because the novelty is framed around traits as a new supervision source rather than simply around adding a reusable reasoning prompt to an on-policy self-teacher.

The otherwise matched solution-answer PI ablation at 1.7B is a meaningful positive control, and the paper does not need to demonstrate that conventional OPSD is intrinsically flawed. What remains unclear is the additional value of the trait-based formulation relative to a comparably specific, non-trait reasoning instruction. Appendix A.3.6 also shows that direct truthfulness substitution in OPSD helps at smaller scale but underperforms solution-conditioned OPSD at 8B (approximately 77.1 versus 78.5), indicating that supervision content and training design interact. A sharper hypothesis about why these behavioral instructions should provide a transferable teaching signal, along with a focused control or analysis, would substantially improve the paper's motivation and contribution statement.

  1. The stance gate has empirical support, but its relation to beneficial student updates is still indirect.

Stance measures how an instruction changes the EMA teacher's likelihood of the observed student trajectory. It is not a step-level measure of correctness, and the subsequent student update compares the student with the instructed EMA teacher rather than comparing the teacher's two conditioning states. The sign of the stance-outcome score therefore need not identify a beneficial direction of change for the student. In particular, negative-weight JSD can move the student away from an instructed teacher even when that teacher assigns a lower probability to an erroneous token than the current student does. Applying the same signed weight to an entire response also cannot distinguish sound intermediate reasoning from incorrect or redundant steps within that response.

These are limits of the proxy, not evidence that the method fails. Figure 3(d) finds that weak negative weights outperform zero or positive alternatives, and Appendix A.3.5 provides gate statistics. A direct diagnostic showing how updates in different gate categories change correct-answer probability or task outcomes would clarify why this simple rule works and under what conditions, particularly as the EMA teacher diverges from the current student.

  1. Main-run gains are attributable to the whole training recipe, not yet cleanly to the proposed supervision source.

The main τ-OPSD configuration uses one rollout and one optimizer update per question batch, whereas the baselines use eight rollouts per question and four optimizer updates per step, together with differences in objective, teacher updating, and normalization. The component ablations demonstrate which choices matter within τ-OPSD, but the main-table margin over OPSD cannot by itself be attributed to behavioral-trait conditioning. The matched solution-answer PI comparison partially addresses supervision-source attribution at 1.7B, and should be acknowledged, but the full baseline comparison still bundles general optimization choices with the new guidance and gate. It would help to more explicitly separate the claims supported by the matched PI ablation from those supported only by comparisons of complete training recipes. The stated speedups remain valid as per-step measurements under the respective configurations, rather than equal-budget efficiency claims.

  1. The abstention transfer result would benefit from a focused reliability check.

The GPQA-Abstain subset contains only 40 answerable–unanswerable pairs but contributes one-third of the unweighted abstention macro-average. Its relatively large gains drive an important part of the overall F1 advantage, particularly at 1.7B and 4B. Additionally, judgments use a fixed Qwen3-8B evaluator for Qwen3-family models, without a reported independent-model or human audit. This does not demonstrate evaluator bias, but a targeted verification of the GPQA cases driving the improvement would make the claim more convincing. The authors already avoid interpreting these results as proof of general honesty or truthful intermediate reasoning, and I agree with that narrower interpretation.

Questions for authors
  1. What is the paper's most specific hypothesis about behavioral traits as privileged supervision, beyond the more general idea of conditioning a teacher on reusable reasoning instructions? How would truthfulness PI be expected to differ from a content- and length-comparable ordinary checking/self-correction instruction? Please clarify what the existing matched solution-answer PI control does and does not establish, including whether “solution answer” contains a full reference derivation.

  2. What evidence connects the signed stance gate to beneficial student updates, rather than only to a change in teacher preference? Could the authors provide a focused analysis, ideally using existing training trajectories or a small controlled update, of the effects of positive and negative gate categories on task correctness? In particular, how does the effect depend on the gap between the EMA teacher and the current student?

  3. How much of the comparison with OPSD should be attributed to trait-conditioned supervision, and how much to EMA/JSD and rollout/update choices? A clear decomposition of the claims supported by the matched 1.7B PI ablation versus the complete-recipe comparisons would help. If an appropriately aligned OPSD configuration has already been evaluated, please report it.

