- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 1
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 1
- Soundness
- 1
Read review
Paper summary
The authors propose some modification of J-Lens for video models to predict how and where a small write in the residual stream will change the model output.
Critical strengths
None
Critical weaknesses
- This paper is extremely hard to understand. I suspect it’s fully AI generated. If this is not true I urge the authors to make their writing significantly more clear. I’m happy to revisit the paper if they have majorly improved understanding and flow here.
- The abstract is very hard to follow. What is a signed, coordinate-resolved response interface? What is signed about it? What is a frozen-path readout? What are held-out fixed-dictionary interventions?
- The intro, too, is very hard to follow; e.g. “Existing readouts illuminate intermediate content, useful feature directions and attention structure. Editing additionally requires the signed effect of a specified change through the complete remaining network.” what does this mean? It is nowhere introduced what a signed effect means or what a readout means here?
- L. 079: What is RCRE - it’s not introduced (quickly mentioned in the abstract but not to the point where I’d understand what it means). The authors should not link to Tables and Figures in the intro without explaining why they matter for the problem statement. I basically didn’t fully understand the research problem based on abstract and intro.
- I really tried hard to understand the method itself but it suffers from the same problems. I think it’s some modification of the J-Lens. Sentences like “The image-editing comparisons use the four-channel epsilon field; the Wan comparisons use the conditional velocity field.” just confuse a reader. It is not introduced what is meant by “epsilon field”, “Wan comparison” or “conditional velocity field”?
Questions for authors
What is a “signed, coordinate-resolved response”? This keeps coming up but I don’t understand it.