acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Speculative Diffusion is a Tale of Two Tradeoffs

Abstract

Speculative decoding is a technique that accelerates the inference speed of autoregressive large language models (LLMs) by sampling from a faster, lower quality draft model. Traditionally, a fundamental characteristic of speculative decoding is that it is lossless with respect to the verifier distribution, guaranteeing speed without sacrificing quality. This differs from recently developed diffusion LLMs (dLLMs), which are notably able to achieve substantial speedups by degrading the quality of their outputs with less diffusion effort. Because diffusion models are able to sample faster than autoregressive models by generating tokens in parallel, they are considered strong candidates for draft models in speculative diffusion. While it is widely understood that diffusion models can sacrifice quality for speed, speculative decoding itself can also be generalized to generate lossy samples faster using more lenient acceptance criteria with respect to the verifier distribution. Presented with the two parameters of diffusion effort and speculative decoding leniency, this paper explores the full achievable Pareto frontier via joint variations of these parameters. Our experiments show that jointly varying diffusion effort and acceptance leniency can extend the speed–quality Pareto frontier over single step diffusion drafting.

Primary area:
foundation or frontier models, including LLMs
Keywords:
speculative decoding, diffusion language model, speed quality tradeoffs, LLM inference

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 27%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 2.00 over 3 reviews, above 27% of the others.
Reviewer_N7BkOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
4
Informativeness
1
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the interaction between two controls in speculative decoding with diffusion drafters: diffusion effort, which determines drafting cost and proposal quality, and acceptance leniency, which relaxes preservation of the verifier’s distribution to increase acceptance. It provides a token-level optimality result for linear interpolation under a total-variation constraint and examines conditions for exact verification of multistep diffusion proposals. Experiments explore how jointly varying diffusion effort and leniency changes the speed–accuracy frontier across several model pairs and reasoning and coding benchmarks.

Critical strengths

The paper provides joint formulation of two interacting control on diffusion effort and verification leniency into a common framework.

The paper theoretically establishes the optimality of linear interpolation under a total-variation constraint.

The experiments demonstrate some speed–accuracy trade-off from jointly varying drafting effort and acceptance leniency.

Critical weaknesses

Limited incremental insight over established trade-offs: the importance of balancing drafting cost against acceptance is already studied in previous paper (i.e. Decoding Speculative Decoding), while another paper (SPEC-RL: Accelerating On-Policy Reinforcement Learning with Speculative Rollouts) examines acceptance lenience and its efficiency–quality trade-off. Although neither studies exactly the same diffusion setting, the individual mechanisms are established. This paper mainly combines these controls through parameter sweeps, without sufficiently demonstrating a new generalizable insight beyond the observation that different configurations occupy different parts of the frontier.

Insufficiently quantified end-to-end advantage over strong baselines. The paper reports completion latency and throughput and includes comparisons with DFlash, DSpark, and Uno. However, improvements over a drafter’s own one-step configuration do not necessarily establish an advantage over the strongest competing system. The authors should explicitly quantify end-to-end speedups at matched accuracy, particularly near the verifier’s accuracy or under a small specified accuracy reduction.

Limited validation under realistic serving conditions. All experiments use a single H200, with no reported serving-concurrency sweep. Additional diffusion passes increase drafting computation, while permissive acceptance reduces the number of verification rounds. Their relative costs can change substantially under batching and higher concurrency,

Questions for authors

see weakness

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 1

Dear Reviewer N7Bk,

We thank the reviewer for their feedback, and we hope to address each point substantively.

Limited incremental insight over established trade-offs: the importance of balancing drafting cost against acceptance is already studied in previous paper (i.e. Decoding Speculative Decoding), while another paper (SPEC-RL: Accelerating On-Policy Reinforcement Learning with Speculative Rollouts) examines acceptance lenience and its efficiency–quality trade-off. Although neither studies exactly the same diffusion setting, the individual mechanisms are established.

