- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper introduces a new benchmark and a VLM-based method for vocabulary-free texture less 3D object identification using active inspection. The model iteratively selects the next viewpoint based on previous observations and predicts discriminative geometric features that can support or reject competing identity hypotheses.
Critical strengths
- The benchmark targets a new task/setting: free-form identification of isolated 3D objects from multiple images from geometry alone without texture or environment cue.
- The method seem to give advantage compare to random sampling and single view point inspection.
Critical weaknesses
A major weakness is the limited set of baselines used to establish the benefit of the proposed active-inspection strategy. The paper compares against single-view recognition, random multi-view sampling, and an ablation in which the VLM selects views without explicit hypothesis testing. However, several obvious alternatives are missing. First, a deterministic geometric baseline using mutually orthogonal or approximately uniformly distributed viewpoints would provide a stronger comparison than random sampling. Second, the authors should evaluate a fixed multi-view baseline in which the VLM receives several images with viewpoints simultaneously . Third, a free form agentic baseline, in which the VLM is given a viewpoint-selection tool and independently decides where to look and when to stop with only basic prompt, would help establish whether GLANCE's explicit hypothesis-generation and verification procedure provides an advantage over generic VLM agent behavior. Given that active inspection is a central methodological contribution, these comparisons are essential for justification for the proposed strategy.
In addition, the recognition experiments are conducted with only a single proprietary VLM (GPT-6 Astra), while another proprietary model (GPT-5.6 Luna) is used for clustering and semantic evaluation. This makes it unclear whether the benefits of GLANCE generalize across different VLMs. Moreover, the experiments rely on hosted model aliases whose underlying snapshots may change or completely phased out by the time the paper published, which limits reproducibility. Evaluating GLANCE with several different VLMs, including open-weight models, would substantially strengthen both the generality and reproducibility of the results.
Questions for authors
See weakness section
2 comments
I thank the authors but this don't really answer any of my concerns.
I maintain my rating.
*Mutually orthogonal meaning 90 angles between camera position and not dependent on object original orientation, same for letting LLM chose viewpoints.
*There plenty open and close models cheaper then Qwen3.8 Max which is both expensive and closed source.
We thank the reviewer for the constructive comments and suggestions regarding stronger passive baselines, generalization across different VLMs, and reproducibility.
Passive multi-view baselines
To further investigate the contribution of active inspection beyond the sequential baselines presented in Sec. 5.2, we implemented passive multiview baselines in which the same VLM receives 1, 3, or 6 rendered viewpoints simultaneously in a single call.
Our preliminary experiments on the Fusion 360 Assembly dataset showed substantial sensitivity to viewpoint selection, consistent with the motivation in Sec. 3.1. Among the tested three-view combinations, accuracy ranged from 40% to 80.7%, depending on the selected viewpoints. These results highlight the importance of viewpoint selection and motivate GLANCE's hypothesis-guided inspection strategy (Sec. 3.3).
Robustness to object orientation
As discussed in Sec. 3.1, CAD models do not necessarily have a canonical orientation. We therefore evaluated GLANCE and passive multiview baselines under upright, upside-down, and randomly rotated configurations, keeping the passive camera configurations fixed.
Recognition accuracy (%):
Under upright orientation, Passive-3 and Passive-6 outperform GLANCE. However, under upside-down orientation, GLANCE achieves 68.8% accuracy, compared with 57.7% for Passive-3. Under random rotations, GLANCE achieves 72%, outperforming both Passive-3 (50%) and Passive-6 (65%). These results suggest that GLANCE is less sensitive to object orientation, particularly when the canonical orientation is unknown. Moreover, GLANCE adaptively selects observations and requires only 2.63 views on average (Sec. 5.2), whereas the passive baselines always process three or six views. This highlights the potential of active inspection to maintain recognition accuracy while reducing the number of observations.
Generalization across recognition VLMs
We conducted preliminary experiments using Qwen3.8-Max on a limited set of 20 objects. Although this sample size is too small to draw definitive conclusions, the results were generally consistent with those obtained using GPT. However, we did not extend the evaluation to more objects for the following reasons.
The GLANCE framework remained identical for both models, including the view selection procedure, geometric hypothesis verification, and overall decision-making pipeline. The main difference was in how the underlying models reasoned when prompted to perform these tasks. Specifically, Qwen generated approximately 15,000 tokens on average to reach a prediction, compared with around 1,121 tokens for GPT. This significantly increased inference time, making Qwen considerably slower, despite both models following the same GLANCE procedure. We also experimented with reducing Qwen's token budget, but this led to a degradation in performance. Given these computational costs and the lack of clear performance improvements in our preliminary experiments, we decided to use GPT for the main evaluation rather than extending the experiments to additional models.
Reproducibility
We will release the complete GLANCE implementation, including all prompts, viewpoint configurations, rendering parameters, hypothesis management, geometric verification, and stopping criteria. We will also document the model identifiers, API configurations, inference parameters, software dependencies.