acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Input-Aligned Grid-State Handoffs Enable Compositional Visual Execution

18 views

Abstract

In visual programs closed over grid states, learned operations can execute accurately in isolation yet fail when composed. We study which boundary representation converts available primitive transitions into execution when the program is supplied. Re-entering each intermediate result through the shared spatial color interface raises exact accuracy on unseen primitive pairs from 43.5% to 88.2% under matched training, with the advantage persisting on longer programs. With every learned weight fixed, the same handoff raises held-out-pair accuracy from 29.2% to 87.6%. Matched position-wise probes recover the intermediate grid from both executors, and grid-state re-entry makes that information directly consumable by the next operation. The advantage also transfers to grounded-object operations and programs recovered from demonstrations. For closed grid-to-grid visual programs, familiar operations compose when every intermediate result returns through the grid representation consumed by the next operation.

Primary area:
neurosymbolic & hybrid AI systems (physics-informed, logic & formal reasoning, etc.)
Keywords:
compositional generalization, visual reasoning, neural program execution, intermediate representations, execution boundary design

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Top 15%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 3.00 over 3 reviews, above 85% of the others.
Reviewer_UGJYOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
3
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper investigates the intermediate-state interface between visual operations using closed grid-to-grid programs. The authors construct two parameter-matched executors: latent handoff, which directly passes hidden states between operations, and input-aligned grid-state re-entry, which re-encodes each predicted intermediate grid through the shared color and positional input interface. Grid-state re-entry achieves approximately 44 percentage points of improvement in exact-grid accuracy on held-out operation pairs and longer programs. Experiments involving frozen-model rollout, position-wise probes, boundary-component ablations, MMD controls, transfer to grounded-object operations, and six-step execution chains collectively support the explanation that intermediate states must be represented in a form directly consumable by subsequent operations.

Critical strengths

Rigorous isolation of the key experimental variable. The latent-handoff and grid-state executors share the same 12.9M parameters, primitive-wise computation, training data, final-output supervision, and update budget. All matched seeds consistently favor grid-state re-entry on the Pair and Depth splits, providing substantially stronger evidence than empirical improvements from a single model configuration.

Comprehensive mechanistic evidence. The experiments systematically examine intermediate supervision, spatial alignment, color-simplex representations, MMD-based distribution matching, intermediate-state probes, and frozen-model rollout. These controls help rule out alternative explanations based solely on increased depth, additional parameters, or marginal distribution matching, and provide evidence that the input-aligned execution boundary plays a central role in compositional generalization.

Critical weaknesses

Insufficient explanation of the underlying failure mechanism of latent handoff. Although the experiments convincingly demonstrate the effectiveness of input-aligned grid-state re-entry, they do not fully explain why latent handoff fails in the first place. In particular, given that the latent-handoff executor is trained end-to-end, why does it fail to learn stable and reusable hidden representations across successive operations? A more direct investigation of the underlying representational incompatibility would strengthen the mechanistic understanding of the proposed approach.

Questions for authors

Please refer to Weaknesses

Reviewer_qWZwOpenReview ↗
Rating
3
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper studies the learning and generalization of compositional visual (colored grid) operations. The core research question is how intermediate states should be passed between two operations when the order and type information of the operations are given. The research proposes input-aligned grid-state re-entry, which decodes the intermediate representation into an explicit distribution of grid colors, and re-encodes with shared input embeddings as the input of the second operation. A latent handoff baseline (passing hidden state without decoding) and a one-pass execution baseline (a single model call instead of two) are used for comparison.

In particular, the model are trained on synthetic grid transformation tasks, covering 7 operation families, with two training settings: single- and two-operation programs with final-output supervision. The learned model are further evaluated on familiar programs, unseen operation pairs and long compositions (1~6 steps).