As the reviewerer concedes, neither paper mentions diffusion, which is half the purpose of our paper. It is unclear what “individual mechanisms” in these papers bear any implication on our work. “Decoding Speculative Decoding” is about the optimal width and depth of a drafter, but because it does not mention diffusion it bears no relevance to the optimal test-time compute allocation of the drafter. It also does not mention anything about speed-quality tradeoffs. “SPEC-RL: Accelerating On-Policy Reinforcement Learning with Speculative Rollouts” conducts an ablation on lenience in the context of RL, but it does not use the same formulation of lenience as our work. In any case, the contribution of our work lies in studying the interaction between diffusion effort and acceptance lenience, so the fact that individual mechanisms exist is completely irrelevant to our contribution.

This paper mainly combines these controls through parameter sweeps, without sufficiently demonstrating a new generalizable insight beyond the observation that different configurations occupy different parts of the frontier.

We dispute the claim that we lack a generalizable insight. In the paper, we find

“additional denoising can support more lenient acceptance and faster generation at comparable accuracy” (105-106)

“In general, low diffusion effort with strict acceptance requirements tends to capture the higher accuracy regions of the Pareto frontier, while higher diffusion effort with more lenient acceptance captures the higher speed regions” (401-404)

This is additionally evidenced by our results and predicted by our cost model in Section 3.3.

Insufficiently quantified end-to-end advantage over strong baselines. The paper reports completion latency and throughput and includes comparisons with DFlash, DSpark, and Uno. However, improvements over a drafter’s own one-step configuration do not necessarily establish an advantage over the strongest competing system.

We agree that these comparisons answer different questions. The within-model K=1 comparison measures the value of allocating additional diffusion computation; the comparison with DFlash, DSpark, and Uno measures competitiveness against specialized systems. Our contribution is an analysis of the joint tradeoff, not a claim that SDAR universally outperforms those systems. We will separate these claims and retain the regimes where specialized one-step drafters are faster.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 2

The authors should explicitly quantify end-to-end speedups at matched accuracy, particularly near the verifier’s accuracy or under a small specified accuracy reduction.

We thank the reviewer for suggesting comparison at fixed accuracy, as it can improve the clarity of our results. Following the reviewer's feedback, we have included additional results in Appendix G, where we computed the additional speedup due to using the joint variation over using a fixed diffusion efforts, which we use as baselines. Note that there is no natural baseline in this framework, because for example the verifier by itself has a single accuracy by definition, which cannot support a "matched accuracy" evaluation, which is why we use each of the fixed diffusion effort drafters as baselines. In Figure 17, 18 and 19, we show the additional speedup factor against the baselines, where each curve represents the speedup against a fixed diffusion steps or a fixed unmasking threshold value. Table 7 and 8 report the exact numerical values that are in the Figure 17, 18 and 19, corresponding to the single step diffusion drafter baseline curve. Note that each column of the table shows the speedup factor of using the joint variation against the baseline of the single step diffusion drafter at matched accuracy. Here are the results.

Latency Speedup over K=1 (×) with Relative Accuracy (% of Verifier)

ModelTask100%95%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%
Dream-7BGSM8K1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.01× (0.02)1.03× (0.04)1.16× (0.05)1.38× (0.05)1.43× (0.10)1.60× (0.08)2.45× (0.41)
DiffusionGemma-26BGPQA1.22× (0.28)1.51× (0.57)1.75× (0.65)3.30× (0.64)5.41× (1.01)8.86× (1.59)13.82× (0.99)14.26× (0.35)14.71× (0.53)
SDAR-1.7BGSM8K--1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.39× (0.06)2.06× (0.12)2.18× (0.12)2.23× (0.08)2.27× (0.06)2.26× (0.05)
SDAR-1.7BHumanEval1.00×1.02× (0.01)1.03× (0.02)1.07× (0.05)1.10× (0.08)1.14× (0.11)1.18× (0.14)1.37× (0.13)1.75× (0.14)
SDAR-8BGSM8K1.07× (0.12)1.77× (0.61)2.27× (0.56)2.55× (0.06)2.51× (0.03)2.47× (0.02)2.39× (0.03)2.30× (0.04)2.17× (0.10)
SDAR-8BHumanEval--1.02× (0.03)1.06× (0.06)1.15× (0.13)1.25× (0.22)1.36× (0.32)1.50× (0.36)1.73× (0.26)1.99× (0.15)

