- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 4
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes CORE, a consensus-guided deep multi-view clustering framework with dual representation learning. It introduces two representation branches for each view: a deep branch to capture abstract semantic information and a shallow branch to preserve structural cues. A consensus target constructed from deep representations is used to encourage semantic invariance across views, while a hardness-aware contrastive learning module mines hard positive and negative samples to improve intra-cluster compactness and inter-cluster separation. The authors further provide theoretical analysis of the consensus mechanism and evaluate the proposed framework on several benchmark multi-view clustering datasets, showing improved performance over compared baselines.
Critical strengths
-
The combination of semantic representation learning, structural representation preservation, and contrastive refinement provides a reasonable approach for improving cluster discrimination.
-
The paper evaluates the proposed method on multiple benchmark datasets and provides ablation studies, visualization results, and parameter analysis, which offer useful evidence for the effectiveness of the framework.
Critical weaknesses
1. The motivation and problem formulation are not sufficiently differentiated from existing deep multi-view clustering methods.
The paper motivates CORE from the observation that existing methods mainly exploit deep representations while underusing shallow structural information. However, this distinction is not clearly established. Many existing deep MVC methods already explore complementary information, hierarchical representations, reconstruction constraints, graph structures, or contrastive objectives to preserve semantic and structural information.
The paper does not clearly demonstrate that the missing shallow structural information is a fundamental limitation of previous approaches rather than an alternative architectural design choice. In particular, it remains unclear what type of clustering information is uniquely captured by the shallow branch and why existing representation learning strategies cannot preserve such information.
2. The novelty and multi-view-specific advantage of the hard sample contrastive learning component are insufficiently justified.
The proposed HaSE module performs pseudo-label-guided hard positive and hard negative mining followed by contrastive learning. However, this design is closely related to existing contrastive learning paradigms, where difficult positive and negative pairs are selected to improve representation separability.
The paper does not clearly explain what is unique about hard sample mining in the multi-view clustering scenario. For example, it is unclear whether the selected hard samples correspond to view disagreement, unreliable consensus, or other specific multi-view ambiguities. Without such analysis, HaSE appears to be a general contrastive refinement strategy applied to MVC rather than a method addressing a unique challenge in multi-view clustering.
3. The theoretical analysis is not sufficiently connected to the main methodological contributions.
The theoretical results characterize when a discriminative view can dominate the consensus assignment. While the analysis is mathematically interesting, it mainly explains the behavior of the consensus mechanism rather than the necessity or effectiveness of the proposed dual representation learning and hard sample contrastive refinement. The connection between the theoretical results and the claimed advantages of CORE remains unclear.
Questions for authors
-
Existing MVC methods have extensively studied complementary information, semantic consistency, and structural preservation. What specific limitation of previous methods motivates introducing a separate shallow representation branch? Can the authors provide analysis showing that the shallow representation captures cluster-relevant information that is not already contained in the deep representation?
-
Several previous MVC methods already employ pseudo labels, cluster assignments, prototypes, or instance relationships for contrastive learning. What is the fundamental difference between HaSE and these existing contrastive MVC approaches? Is the improvement mainly due to harder pair selection, or does HaSE exploit a unique property of multi-view clustering?
-
Since HaSE relies on consensus-derived pseudo labels, how robust is CORE when the initial consensus representation is inaccurate or when different views provide conflicting clustering evidence? Is there any mechanism preventing incorrect pseudo labels from being reinforced during contrastive learning?