- Rating
- 2(+1)
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes the Product Kernel Perspective Space (PKPS), a framework for predicting benchmark scores from sparse and unpaired cached model responses. The work aims to address the dependence of existing benchmark prediction methods on shared queries or aggregate scores. The authors first construct pairwise model affinities by weighting response similarity with query similarity. Then they embed the resulting model distances using multidimensional scaling and perform score prediction with nearest-neighbor regression. They further provide concentration and query-efficiency analyses for PKPS. Experiments on synthetic data, HELM-Lite, and Every Eval Ever demonstrate its effectiveness in query-efficient evaluation and score-matrix completion.
Critical strengths
- Although the core method is relatively simple, the authors provide extensive mathematical proof to establish a theoretical foundation for the paper.
- The motivation of this work is inspiring, as sparse and unpaired evaluation records are common in practical model benchmarking.
Critical weaknesses
- The manuscript structure need improvement. Placing Related Work in Section 1.1 is uncommon, a standalone section would improve the organization. Many key equations in Appendix D are unnumbered, making the proofs difficult to reference.
- The theoretical analysis relies on seven assumptions (Assumptions 1-7) to establish guarantees for an idealized setting. These assumptions are not verified on the real benchmarks, and the guarded selector required by Theorem 2 is not clearly used in the experiments.
- The presentation lacks a clear logical focus. The core method consists of product-kernel similarity, multidimensional scaling, and nearest-neighbor regression, but the extensive mathematical derivations obscure this relatively simple pipeline and make the paper difficult to follow for human.
- The experimental validation is limited to synthetic data and two benchmark suites. More experiments on larger model collections and different embedding models are needed.
- The paper lacks a clear overview diagram of the complete PKPS pipeline.
Questions for authors
See weaknesses, if the authors can adequately address my concerns, I would consider raising my score.
5 comments
Initial response (2/2)
More experiments on larger model collections and different embedding models are needed.
Larger model collections
PKPS needs item-level responses, and most large public leaderboards only release aggregate benchmark scores. Evaluating PKPS also requires the full scores of every target model, so within each repository we use the largest fully evaluated block: 93 models × 18 tasks for HELM and 45 models × 16 tasks for EEE. EEE as a whole covers 165 models and 36 benchmarks, but only 15% of (model, benchmark) pairs have been evaluated, so a larger fully evaluated block is not available.
Several larger collections exist but are not suitable for our setting. Leaderboards such as Artificial Analysis (Artificial Analysis, 2026) report only aggregate scores. Arena-style platforms such as Chatbot Arena (Chiang et al., 2024) collect pairwise human preferences, so there is no per-model ground-truth score on a fixed task to predict.
We found one other “large” public benchmark suite: The Open LLM Leaderboard (v1; Beeching et al., 2023). It is not ideal in that the tasks it contains are either largely multiple choice or true / false. In any case, we considered 367 models from 150 families (a family is the organization of the root base model, with at most 5 fine-tunes per base model and near-duplicate models removed) and 16 tasks, with a pool of 100 queries per task and the full-task score as the target. As with HELM and EEE, we induce sparsity and unpairedness by subsampling each model's queries. Reported results are average MAE over 16 seeds using the “correctness” response kernel (see our response to Reviewer e8LY):
| m=1 | 2 | 8 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample | .387 | .265 | .120 |
| DKPS | .168 | .092 | .045 |
| PKPS | .079 | .061 | .044 |
| IRT (regularized Rasch) | .147 | .134 | .092 |
| IRT + PKPS | .079 | .061 | .043 |
| LRMC + sample | .102 | .085 | .062 |
| LRMC + sample + PKPS | .079 | .061 | .043 |
PKPS is the most accurate method at m = 1 and 2 and matches DKPS at m = 8. PKPS outperforms all other reported baselines. We will add these results to the appendix.