Throughput Gain over K=1 (×) with Relative Accuracy (% of Verifier)

ModelTask100%95%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%
Dream-7BGSM8K1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.01)1.00× (0.01)1.04× (0.05)1.08× (0.08)1.08× (0.07)1.13× (0.09)1.38× (0.24)
DiffusionGemma-26BGPQA1.29× (0.30)1.48× (0.43)1.62× (0.59)2.82× (1.67)4.24× (1.80)6.38× (1.57)9.17× (0.62)8.82× (0.53)8.48× (0.49)
SDAR-1.7BGSM8K--1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.36× (0.06)1.96× (0.09)2.10× (0.06)2.21× (0.04)2.25× (0.05)2.17× (0.05)
SDAR-1.7BHumanEval1.00×1.01× (0.01)1.01× (0.02)1.03× (0.05)1.04× (0.08)1.06× (0.10)1.07× (0.13)1.22× (0.11)1.50× (0.10)
SDAR-8BGSM8K1.05× (0.09)1.58× (0.45)1.94× (0.41)2.23× (0.05)2.31× (0.07)2.40× (0.11)2.38× (0.09)2.34× (0.06)2.22× (0.12)
SDAR-8BHumanEval--1.01× (0.02)1.05× (0.02)1.12× (0.03)1.20× (0.04)1.28× (0.05)1.35× (0.06)1.39× (0.04)1.43× (0.03)

Although results vary depending on the dataset and model, we would like to highlight the following results. At 90% relative accuracy, SDAR-8B achieves a 2.27x latency speedup and 1.94x throughput gain on GSM8K. At 100% relative accuracy, we find 1.22x latency speedup and 1.29x throughput gain for DiffusionGemma on GPQA. In addition, at 50% relative accuracy, that configuration achieves 13.82x latency speedup and 9.17x throughput gain. While 50% relative accuracy is a significant drop in accuracy, the speedup is considerable.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 3

Limited validation under realistic serving conditions. All experiments use a single H200, with no reported serving-concurrency sweep. Additional diffusion passes increase drafting computation, while permissive acceptance reduces the number of verification rounds. Their relative costs can change substantially under batching and higher concurrency,

It is very standard to evaluate speculative decoding at batch size 1 (See [1,2,3,4]). However, in accordance with your suggestion, we have further simulated results under more realistic serving conditions, namely, continuous batching with different batch sizes. Please refer to the newly added Appendix H.

Since under continuous batching all sequences in the batch are always getting a meaningful token decoded, it suffices to profile the drafter and verifier call times by decoding one token position for each sequence concurrently. For each batch size, we run the Dream-Qwen model pair on 50 random problems from GSM8K to profile the time the drafter and verifier calls take, which are the cd(K)c_d(K) and cvc_v values, respectively. For each run, the leniency and diffusion efforts are varied the same way as in the batch size of 1 case. After that, for each combination of leniency and diffusion efforts, using the accuracies from the batch size of 1 case, we can derive the corresponding latency and throughput under the profiled batch sizes.

Experimentally, each of the Pareto frontiers at batch sizes 2, 4, 8, 16 show a similar pattern as in the case of batch size of 1, where different combinations of the leniency and diffusion efforts occupy different regions of the frontier, showing that the relative magnitudes of cd(K)c_d(K) and cvc_v are stable enough under different serving conditions so that it is always meaningful to explore the Pareto frontier composition by varying the leniency and diffusion effort. This shows that the relative costs of the drafter and verifier remain stable enough under different realistic serving conditions for the joint exploration of the Pareto frontier to be always meaningful.

We believe we have addressed each point, and we respectfully request the reviewer to reconsider their score in light of our rebuttal.

[1] Leviathan, Yaniv, Matan Kalman, and Yossi Matias. "Fast inference from transformers via speculative decoding." International conference on machine learning. PMLR, 2023.