The main findings of the experiments include: (1) grid-state re-entry significantly improves accuracy on compositional operations; (2) in the latent handoff baseline, intermediate grid states are also available for decoding (with an extra probe layer), but has a much lower compositional performance; (3) similar performance gains are observed when reusing frozen checkpoints, evaluating longer programs, and transferring to grounded-object operations. The authors claimed that returning intermediate states to the input representation improves the compositionality of the learned operations.

Critical strengths
  1. The main comparison of intermediate state representations is well controlled and the significant performance difference brings interesting insights. Compared to the latent handoff method, the grid-state re-entry method has substantial improvement on held-out validation accuracy. The experiment is well-controlled (model sizes, training data, operation primitives and supervision signals, etc.). This support the insight that explicit decoding is an useful inducted bias for such compositional operation learning task.

  2. The paper also provides an interesting intermediate state reuseability analysis. The linear probe experiment shows that both methods are able to decode the final grid representation from the intermediate information, despite their performance gap. The frozen-checkpoint and longer-program experiments further demonstrate that learned operations can be effectively reused through grid-state feedback. These results provide interesting insights into compositional execution.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The effect of input alignment is not fully separated from the representation bottleneck. (Section 4.4.) The proposed method (grid-state re-entry) also introduces a normalized, low-dimensional intermediate representation, which may itself improve training and generalization. Although the authors provide several ablations, some alternatives, such as untied codebooks, suffer from training instability. It is therefore unclear how much of the improvement comes specifically from input alignment rather than the constrained representation.

  2. Concerns on whether this experimental setting is meaningful for general purpose. The experiments assume a known program and a predefined grid representation that is sufficient for every operation. This provides a strong task-specific prior for the proposed method. Also, the models are trained on at most two-operation programs, while longer programs are only tested during inference. It is unclear whether the method would remain effective when training on longer compositions or applying it to less structured tasks.

Questions for authors

Q1. Could the authors provide a comparison with a similar low-dimensional, normalized bottleneck? For the untied-codebook experiments, would matching the initialization and improving training stability change the results?

Q2. Have the authors tried training on three-operation programs instead of only one- and two-operation programs? Would the performance of grid-state re-entry remain stable, and how would the gap with latent handoff change?

Q3. Could the authors report the actual intermediate-grid accuracy using the model's own decoding head, rather than a separately trained linear probe? This would help verify whether each step actually performs the intended operation.

Q4. In the supplementary code, the hard-feedback evaluation of the generic scratchpad appears to omit the step index, while step embeddings are used during training. Could the authors clarify whether this affects the results in Table 4? Also, the third-step embedding is actually unseen in the training, could it affect the Depth performance?

Reviewer_y5HgOpenReview ↗
Rating
3(+1)
Confidence
3
Informativeness
3(+2)
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies the problem of closed grid-to-grid visual program execution. Given an initial colored grid and an explicitly provided sequence of operations, the model progressively executes operations such as rotation, translation, reflection, recoloring, and cropping, and outputs the final grid.

The paper compares two approaches for state transfer across steps:

  1. Latent handoff: The hidden state produced by the previous step is directly passed to the next step;
  2. Grid-state re-entry: The previous step's result is first decoded into a grid, then re-encoded through the shared visual input interface as input to the next step.

On self-constructed ARC-style tasks, the authors report that grid-state re-entry substantially outperforms latent handoff on unseen operation combinations and longer programs. For example, accuracy on held-out operation pairs improves from approximately 43.5% to approximately 88.2%, and accuracy on three-step programs improves from approximately 46.8% to approximately 91%.

The paper also reports experiments including frozen-model rollout, position-level intermediate-state probing, boundary representation ablations, six-step program chains, and grounded-object tasks, aiming to argue that intermediate information may already exist in the latent state, but only by converting it back into the grid input representation familiar to the next step can multi-step composition be reliably supported.

Critical strengths
  1. Clearly defined research question with relatively systematic internal controls

    The paper clearly compares two state interfaces across operation boundaries and makes efforts to match model scale, training data, compute, and final supervision. Multiple random seeds, frozen-model rollout, and intermediate-state probing also lend a degree of internal consistency to the results within the custom task setting.

