acceptodds
Withdrawn from ICLR 2027

Looking One Step Ahead: An Anticipation-guided Agent for Object State Readout in Videos

Withdrawn from ICLR 2027, so left out of the paper lists and the map.

Abstract

Understanding the progress of an activity requires tracking how the objects involved change over time. Object state readout provides this information by describing a target object's states and transitions across video frames. Although multimodal large language models (MLLMs) generate detailed visual descriptions, these descriptions may leave the attributes needed to distinguish successive states insufficiently specified. In this paper, we propose look-ahead state readout (LASER), an anticipation-guided agent for object state readout that uses possible next-step changes to determine which attributes to inspect in the present. Given temporally ordered frames and a target object, LASER converts anticipated changes into targeted visual questions and inspects the current frame to establish attribute values. It then checks state readouts and forecasts against independent observations of subsequent frames, refining a state record used to generate the final description. Reusable textual observation skills guide this process and are refined by tracing discrepancies with reference captions to the responsible instructions. Candidate revisions are selected on separate videos based on improved caption quality without increased contradictions with reference facts. Model parameters remain frozen throughout adaptation and inference, and the revised skills remain fixed during evaluation. Experiment results and further analysis on OSCaR and PLM RCap show consistent improvements of LASER over strong baselines and existing approaches, which demonstrates the effectiveness of our approach.

Primary area:
applications to computer vision, audio, language, and other modalities
Keywords:
world modeling, video understanding, multimodal agents, predictive attribute selection, feedback-guided skill adaptation

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_Ey3wOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
3
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
1
Read review
Paper summary

LASER addresses object-conditioned state readout in videos using a frozen multimodal model. Structured observation skills guide attribute inspection; hypotheses about future changes select discriminative attributes to reinspect in the current frame. Independent observations of subsequent frames support correction, and reference-based feedback revises reusable skills on training videos. Evaluation on OSCaR and PLM RCap uses four model backbones and compares prompting, reinspection, skill-optimization, and existing agent baselines.

Critical strengths
  1. Using anticipation to select current visual attributes is a meaningful observation principle. It targets the tendency of generic captioning to describe object categories or activities while missing attributes that distinguish state transitions. The workflow is interpretable and has practical benefits over direct captioning: with Qwen3.5-9B, OSCaR ROUGE-L increases from 26.9 to 29.6 and the PLM RCap score from 25.6 to 28.1. Evaluation across four backbones and two datasets provides useful breadth.

  2. The separation of observation from anticipation is thoughtful. Initial observations are obtained without the predictions, and later visual evidence can correct the hypotheses. Table 3 supports the importance of this separation: removing independent observation reduces Qwen3.5-9B scores from 29.6 to 29.0 on OSCaR and from 28.1 to 27.3 on PLM RCap. This is separation of prompt inputs and information flow, rather than independence of the underlying visual models.

Critical weaknesses
  1. Limited methodological novelty. The contribution mainly combines structured prompting, sequential verification, and prompt optimization. Anticipation-guided attribute selection is a sensible task-level design, but its distinctive observation capability beyond these existing mechanisms is not sufficiently demonstrated.

  2. Unclear attribution and computational fairness. Without skill revision, 4B LASER ties Attribute Checklist on OSCaR (26.7) and trails it on PLM RCap (25.9 versus 26.8). The independent benefit of anticipation remains unclear, and missing call/token/latency accounting makes it difficult to separate design gains from extra computation.

  3. Weak evidence for the specialized revision procedure. GEPA on the same LASER interfaces exceeds Full on OSCaR ROUGE-L for three of four backbones and on PLM RCap for two. Some gains over existing systems are also small, such as 29.6 versus 29.4 for ScaleCap. The added value of specialized revision is not established.

  4. Indirect evidence for factual state accuracy. Caption-reference similarity does not directly establish correct attributes or transitions. The revision-stage contradiction check is not a test-set factual evaluation, especially for details absent from references. The claimed improvement in object-state understanding needs direct support.

Questions for authors
  1. Does anticipation provide an independent benefit in a two-by-two comparison with skill revision on/off, while retaining visual correction?

  2. How do LASER and simpler reinspection/checklist baselines compare at matched model-call, visual-input, and token budgets? Please report their inference latency.

  3. What benefit does the specialized skill revision provide over GEPA on the same interfaces and at matched adaptation budgets?

  4. Does LASER improve test-set attribute and transition accuracy and reduce unsupported claims, including details absent from reference captions?

Reviewer_w34tOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

LASER is a frozen multimodal-LLM agent for object state readout. Given ordered frames and a target, it writes an initial observation, anticipates up to three next-step changes, turns those changes into current-frame questions tied to visual signs, reads the state, and uses later frames to correct the record without rewriting a past state that the evidence still supports. The adapted object is a text skill library, not the weights. On 500 training clips per benchmark, split 4:1 into revision and selection with videos kept disjoint, up to five rounds propose skill edits. An edit is kept only if caption agreement rises by at least 0.005 and contradictions do not increase. The experimental section states a normalized caption-quality score and a margin of 0.005, but it does not define that score. Prompts are not in the paper. There is no appendix. Evaluation uses the OSCaR state-change slot (three frames, 500 test clips, ROUGE-L as the primary metric) and PLM region captioning (eight frames, official LM similarity). Across Qwen3.5-4B, 9B, 35B-A3B, and Ministral-3-3B, full LASER gains +3.7, +2.7, +2.7, and +3.0 ROUGE-L over direct captioning, and +2.6, +2.5, +2.5, and +2.3 on the PLM score. On the main 9B model the full system is 9.9 / 32.0 / 10.1 / 29.6 (BLEU / ROUGE-1 / ROUGE-2 / ROUGE-L) and 28.1 PLM. Table 2, on that backbone only, puts it above five adapted captioning agents; the closest headline gaps are 0.2 ROUGE-L (ScaleCap 29.4) and 0.3 PLM (ReAgent-V 27.8).