[2] Li, Yuhui, et al. "Eagle-2: Faster inference of language models with dynamic draft trees." Proceedings of the 2024 conference on empirical methods in natural language processing. 2024.

[3] Bachmann, Gregor, et al. "Judge decoding: Faster speculative sampling requires going beyond model alignment." International Conference on Learning Representations. Vol. 2025. 2025.

[4] Kumar, Tanishq, Tri Dao, and Avner May. "Speculative speculative decoding." arXiv preprint arXiv:2603.03251 (2026).

Reviewer_T627OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies speculative decoding with diffusion LLM drafters and argues that it has two speed-quality knobs: the drafter's number of diffusion steps K and the verifier's acceptance leniency. It shows that linear interpolation between the verifier and drafter distributions is optimal under a TV constraint, and justifies using the final-step diffusion probabilities as proposals. Experiments sweep both knobs for Dream-7B→Qwen2.5-32B and DiffusionGemma→Gemma-4-31B, and compare SDAR, Uno, DFlash and DSpark under a shared Qwen3-8B verifier. The main finding is that the speed-accuracy frontier is occupied by different K values, and that varying both knobs extends SDAR's frontier.

Critical strengths
  1. The two-knob view (diffusion effort and acceptance leniency) is a clear and useful way to think about diffusion drafters, and both latency and throughput are reported.
  2. The experiments cover masked, uniform, block and one-step drafters, and negative results (e.g., the one-step drafters remain strong) are reported honestly.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The gain of joint variation is not quantified. The joint grid contains every single-K setting, so the joint frontier cannot be worse by construction, but no speedup at matched accuracy is reported. For Dream and DiffusionGemma, most of the extension sits in the low-accuracy region, and near verifier accuracy the specialized one-step drafters such as DFlash are still faster.

  2. Limited novelty and thin theory. The interpolation rule is not original, and Theorem 1 is a short triangle-inequality argument. Proposition 2 covers one token with a fixed target, but it is used to claim exact sampling for multi-step block drafts with out-of-order unmasking.

  3. Weak comparator for SDAR. SDAR is trained with a multi-step diffusion objective, so beating its own K = 1 setting is expected, and there is no SDAR-only curve (without the verifier) to show what verification adds.

  4. typos such as "does cannot capture" and "is capable of can running".

Questions for authors

na

3 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 1

Dear Reviewer T627,

We thank the reviewer for their feedback and appreciate that they find our framework “clear and useful”. We hope to address the critical comments below:

The gain of joint variation is not quantified. The joint grid contains every single-K setting, so the joint frontier cannot be worse by construction, but no speedup at matched accuracy is reported.

We thank the reviewer for their helpful critique and have worked to better quantify the speedup at matched accuracy. Following the reviewer's feedback, we have included additional results in Appendix G, where we computed the additional speedup due to using the joint variation over using a fixed diffusion efforts, which we use as baselines. Note that there is no natural baseline in this framework, because for example the verifier by itself has a single accuracy by definition, which cannot support a "matched accuracy" evaluation, which is why we use each of the fixed diffusion effort drafters as baselines. In Figure 17, 18 and 19, we show the additional speedup factor against the baselines, where each curve represents the speedup against a fixed diffusion steps or a fixed unmasking threshold value. Table 7 and 8 report the exact numerical values that are in the Figure 17, 18 and 19, corresponding to the single step diffusion drafter baseline curve. Note that each column of the table shows the speedup factor of using the joint variation against the baseline of the single step diffusion drafter at matched accuracy. Here are the results.