  2. Distinguishes single-step capability from multi-step compositional capability

    The paper demonstrates that the model may already possess good single-step primitive competence yet fails to reliably execute multi-step programs. This phenomenon, along with the analysis that "intermediate states are readable but not necessarily effectively usable by the next step," offers some reference value for understanding compositional failures in neural executors.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Core results are highly predictable, and a fair latent baseline is missing

    The model is already trained to receive color-position grid representations, and the task itself is a closed grid-to-grid process. Therefore, grid-state re-entry directly places intermediate results back into the model's familiar canonical input space; in contrast, latent handoff feeds an unadapted hidden state directly as input to the next step. The resulting input distribution shift, representation mismatch, and multi-step error accumulation are naturally expected outcomes.

    Thus, the paper primarily demonstrates that "unadapted hidden-to-hidden connections are inferior to the standard grid interface," rather than that "explicit grid state is inherently superior to a reasonably designed latent interface." The paper lacks a strong latent baseline with learned adapters, normalization, position recovery, or dedicated latent rollout training, which weakens the novelty and explanatory power of the core conclusion.

  2. The task could in principle be solved directly by an explicit symbolic program, raising questions about the necessity of neural networks

    The paper explicitly provides the operation set, operation semantics, and operation sequences, and both inputs and outputs are discrete grids. Operations such as rotation, translation, reflection, recoloring, cropping, and masking could in principle be executed directly by a deterministic symbolic executor, thereby avoiding neural prediction errors, interface mismatch, and multi-step error accumulation.

    Therefore, the paper does not explain what problem the neural network solves in this task that a symbolic program could not. The current results read more like a comparison of two neural executor interfaces on a task that could be solved exactly by an explicit program, and the practical significance is limited.

  3. Conclusions are confined to a highly restricted custom setting and do not generalize easily

    The paper primarily uses self-constructed ARC-style, closed grid-to-grid tasks and typically assumes that operation sequences are given. This setting avoids rule discovery, program induction, and task interpretation found in standard ARC, and also makes grid states the most natural intermediate representation.

    The paper does not validate on standard ARC, ConceptARC, CLOSURE, or other public visual program execution benchmarks, nor does it sufficiently test unknown programs, non-grid intermediate states, or other model architectures. Therefore, the current results can only support a narrow conclusion: within known program sequences and closed grid-state spaces, a normalized grid interface outperforms unadapted latent handoff; its applicability to general visual reasoning or neural program execution remains unproven.

Questions for authors

Clarification Requests

  1. Does latent handoff use any interface adaptation?​

    Please clarify whether the hidden state undergoes LayerNorm, linear projection, positional encoding recovery, scale calibration, or any other learnable adaptation. If not, why do the authors consider unadapted latent handoff a fair baseline against grid-state re-entry?

  2. How are single-step and multi-step tasks trained? ​ Please specify the sampling ratio of single-step and two-step tasks, training order, supervision format, and checkpoint selection procedure, and confirm whether both interfaces use exactly the same data and optimization process. In particular, please clarify whether the main experiments use intermediate grid supervision or teacher forcing.

  3. Is there structural leakage in the Pair and Depth splits? ​ Please clarify whether the training and test sets share operation parameter patterns, intermediate grid templates, or exploitable generation rules. Otherwise, the compositional generalization implications of the Pair/Depth splits are unclear.

Additional Validation That Could Change the Assessment

  1. Have stronger latent baselines been tested?

    Please report results for latent methods with learned latent adapters, primitive-specific projections, normalization, position recovery, latent intermediate supervision, teacher forcing, or scheduled sampling. This will determine whether the paper demonstrates a unique advantage of grid state, or merely that unadapted latent connections perform poorly.

  2. Has the method been validated on standard benchmarks or more general tasks?

    Please clarify whether the authors have tested the method on standard ARC, ConceptARC, CLOSURE, or other public visual program execution benchmarks. If not, would the authors be willing to explicitly restrict the main conclusion to: within known program sequences and closed grid-to-grid state spaces, a normalized grid interface outperforms unadapted latent handoff?