Different embedding models
We repeated the EEE query-efficiency experiment with four additional frontier embedding models, eight smaller open embedding models (8M to 600M parameters), and the "correctness" response kernel that needs no response embedding. For each embedding model, the response PCA dimension and the MDS dimension are selected by the same cross-validation used for the bandwidth (for both PKPS and DKPS). Reported results are average MAE over 16 seeds:
| m=1 | 2 | 8 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sample | .224 | .164 | .081 |
| DKPS (gemini-embedding-001) | .114 | .108 | .068 |
| PKPS: gemini-embedding-001 | .068 | .063 | .060 |
| PKPS: OpenAI text-embedding-3-large | .075 | .065 | .060 |
| PKPS: Gemini-embedding-2 | .074 | .068 | .060 |
| PKPS: Cohere embed-5-pro | .079 | .069 | .064 |
| PKPS: Voyage-4-large | .089 | .074 | .067 |
| PKPS: potion-8M | .077 | .069 | .061 |
| PKPS: all-MiniLM-L6 (23M) | .092 | .075 | .065 |
| PKPS: bge-small (33M) | .084 | .072 | .063 |
| PKPS: nomic-embed-v1.5 (137M) | .087 | .070 | .065 |
| PKPS: jina-v5-nano (212M) | .098 | .075 | .064 |
| PKPS: embeddinggemma-300M (303M) | .101 | .078 | .067 |
| PKPS: Qwen3-Embedding-0.6B (596M) | .085 | .065 | .059 |
| PKPS: jina-v5-small (596M) | .089 | .069 | .060 |
| PKPS: correctness kernel | .071 | .059 | .044 |
PKPS outperforms the sample score and DKPS (using the same embedding model) for every embedding model and budget. Performance varies with the embedding model at the smallest budget (.068 to .101 at m=1) and much less at m=8 (.059 to .067). The correctness kernel, which needs no response embedding, is competitive at m=1 and the most accurate at $ m \ge 2 $. We will add these results to the appendix.
The paper lacks a clear overview diagram of the complete PKPS pipeline.
PKPS is a method to obtain low-dimensional representations of models. We describe the process relative to standard DKPS in Figure 1.
As you point out, given these representations we use a simple regression technique for benchmark prediction. This is described in the first paragraph of Section 3.2: "Inference using the PKPS is a two-step statistical problem: first embed the models, then train a decision function that uses the representations as proxies for the models."
We think that the combination of Figure 1 and the description of the process is sufficient but are happy to include a full diagram of the process if you think it is necessary!
Thank you again for taking the time to review our paper! Please let us know if we were able to address your questions / concerns.
References
Artificial Analysis. “AI Model & API Providers Analysis.” Artificial Analysis, 2026, artificialanalysis.ai. Accessed 11 Nov. 2026.
Beeching, Edward, et al. "Open LLM Leaderboard (2023-2024)." Hugging Face, 2023, huggingface.co/spaces/open-llm-leaderboard-old/open_llm_leaderboard.
Chiang, Wei-Lin, et al. "Chatbot Arena: An Open Platform for Evaluating LLMs by Human Preference." Proceedings of the 41st International Conference on Machine Learning, PMLR, vol. 235, 2024.
summary of initial response
Unfortunately we did not get the chance to engage with you during the reviewer-author discussion period. We briefly summarize our response to each of your points above:
Placing Related Work in Section 1.1 is uncommon. Many key equations in Appendix D are unnumbered.
We will move the related work to its own section and number all referenced equations.
The theoretical analysis relies on seven assumptions.
We explained which assumptions are standard (iid data, an eigengap for MDS, embeddings that capture the score) or hold by construction, and checked others on our data. The population overlap is 0.58 (HELM) and 0.88 (EEE), there is a clear eigengap after the 8th eigenvalue with no negative eigenvalues, and models share only 2.7–11% (HELM) and 1.1–4.4% (EEE) of their queries. Adding the guarded selector to our implementation changes MAE by 0.001 on average (at most 0.004).