Latency Speedup over K=1 (×) with Relative Accuracy (% of Verifier)

ModelTask100%95%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%
Dream-7BGSM8K1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.01× (0.02)1.03× (0.04)1.16× (0.05)1.38× (0.05)1.43× (0.10)1.60× (0.08)2.45× (0.41)
DiffusionGemma-26BGPQA1.22× (0.28)1.51× (0.57)1.75× (0.65)3.30× (0.64)5.41× (1.01)8.86× (1.59)13.82× (0.99)14.26× (0.35)14.71× (0.53)
SDAR-1.7BGSM8K--1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.39× (0.06)2.06× (0.12)2.18× (0.12)2.23× (0.08)2.27× (0.06)2.26× (0.05)
SDAR-1.7BHumanEval1.00×1.02× (0.01)1.03× (0.02)1.07× (0.05)1.10× (0.08)1.14× (0.11)1.18× (0.14)1.37× (0.13)1.75× (0.14)
SDAR-8BGSM8K1.07× (0.12)1.77× (0.61)2.27× (0.56)2.55× (0.06)2.51× (0.03)2.47× (0.02)2.39× (0.03)2.30× (0.04)2.17× (0.10)
SDAR-8BHumanEval--1.02× (0.03)1.06× (0.06)1.15× (0.13)1.25× (0.22)1.36× (0.32)1.50× (0.36)1.73× (0.26)1.99× (0.15)

Throughput Gain over K=1 (×) with Relative Accuracy (% of Verifier)

ModelTask100%95%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%
Dream-7BGSM8K1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.01)1.00× (0.01)1.04× (0.05)1.08× (0.08)1.08× (0.07)1.13× (0.09)1.38× (0.24)
DiffusionGemma-26BGPQA1.29× (0.30)1.48× (0.43)1.62× (0.59)2.82× (1.67)4.24× (1.80)6.38× (1.57)9.17× (0.62)8.82× (0.53)8.48× (0.49)
SDAR-1.7BGSM8K--1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.36× (0.06)1.96× (0.09)2.10× (0.06)2.21× (0.04)2.25× (0.05)2.17× (0.05)
SDAR-1.7BHumanEval1.00×1.01× (0.01)1.01× (0.02)1.03× (0.05)1.04× (0.08)1.06× (0.10)1.07× (0.13)1.22× (0.11)1.50× (0.10)
SDAR-8BGSM8K1.05× (0.09)1.58× (0.45)1.94× (0.41)2.23× (0.05)2.31× (0.07)2.40× (0.11)2.38× (0.09)2.34× (0.06)2.22× (0.12)
SDAR-8BHumanEval--1.01× (0.02)1.05× (0.02)1.12× (0.03)1.20× (0.04)1.28× (0.05)1.35× (0.06)1.39× (0.04)1.43× (0.03)

As you correctly point out, the joint frontier cannot be worse by construction as it is optimizing over a strictly larger config space, but here we show that at some accuracies the speedup is quite substantial. For example, at 90% relative accuracy, SDAR-8B achieves a 2.27x latency speedup and 1.94x throughput gain on GSM8K.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 2

For Dream and DiffusionGemma, most of the extension sits in the low-accuracy region, and near verifier accuracy the specialized one-step drafters such as DFlash are still faster.

We must respectfully point out that the improvement being limited to the “low-accuracy region” is inaccurate. In fact, most of the “extension” sits in the high-accuracy region, as can be seen in Figure 4. For example, DiffusionGemma achieves a 1.51× latency speedup over K=1 at 95% of verifier accuracy and 1.22× at 100%, as can be seen in the newly added Appendix G.

On GSM8K, SDAR-8B achieves 21.4% lower latency than DFlash at 90% of the verifier's accuracy (1.140 s versus 1.450 s) and 30.7% lower latency at 80% (0.995 s versus 1.436 s), so one cannot conclude that DFlash is always faster. This can also be seen in Figure 11's top left graph where the DFlash curve shows its accuracy drops dramatically without achieving any significant speedup at higher leniency values.

While DFlash performs better on HumanEval, it must be restated that SDAR which is not trained as drafter achieves significant improvement such that it is competitive. This emphasizes the importance of our thesis, which is that joint variation can enable Pareto optimal multistep diffusion drafting. There is no reason in principle that DFlash could not have been trained for multi-step drafting and see a similar improvement.

Limited novelty and thin theory. The interpolation rule is not original, and Theorem 1 is a short triangle-inequality argument.