Comments on the paper

6 comments

Thanks for the authors' responses, but I do not agree with the response to the core concern about the predictability of this work. The response said: "Why the result is not simply predictable. The latent state already contains the result: the model's own head reads the intermediate grid from it with 98.2% accuracy, so information content alone predicts no gap." I want to clarify that the review never said that the latent state loss needed information to make the combinatorial process degrade. Rather, it is the input gap—meaning the distribution gap—that causes the degradation, because the model is trained on the grid input but not on the contrastive latent state before output head. It is quite predictable that performance with latent state input will degrade a lot, even though this state contains the needed information. Let me give a not-so-perfect but illustrative example: if a language model has just been trained on an English corpus, it cannot understand a Chinese or German sentence, although the information is contained in the sentence. Later, you give a further explanation of the performance degradation of latent state inputs with shortcut; I think this explanation does not conflict with the input domain or distribution gap term—it is just at a more specific level. So until now, I still think this core concern has not been addressed. If you have further clarification, please let me know. Thanks again for the detailed response.

AuthorsOpenReview ↗

Further response to Reviewer y5Hg

Thank you for the clarification. Your concern rests on the successor being trained on grid inputs but not on latent states. In our setup, it is trained on latent states.

  1. Latent states are not an unseen input domain. The second call of the latent executor receives the first operation's latent state in all 966 two-operation training tasks, trained end to end. On familiar two-operation programs with new grids, latent handoff reaches 89.4% (Appendix G.4). It fails only when the same kind of latent input comes from a predecessor never paired with that operation (43.5% on Pair). A gap between grid and latent inputs would predict failure in both cases; we observe it only for held-out pairs.

  2. What helps is the grid format, not closeness to the grid distribution. Training the boundary state to match the distribution of real input-grid embeddings reduces the MMD about 400-fold, to within 4× of the floor between two real samples, yet Pair accuracy is 25.1% (Table 7). Shifting the latent mean to the mean the successor saw in training leaves Pair unchanged (43.8% vs 43.5%). In contrast, Pair rises as the state adopts the structure of the input format: 77.3% with a learned adapter that restores LayerNorm and positions, 82.8% with a normalized codebook over 11 colours, and 88.2% when that codebook is the input dictionary itself.

  3. The failure separates predecessors. After reflect (seen) and rotate (held out), the translation routing head places 34% and 39% of its weight on the source cell, both far below the 99% on grid inputs, yet accuracy is 71% and 41% (Table 8). A linear classifier identifies the predecessor from the latent state with 100% accuracy, against 47.8% from the grid encoding of the same grids. The successor has learned to read latent states from the predecessors it was trained with.

We agree that held-out pairs are a distribution shift by construction, so some degradation is expected. What the input-domain account does not predict is that (i) latent inputs trained end to end fail only for unseen predecessors, (ii) matching the grid distribution does not help while adopting the grid format does, and (iii) a whole-task model trained without step decomposition already contains reusable transitions, so that grid-state rollout of the same frozen weights raises Pair from 29.2% to 87.6% (Table 3).

Thank you for the further clarification. I had indeed overlooked the fact that the latent-state executor was also trained end to end on two-operation programs, and I apologize for this oversight. Your response has helped me better appreciate the value of the paper.

To understand the training setup more precisely, I would appreciate clarification on the following questions about each held-out two-operation program A --> B:

  1. Were A and B each observed individually in single-operation training tasks?
  2. Did both A and B also appear in other two-operation training programs, regardless of their positions?
  3. Did every held-out predecessor A appear as the first operation in at least one training program A --> C? Likewise, did every successor B appear as the second operation in at least one training program D --> B?

If possible, could you clarify these points both at the operation-family level and at the level of primitives with their specific parameters? This would help me understand whether the evaluation isolates an unseen pairing of operations that have already been trained in their respective roles.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.