- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
In this paper, the authors proved a universal (strong) consistency theorem for functional regressors in hyperbolic setting. They also provided an estimation on stochastic error bounds and provide the corresponding asymptotic bound. Justifications and implications of the theoretical results are discussed through numerical experiments.
Critical strengths
The theoretical analysis provided in the paper is sound and impactful.
Critical weaknesses
Some of the results and statements are not completely clear. See the Questions.
Questions for authors
- While it is implicated and referred, it would be helpful to have a formal definition of the consistency provided, and the meaning of terms such as universal and strong explained.
- In related work, while works on attention and hyperbolic networks are provided, the consistency theorem, which is a critical topic in statistics and has been extensively studied, has not been adequately discussed. It would be great if the relationship between the consistency theorem presented in this paper and those in the literature can be clarified.
- is the lower bound (2,1,4) on the parameter based on the limit of universal approximation results discussed below equation (8), what do we know about situation when it is violated?
- The discussion below Table 2 on asymptotic behavior enabling an upper bound on the covering number does not provide enough details for the statement to be understood and verified.
- The proof of Lemma 16 is not very clearly written, first of all, there seems to be no Lemma 8 in the paper, then, it is quite difficult to reach equation (36) from the statements provided in the lemma, and the constant is never specified.