We respectfully disagree that our work exhibits “limited novelty”. Prior works on speculative diffusion have not found multi-step diffusion to be beneficial because the goal was lossless decoding. We demonstrate that multiple step diffusion drafting is indeed desirable when relaxing the acceptance criteria of speculative decoding.

We do not claim the “interpolation rule” itself is original, and the paper credits prior uses. However, unlike prior works, our contribution poses a constrained-optimization characterization, which maximizes acceptance under a token-level TV budget, and our proof establishes a tradeoff under those assumptions. The theory serves as the basis by which the tradeoff between speed and quality is made rigorous. In addition, we justify why multi-step block diffusion drafting gives exact target distributions under traditional rejection sampling.

Proposition 2 covers one token with a fixed target, but it is used to claim exact sampling for multi-step block drafts with out-of-order unmasking.

In order to prove all elements in a set SS has a property, it suffices to show that for any element xx in SS, xx has that property. Proposition 2 states that exact sampling for multi-step block drafts can be achieved by using the final drafting probability at each position. In order to prove this, it suffices to prove that exact sampling can be achieved for multi-step diffusion drafts at any position xx, which is what Proposition 2 proves, where it shows that for any position xx, exact sampling can be achieved regardless of the diffusion trajectory, as long as final drafting probability for xx is used for performing the rejection sampling at xx.

We have updated the manuscript to make this clearer.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 3

Weak comparator for SDAR. SDAR is trained with a multi-step diffusion objective, so beating its own K = 1 setting is expected, and there is no SDAR-only curve (without the verifier) to show what verification adds.

SDAR being trained with a multi-step diffusion objective does not make “beating its own K=1 setting expected”. It is not obvious a priori that any configuration of multi-step drafting could be Pareto optimal in speculative diffusion. As K increases, the drafter call takes longer, so while the drafting quality might increase, the latency and throughput could become worse, which is one of the two Pareto tradeoffs this paper focuses on. Coupled with the other leniency tradeoff, the picture is even more complex, which no prior work demonstrates. For instance, not only is SDAR with multistep drafting better than K=1, it is better by a substantial margin. We better represent the results of Figure 5 by computing percentage improvement at fixed accuracy.

To quantify this advantage, we added comparisons between full Pareto frontier and K=1 at a fixed minimum accuracy in Appendix G. The table provides several concrete examples:

  • SDAR-8B on GSM8K: At 90% of relative accuracy, 2.27× latency speedup and 1.94× throughput gain. At 95% of verifier accuracy, 1.77× latency improvement and 1.58× throughput gain.
  • SDAR-1.7B on GSM8K: At 50% of relative accuracy, the improvements are 2.23x in latency and 2.21x in throughput.

In addition, in accordance with your feedback, we have updated Figure 5 to include “SDAR-only” shown as orange and blue stars for SDAR-1.7B and SDAR-8B using default generation parameters. On HumanEval, standalone SDAR achieves only 28.0% and 39.6% pass@1, respectively, whereas verification extends the maximum observed accuracy to 85.4% and 86.6%. On GSM8K, the corresponding increases are 64.2% to 92.8% and 85.0% to 93.0%. Thus, verification substantially extends the attainable accuracy of SDAR.

typos such as "does cannot capture" and "is capable of can running".

Thank you for identifying these errors. We will correct both.

We thank the reviewer for their time. We kindly request that they increase their score if all of their concerns have been addressed.

Reviewer_aqpfOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the speed-quality trade-off in speculative decoding with diffusion drafters by jointly varying denoising effort and verification leniency. It presents a cost model and evaluates empirical latency and throughput versus task accuracy across several model pairs and benchmarks.

Critical strengths

The joint study of two interacting design choices provides a useful empirical view of speed-quality operating points for speculative diffusion. Reporting both end-to-end latency and throughput helps clarify practical trade-offs, and the paper evaluates multiple model pairs and acceptance rules.

Critical weaknesses

The individual ingredients are familiar, and the incremental contribution is primarily the analysis of their interaction. The strength and generality of the empirical improvements remain uncertain: the evaluation excludes some model-benchmark combinations and the gains depend on the drafter and operating point. The simplified cost model captures qualitative trends but does not closely predict all measured results.