Critical strengths

First, once skill revision is included, the full system is above direct captioning, sequential readout, generic reinspection, the attribute checklist, and free anticipation on every cell of Table 1, including a mixture-of-experts model and a second family (Ministral-3-3B, where full LASER does win ROUGE-L, 27.0 vs GEPA 26.4). That ranking is numerically consistent even though the scientific confound remains. Second, the paper's own controls already point at visual signs rather than at anticipation in the abstract's sense. Free anticipation does not help. Removing discriminating signs costs 1.5 ROUGE-L on the 9B model, the largest ablation drop on the primary metric, and every Table 3 ablation stays above direct captioning (ROUGE-L 28.1 to 29.0 versus 26.9). Weights stay frozen, and revision videos are disjoint from selection videos.

Critical weaknesses

First, look-ahead is not isolated as the cause of the gain. The matched control without a next-step hypothesis is the attribute checklist, and LASER without skill revision often loses to it. The missing row is the checklist, or direct captioning, under the same revision budget. As written, the gains are consistent with prompt optimization against 500 reference captions. This is the weakness that supports rejection. Second, the revision rule is not shown to beat generic prompt optimization on the metric the authors call primary. GEPA wins ROUGE-L on three of four backbones, including the main 9B result, and Section 4.1 does not discuss the comparison. Evaluation is n-gram overlap and an LM judge, not attribute accuracy. In the case study, a lean that the reference does not state is presented as a success. Under the paper's own judging rule, details absent from the reference are not contradictions, so that extra claim is not penalized.

Questions for authors

Clarification: What is the agreement function q used to accept a skill edit, which model is the contradiction judge, and what are selection-set versus test-set values of that score? An acceptance margin of 0.005 on about 100 selection examples is small enough that the definition matters. Clarification: If the attribute checklist and direct captioning receive the same revision budget and the same GEPA interface, does full LASER still win ROUGE-L on the 9B model? If it does not, I would lower the rating. Clarification: On OSCaR, what is accuracy on the attribute that distinguishes successive states, rather than ROUGE-L? The case-study lean is exactly the kind of extra detail caption overlap does not police. These are clarification requests about the existing experiments. I am not asking for a new benchmark.

Reviewer_NHj3OpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The paper proposes LASER, an anticipation-guided agent for object state readout in videos. It uses possible next-step changes to identify attributes worth inspecting in the current frame, then checks state descriptions and forecasts against subsequent observations. Reusable observation skills are refined by tracing caption discrepancies to specific instructions and selecting revisions on separate videos. Model parameters remain frozen, and the adapted skills are fixed during evaluation. Experiments on OSCaR and PLM RCap across four MLLM backbones show improvements over direct captioning and alternative observation strategies. Ablations examine current-frame reinspection, discriminating visual signs, and observations obtained without exposure to forecasts.

Critical strengths
  1. The connection between possible transitions and present attribute selection is well motivated. Sections 2.2-2.3 explicitly separate hypotheses from initial visual observations and preserve earlier supported states when a forecast is contradicted. This is a useful design for limiting forecast-induced confirmation bias.
  2. The evaluation goes beyond a one-pass baseline: Table 1 includes sequential readout, reinspection, attribute checklists, free anticipation and GEPA across four backbones. For Qwen3.5-9B, full LASER improves OSCaR ROUGE-L from 26.9 to 29.6 and RCap score from 25.6 to 28.1; Table 3 tests relevant internal mechanisms.
Critical weaknesses
  1. The incremental evidence for the specialized skill-revision procedure is inconclusive. In Table 1, GEPA exceeds full LASER on the primary OSCaR metric, ROUGE-L, for three of four backbones (29.0 vs 28.9; 29.9 vs 29.6; 30.7 vs 30.4), and on RCap for two. Section 3.3 specifies LASER's search rounds but not a comparable GEPA search/LLM-call budget; uncertainty and inference costs are not reported. The substantial pipeline therefore has not yet established an advantage over generic optimization at comparable cost.
  2. Caption agreement is an indirect test of the main mechanism. Section 3.3 evaluates lexical overlap and reference-caption similarity, while Table 3 reports the same metrics. There is no aggregate assessment of state/transition correctness or unsupported claims, and the contradiction score used during skill selection is not reported at test time. Figure 2 usefully illustrates two cases, but cannot establish that anticipation improves grounded state accuracy rather than caption matching. These gaps, especially the mixed GEPA comparison, currently outweigh the consistent gains over direct captioning.
Questions for authors
  1. Could the manuscript specify the shared adaptation data, search budget and model-call budget for LASER and GEPA, and explain which claimed advantage remains under that comparison?
  2. Are per-example outputs or repeated runs available to assess uncertainty in the small differences from GEPA and ScaleCap, especially on OSCaR's 500 test clips?
  3. Does the existing evaluation include aggregate state/transition errors or unsupported-claim rates, independent of reference-caption similarity? Such evidence would directly affect the interpretation of Table 3.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.