- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes a visibility-aware approach to surface reconstruction from range scans. Instead of directly fitting an implicit surface to observed point samples, the method formulates reconstruction as robust regression of the first surface intersection along each acquisition ray against the measured depth. The surface is represented by a Lipschitz-constrained neural implicit function, and sphere tracing is used to locate the predicted first intersections. The optimization combines an incidence-weighted depth residual with a Huber loss to improve robustness to measurement noise and outliers.
The authors evaluate the method on synthetic datasets, including SRB and ShapeNet, as well as real-world LiDAR data from ARKitScenes and KITTI. The results demonstrate competitive reconstruction quality on clean data and improved robustness under noisy and outlier-contaminated observations. The paper also investigates the trade-off between reconstruction fidelity and robustness through different positional encoding levels.
Critical strengths
-
Well-motivated formulation that makes effective use of visibility information. A key strength is the formulation of surface reconstruction as first-hit depth regression. By explicitly using acquisition rays, the approach incorporates free-space information that is often discarded by point-based neural implicit reconstruction methods. The resulting objective is conceptually simple and avoids requiring oriented normals, off-surface samples, or additional geometric regularization losses. I find this formulation meaningful, particularly for range scans where sensor positions are available.
-
Convincing robustness results across different corruption settings. The experimental results provide useful evidence of the method's effectiveness under noise and outliers. The comparisons on SRB and ShapeNet cover multiple corruption settings, while the ARKitScenes experiments further demonstrate its potential on real LiDAR measurements. The ablation studies and the analysis of positional encoding levels also help explain the trade-off between reconstruction accuracy and robustness. These results support the practical value of the proposed approach.
Critical weaknesses
-
The theoretical properties of the practical variants could be better clarified. The theoretical motivation for using a 1-Lipschitz network is reasonable, as it supports reliable first-hit computation through sphere tracing. However, as discussed in Section 3.5, the empirical rescaling and positional encoding used in the practical variants no longer provide a formal 1-Lipschitz guarantee. Although the paper acknowledges this limitation and provides empirical evidence, it would be useful to better understand how the relaxation affects the reliability of first-hit tracing in practice. This is particularly relevant because first-hit computation is central to the proposed formulation.
-
Computational cost and the scope of real-world validation remain limitations. The method requires substantially more training time than the compared baselines, as acknowledged in Section 5. While the robustness improvements are encouraging, this overhead may limit its applicability to larger-scale reconstruction tasks. In addition, the quantitative real-world evaluation is mainly conducted on one ARKitScenes scene, while the KITTI evaluation is qualitative. A clearer discussion of the practical trade-off between reconstruction quality, computational cost, and scene complexity would strengthen the experimental evaluation.
Questions for authors
Q1. Since the practical variants are not formally guaranteed to be 1-Lipschitz, could the authors clarify how this affects sphere-tracing reliability? In particular, is there empirical evidence that the first-hit computation remains stable across different positional encoding levels and challenging geometries?
Q2. The paper reports a substantial increase in training time compared with the baselines. Could the authors further clarify the quality-efficiency trade-off, particularly whether the robustness advantages remain significant when comparing methods under similar computational budgets?
1. Since the practical variants are not formally guaranteed to be 1-Lipschitz, could the authors clarify how this affects sphere-tracing reliability? In particular, is there empirical evidence that the first-hit computation remains stable across different positional encoding levels and challenging geometries?
We estimate the Lipschitz constant from sampled gradient norms and rescale the field accordingly, validating the resulting sphere tracing against certified reference intersections (Table 6). Across all tested PE levels (L=0,2,4,6), we observe no overshoots and over 99% first-hit accuracy. These results support reliable tracing on the geometries represented in standard reconstruction benchmarks. Whether this extends to more challenging geometries remains to be systematically evaluated.
2. The paper reports a substantial increase in computation time compared with the baselines. Could the authors further clarify the quality-efficiency trade-off, particularly whether the robustness advantages remain significant when comparing methods under similar computational budgets?
We reduced computation time per shape from approximately 2h45 to 45 minutes on an NVIDIA RTX 6000 (L=0) through CUDA graph replay and kernel fusion, achieving a 3.7× speedup with unchanged reconstruction results. Updated runtime comparisons are provided in Table 15. Furthermore, Table 16 reports reconstruction accuracy at intermediate training budgets on SRB, using the architecture with the lowest final CD1 for each corruption setting. After 15k steps (approximately 27 minutes), our method already achieves the lowest mean CD1 among all compared methods under both scanner noise (λ=1 with L=0) and outlier contamination (α=0.2 with L=2), demonstrating that its robustness advantages persist at reduced computational budgets.
We have also expanded quantitative real-world validation from one to four distinct ARKitScenes acquisitions, reconstructing surfaces from iPad LiDAR measurements and evaluating against held-out FARO reference depths. Our method achieves the lowest depth MAE on all four scenes (Table 4).