Questions for authors

At matched task accuracy, how much end-to-end latency improvement does joint tuning provide over a tuned single-step drafter for each main model and task? How stable are these differences across random seeds or repeated runs?

2 comments
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 1

Dear Reviewer aqpf,

Thank you for your review. We hope to address each of your concerns.

The individual ingredients are familiar, and the incremental contribution is primarily the analysis of their interaction.

We respectfully disagree with this characterization of our contribution. “Ingredients are familiar” is a broad standard that includes every paper built upon existing work. Combining existing approaches in novel ways that reveal new interactions is standard in research. We challenge the idea that our contribution is “incremental”. Prior works on speculative diffusion have not found multi-step diffusion to be beneficial because the goal was lossless decoding. We demonstrate that multiple step diffusion drafting is indeed desirable when relaxing the acceptance criteria of speculative decoding.

The strength and generality of the empirical improvements remain uncertain: the evaluation excludes some model-benchmark combinations and the gains depend on the drafter and operating point.

The contribution of this paper should not be thought of as a single method that achieves improvement in every instance over single-step diffusion drafting, but rather a framework for speculative diffusion that has not been studied previously. If multistep drafting with relaxed acceptance does not help for a particular operating point, we consider that an empirical finding in our framework and not a limitation. While not every result is interesting, in light of your feedback we have included every model-benchmark combination in the Appendix F.5.

The simplified cost model captures qualitative trends but does not closely predict all measured results.

The current model estimates acceptance without measuring it online. Its predictions can therefore differ from the realized acceptance on prefixes generated under each decoding configuration. When using the online acceptance numbers, we can achieve very accurate predictions.

At the reviewer's request, to quantify this effect, we added a held-out evaluation using Dream-7B and Qwen2.5-32B on GSM8K. We calibrate acceptance statistics and timing costs on 50 problems and evaluate throughput predictions on 450 disjoint problems. Holding the throughput formula and fitted costs fixed, substituting configuration-specific online acceptance reduces mean absolute percentage error from 55.3% to 10.1%. For more details, please see Appendix I (Figure 24 and Table 9).

However, using online acceptance rates diminishes the purpose of the cost model because measuring online acceptance rates will also measure the empirical cost. We maintain that the cost model as currently formulated suffices in its conceptual purpose of explaining how additional drafting steps can shift the verifier agreement acceptance rate curve and throughput as a consequence.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Rebuttal Part 2

At matched task accuracy, how much end-to-end latency improvement does joint tuning provide over a tuned single-step drafter for each main model and task?

We thank the reviewer for suggesting comparison at fixed accuracy, as it can improve the clarity of our results. Following the reviewer's feedback, we have included additional results in Appendix G, where we computed the additional speedup due to using the joint variation over using a fixed diffusion efforts, which we use as baselines. Note that there is no natural baseline in this framework, because for example the verifier by itself has a single accuracy by definition, which cannot support a "matched accuracy" evaluation, which is why we use each of the fixed diffusion effort drafters as baselines. In Figure 17, 18 and 19, we show the additional speedup factor against the baselines, where each curve represents the speedup against a fixed diffusion steps or a fixed unmasking threshold value. Table 7 and 8 report the exact numerical values that are in the Figure 17, 18 and 19, corresponding to the single step diffusion drafter baseline curve. Note that each column of the table shows the speedup factor of using the joint variation against the baseline of the single step diffusion drafter at matched accuracy. Here are the results.

Latency Speedup over K=1 (×) with Relative Accuracy (% of Verifier)