The presentation lacks a clear logical focus.
We condensed the narrative (problem, unified framing, theory, experiments) to a few paragraphs and will add a similar summary at the end of the introduction.
More experiments on larger model collections are needed.
We added the Open LLM Leaderboard (367 models from 150 families, 16 tasks) with the correctness response kernel. PKPS is the most accurate method at and (e.g., : 0.079 vs. 0.102 for LRMC + sample) and competitive throughout.
More experiments on different embedding models are needed.
We repeated the EEE experiment with four frontier and eight smaller open embedding models (8M to 600M parameters) and the correctness response kernel, with dimensions selected by cross-validation for each. PKPS outperforms the sample score and DKPS for every embedding model and budget. MAE ranges from 0.068 to 0.101 at and from 0.059 to 0.067 at .
The paper lacks a clear overview diagram of the complete PKPS pipeline.
We pointed to Figure 1 and the first paragraph of Section 3.2, which describe the two-step pipeline, and offered to add a full diagram if needed.
We believe we have adequately addressed your initial weaknesses and questions & we hope these summaries make it easier for you to assess our original response.
Initial response (1/2)
Thank you for taking the time to review our paper. We appreciate you noting that the motivation of our work is inspiring. We attempt to address your noted weaknesses / questions inline below:
We will move the related works to their own section. We will also make sure that all referenced equations are numbered.
Yes. Some of the assumptions are very standard across all analytical settings (e.g., Assumption 1 == the data is iid), for multi-dimensional scaling (e.g., Assumption 4 == eigengap in the dissimilarity matrix), or for proving query efficiency (e.g., Assumption 5 == the embeddings capture the score function well).
Several hold by construction (e.g., Assumption 2 == bounded kernels and embeddings), and we checked others on our data using the $ m −querysamples( m \in {2, 8} $). The cross-model query-kernel mass (Assumption 3) is $ 0.58 > 0 $ on HELM and $ 0.88 > 0 $ on EEE. The 8th eigenvalue of the double-centered distance matrix (spectral identifiability) is 13–26% (HELM) and 3–7% (EEE) of the largest, separated from the 9th, with no negative eigenvalues (Assumption 4). Pairing deficiency approximately holds by construction: models share 2.7–11% (HELM) and 1.1–4.4% (EEE) of their queries (Assumption 7). The rest are standard idealizations in the analysis of nearest-neighbor methods.
Lastly, we introduced the guarded selector as a theoretical device and did not originally include it in the implementation of our method. We have re-run our analysis with the guarded selector with 95% confidence. The average absolute difference in MAE with and without the guarded selector is 0.001 (at most 0.004) across both suites and $ m \in {1, 2, 8, 32} $. We will note this in the main text.
We have distilled the narrative flow to a few paragraphs:
Evaluation is expensive. Benchmark prediction attempts to mitigate this cost. There are two main types of benchmark prediction. We describe both problems as instances of a more general problem.
One new(er) way to tackle benchmark prediction is by using representations of the models and learning a simple regression function on them. Historically, these methods have required paired data to build the representations (DKPS).
We are the first to describe DKPS-like methods as the product of a query kernel and a response kernel. With a strictly positive query kernel, we are able to use this family of representations for benchmark prediction in sparse and unpaired regimes.
Theoretically, we first show that PKPS representations of the models behave well (i.e., concentrate / Theorem 1). We then show that regression using PKPS representations is never worse than using DKPS representations. Finally, we show that there exists a setting where regression using PKPS representations is better than using DKPS representations.
We then investigate if / when PKPS is an empirically competitive option for benchmark prediction. We include the synthetic data to be able to explore the trade-offs in highly controlled settings. We then include results on two of the largest public benchmark repositories with item-level response information before concluding.
We hope that this description / summary clears up any confusion about the logical focus of the paper. If it does, we will plan to add a similar description at the end of the introduction to better prepare readers.