W1. The novelty relative to existing decomposition-and-generation pipelines is insufficiently established.
The high-level strategy of generating selected regions separately and assembling them into a larger 3D representation has substantial precedent. In particular, SAM 3D Objects reconstructs mask-conditioned objects together with their geometry, texture, and spatial layout. Although object-level scene assembly differs from replacing a connected subregion of an existing mesh, this related work makes it important to identify precisely what NOFACE3D contributes beyond localized generation and placement.
The paper should discuss this distinction explicitly and include a task-matched comparison where feasible. For example, a segmentation-guided local reconstruction pipeline could regenerate the same selected region and place it back into the source asset, with alignment and reintegration procedures documented. Boundary quality, local fidelity, preservation, and computational cost would then help establish the additional value of NOFACE3D.
The capacity-allocation argument is also relevant to scenes or multi-object assets, where small objects receive limited representation capacity. A scene-level experiment would help establish the broader usefulness of the approach, although the authors should distinguish independent-object replacement from connected-surface refinement. At present, the conceptual contribution appears incremental, and the necessity of the particular sampling mechanism is not sufficiently isolated.
W2. Robustness to local reparameterization and the loss of global context needs stronger investigation.
Extracting, rescaling, and re-encoding a component changes its coordinate frame, spatial discretization, and available context. Consequently, its local latent representation need not match the representation it had within the complete asset. This difference is not inherently problematic, but it raises questions about whether the regenerated geometry remains compatible with its surroundings beyond the explicitly anchored band.
The existing ablation removes boundary anchoring and spatial scheduling together and primarily provides qualitative evidence. It therefore does not determine whether the proposed schedule specifically addresses these issues, or whether a simpler hard boundary mask with uniform interior noise would suffice.
I would encourage controlled experiments varying crop size, crop position, retained context, and the number of attachment boundaries. Particularly useful measurements would include local reconstruction error, boundary position and normal discontinuities, changes outside the selected region, and consistency across slightly perturbed boxes. These experiments would clarify whether the method is robust to reasonable region selections rather than dependent on carefully chosen crops.
W3. Improvement of unseen and geometrically complex surfaces remains insufficiently demonstrated.
Rescaling a region increases its effective spatial resolution, but it does not introduce new observations. The refinement remains conditioned on a single image crop, which may provide little information about side surfaces, rear surfaces, cavities, or occluded connections. The method can synthesize such geometry through its pretrained prior, but plausible additional detail should be distinguished from faithful recovery.
This distinction matters for complex objects, where a sharper frontal appearance can coexist with incorrect hidden geometry. The reported whole-asset metrics do not adequately isolate these cases, and preference-based evaluation alone cannot establish geometric accuracy.
The authors should evaluate the selected region separately across visible and occluded surfaces, using reference meshes where available. Region-specific geometry metrics, side and rear views, sectional visualizations, and examples involving cavities or thin connected structures would be informative. An optional multiview-conditioning experiment could further establish whether the observed limitations arise from insufficient visual evidence or from the refinement procedure itself.