ModelTask100%95%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%
Dream-7BGSM8K1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.01× (0.02)1.03× (0.04)1.16× (0.05)1.38× (0.05)1.43× (0.10)1.60× (0.08)2.45× (0.41)
DiffusionGemma-26BGPQA1.22× (0.28)1.51× (0.57)1.75× (0.65)3.30× (0.64)5.41× (1.01)8.86× (1.59)13.82× (0.99)14.26× (0.35)14.71× (0.53)
SDAR-1.7BGSM8K--1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.39× (0.06)2.06× (0.12)2.18× (0.12)2.23× (0.08)2.27× (0.06)2.26× (0.05)
SDAR-1.7BHumanEval1.00×1.02× (0.01)1.03× (0.02)1.07× (0.05)1.10× (0.08)1.14× (0.11)1.18× (0.14)1.37× (0.13)1.75× (0.14)
SDAR-8BGSM8K1.07× (0.12)1.77× (0.61)2.27× (0.56)2.55× (0.06)2.51× (0.03)2.47× (0.02)2.39× (0.03)2.30× (0.04)2.17× (0.10)
SDAR-8BHumanEval--1.02× (0.03)1.06× (0.06)1.15× (0.13)1.25× (0.22)1.36× (0.32)1.50× (0.36)1.73× (0.26)1.99× (0.15)

Throughput Gain over K=1 (×) with Relative Accuracy (% of Verifier)

ModelTask100%95%90%80%70%60%50%40%30%
Dream-7BGSM8K1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.01)1.00× (0.01)1.04× (0.05)1.08× (0.08)1.08× (0.07)1.13× (0.09)1.38× (0.24)
DiffusionGemma-26BGPQA1.29× (0.30)1.48× (0.43)1.62× (0.59)2.82× (1.67)4.24× (1.80)6.38× (1.57)9.17× (0.62)8.82× (0.53)8.48× (0.49)
SDAR-1.7BGSM8K--1.00× (0.00)1.00× (0.00)1.36× (0.06)1.96× (0.09)2.10× (0.06)2.21× (0.04)2.25× (0.05)2.17× (0.05)
SDAR-1.7BHumanEval1.00×1.01× (0.01)1.01× (0.02)1.03× (0.05)1.04× (0.08)1.06× (0.10)1.07× (0.13)1.22× (0.11)1.50× (0.10)
SDAR-8BGSM8K1.05× (0.09)1.58× (0.45)1.94× (0.41)2.23× (0.05)2.31× (0.07)2.40× (0.11)2.38× (0.09)2.34× (0.06)2.22× (0.12)
SDAR-8BHumanEval--1.01× (0.02)1.05× (0.02)1.12× (0.03)1.20× (0.04)1.28× (0.05)1.35× (0.06)1.39× (0.04)1.43× (0.03)

Although results vary depending on the dataset and model, we would like to highlight the following results. At 90% relative accuracy, SDAR-8B achieves a 2.27x latency speedup and 1.94x throughput gain on GSM8K. At 100% relative accuracy, we find 1.22x latency speedup and 1.29x throughput gain for DiffusionGemma on GPQA. In addition, at 50% relative accuracy, that configuration achieves 13.82x latency speedup and 9.17x throughput gain. While 50% relative accuracy is a significant drop in accuracy, the speedup is considerable.

How stable are these differences across random seeds or repeated runs?

In the above table we report the standard errors obtained by using a block jackknife estimator in the parentheses, where the problems for each model-benchmark combination are divided into 10 disjoint blocks. Based on the computed standard errors, we find that the differences are quite stable.

We hope to have addressed your concerns and can answer any follow-up questions.

Comments on the paper

1 comment
AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Summary of Changes

Dear Reviewers,

Thank you again for your feedback. With the discussion period nearing its end, we wanted to highlight the major revisions added to the updated manuscript in response to your reviews.

  1. Report Speedup at Matched Accuracy. We have added tables and plots to show the speedup for different models and benchmarks at matched accuracy, which is requested by all three reviewers. Contrary to reviewer concerns, we find meaningful speedup even at 90% relative accuracy. These results can be found in Appendix G of the manuscript.
  2. Realistic Serving Conditions. We performed additional experiments to show the speed-accuracy tradeoff pattern holds under concurrent serving conditions. The results are added to Appendix H.
  3. Exhaustive Inclusion of Experiments. We have also included 3 more experiments to show the complete results of all possible model-benchmark combinations. See Appendix F.5.

In light of these changes, we encourage reviewers to engage with our rebuttals, and welcome any remaining questions or feedback before the discussion window closes.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.