  4. Can the authors examine the specific GPQA-Abstain pairs responsible for the reported F1 improvement, and check the relevant judgments with an independent model or human assessment?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FWAT (1/2)

We sincerely thank the reviewer for the insightful assessment and constructive suggestions, particularly for recognizing the value of reusable privileged supervision and our empirical validation.

To W1 & Q1. Distinctive Role of Behavioral Traits as Privileged Supervision

What is the paper's most specific hypothesis about behavioral traits as privileged supervision, beyond reusable reasoning instructions?

How would truthfulness PI differ from an ordinary checking/self-correction instruction?

Our hypothesis. Behavioral traits provide transferable epistemic supervision by guiding how models manage reasoning, including when to trust an inference, question uncertainty, or revise unsupported conclusions. Rather than prescribing specific solution procedures, these principles can shape teacher preferences over student-generated reasoning paths across different problems. On-policy self-distillation then internalizes this guidance without requiring trait instructions at inference. The distinctive value lies in the behavioral principles encoded by traits, rather than their linguistic form as instructions. We have clarified this hypothesis in the revised Introduction and integrated it into the relevant discussions throughout the paper.

New fine-grained PI ablations. We replace truthfulness PI with three approximately length-comparable instructions on Qwen3-1.7B while keeping all other training settings unchanged.

PI VariantAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
Generic Reasoning76.9149.1735.0053.69
Verification77.5147.5035.5653.52
Presentation75.9048.0636.1153.36
Full Truthfulness (τ\tau-OPSD)78.3151.3938.0655.92

Full truthfulness consistently outperforms all three controls by 2.23, 2.40, and 2.56 points, respectively. Its advantage over Verification particularly suggests that the benefit extends beyond ordinary checking to broader epistemic guidance. We have incorporated these experiments and analyses into revised Section 4.3, with the exact PI instructions provided in Appendix A.4.3.

Regarding the existing matched w/o truthfulness control, the teacher receives the full reference derivation and final answer, rather than the answer alone. Its result (54.37% vs. 55.92%) further supports the value of truthfulness PI under the same training configuration.

To W2 & Q2. Direct Evidence for Stance-Gated Student Updates

What evidence connects the signed stance gate to beneficial student updates, particularly for negative weights and varying EMA teacher–student gaps?

Paired one-step interventions. To directly examine the effects of signed weighting, we conduct four paired interventions on Qwen3-1.7B, each using 64 fixed trajectories from the step-100 checkpoint. We compare Full Gate with Positive-only, which removes negative weights while retaining positive weights. Both branches share the same training settings, differing only in negative weighting.

Update-level analysis. We measure the outcome-aligned change in observed-trajectory log-likelihood, where positive values indicate increased student support for correct trajectories or decreased support for incorrect ones. Across 256 trajectories, Full Gate improves mean alignment by 3.191×10−53.191\times10^{-5} nats/token, outperforming Positive-only in three of four batches.

The following table reports category-level results for non-truncated trajectories with absolute stance above 0.001, in units of 10−510^{-5} nats/token.

Outcome / PI-induced stanceNPositive-onlyFull GateDifference
Correct / Increased support634.8859.811+4.926
Incorrect / Decreased support72.3660.049-2.317
Correct / Decreased support68-8.232-6.637+1.595
Incorrect / Increased support23-8.62710.974+19.601

The strongest benefit occurs when PI increases teacher support for incorrect trajectories. Full Gate reverses the mean update from increasing to decreasing student support for these trajectories, with consistent improvements across all four batches. Moreover, the benefit is stronger under lower observed-token teacher–student discrepancy (+7.034) than higher discrepancy (-0.652), suggesting that teacher–student alignment influences the effectiveness of signed supervision.

These update-level findings complement Figure 3(d), where weak negative weighting achieves 55.9% accuracy compared with 54.4% when negative weights are removed. Together, they provide direct likelihood-level evidence for the role of weak negative weighting alongside its long-term accuracy gains.

We have incorporated these findings into revised Section 4.2 (page 8), with further diagnostics in Appendix A.3.5 (page 24).

