- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The paper proposes CMKL for continual learning on evolving biomedical knowledge graphs. It combines structural, textual, and molecular representations through entity-level MoE routing, together with EWC and a diverse replay buffer. Evaluation uses a PrimeKG-derived benchmark with 129K entities and updates from two database releases. CMKL achieves substantial entity-classification gains over feature-matched baselines, while link-prediction improvements are limited. The paper also reports that the strong text-only link-prediction result comes from transductive node embeddings rather than text semantics.
Critical strengths
- The results seem good compared to the baselines.
- The analysis of the text-only result usefully distinguishes semantic information from node-embedding effects.
Critical weaknesses
-
The main aligned comparisons are Naive Sequential, EWC, and Joint Training. Relevant methods such as IncDE and MRCKG are not evaluated, while LKGE uses a different protocol. Link-prediction gains over Naive/EWC are not statistically significant, and EWC+RotatE performs better. The evidence for an advance over existing continual KG methods is therefore limited.
-
The classification head, node splits, task construction, and graph visibility are underspecified. Fusion alternatives are compared only on link prediction, and forgetting metrics are missing for the feature-matched classification baselines.
Questions for authors
-
Please specify the classification head and loss, node splits, task sequence, and graph used for message passing.
-
Can LKGE be evaluated under the same task protocol, and can IncDE or MRCKG be included? Please also compare K-means replay with random replay and no replay to establish the contribution of the proposed memory selection.