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Response to Reviewer FWAT (2/2)

To W3 & Q3. Disentangling Training Recipes and Trait-Conditioned Supervision

Main-run gains are attributable to the whole training recipe, not yet cleanly to the proposed supervision source.

How much of the comparison with OPSD should be attributed to trait-conditioned supervision, and how much to EMA/JSD and rollout/update choices?

Controlled OPSD comparisons. We conduct three additional experiments on Qwen3-1.7B, progressively aligning OPSD with τ\tau-OPSD.

  • Single-rollout OPSD reduces rollouts from 8 to 1 while retaining 4 optimizer updates.
  • Single-update OPSD further increases the mini-batch size to 64 with 1 optimizer update.
  • Recipe-aligned OPSD additionally adopts EMA teacher updates, JSD, no clipping, and sequence-level normalization.

All experiments use the same training data and evaluation protocol.

MethodRolloutsUpdatesAMC23AIME24AIME25Avg.
OPSD (original)8475.3048.8935.5653.25
OPSD (single-rollout)1475.8048.8934.4453.05
OPSD (single-update)1175.9049.4435.83‾\underline{35.83}53.72
OPSD (recipe-aligned)1175.5050.28‾\underline{50.28}34.1753.32
τ\tau-OPSD (reference + answer PI)1178.11‾\underline{78.11}49.4435.5654.37‾\underline{54.37}
τ\tau-OPSD (truthfulness PI)1178.3151.3938.0655.92

Training recipe effects. Adjusting rollout counts and optimizer updates produces relatively modest changes in OPSD performance. Even after aligning EMA, JSD, and other optimization settings, τ\tau-OPSD outperforms recipe-aligned OPSD by 2.60 points (55.92% vs. 53.32%), supporting the effectiveness of our complete supervision framework.

Supervision-source effects. Under identical τ\tau-OPSD training settings, truthfulness PI outperforms the full reference derivation and final answer PI by 1.55 points (55.92% vs. 54.37%). This matched comparison provides more specific evidence for the contribution of trait-conditioned supervision, while the complete-recipe comparison additionally reflects our adaptive supervision mechanisms.

We have incorporated these analyses into revised Section 4.2 (page 9) and Appendix A.3.4 (page 23). The reported efficiency gains refer to per-step measurements under the respective training configurations.

To W4 & Q4. Independent Verification of GPQA-Abstain Results

The GPQA-Abstain subset contains only 40 pairs and contributes substantially to the overall F1 advantage.

Can the authors examine the specific GPQA-Abstain pairs and verify the judgments with an independent model?

Independent evaluator verification. Following the reviewer's suggestion, we re-evaluate the existing GPQA-Abstain responses using MiMo-V2.6-Flash, an independent evaluator from a different model family than the original Qwen3-8B judge. We focus on Qwen3-1.7B and 4B, where GPQA contributes substantially to the reported improvements.

The following table reports abstention F1 and answerable accuracy (%) under the independent evaluator.

ScaleMethodGPQA F1GPQA Acc.
1.7BGRPO29.7940.00
OPSD29.1737.50
SDPO36.73‾\underline{36.73}42.50‾\underline{42.50}
τ\tau-OPSD43.1445.00
4BGRPO43.1452.50
OPSD43.1462.50‾\underline{62.50}
SDPO51.85‾\underline{51.85}55.00
τ\tau-OPSD57.1465.00

Focused judgment analysis. We further examine the GPQA-Abstain confusion matrices for Qwen3-1.7B τ\tau-OPSD under the original and independent evaluations.

MetricQwen3-8B JudgeMiMo JudgeΔ\Delta
True Positives (TP)911+2
False Positives (FP)000
False Negatives (FN)3129-2
True Negatives (TN)40400
Abstention F1 (%)36.7343.14+6.41

Both evaluations show zero false-positive abstentions, with a difference of only two true positives in their aggregate confusion matrices. The results correspond to the checkpoints used in the respective evaluations.

Results. Under the independent evaluator, τ\tau-OPSD maintains the highest GPQA abstention F1 and answerable accuracy at both scales. The consistent overall findings and similar abstention patterns across evaluators provide additional evidence that our GPQA improvements are not specific to the original Qwen3-based evaluation.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.