- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
MORTIS combines a 5B diffusion transformer pretrained from scratch with an agentic prompt enhancer for text-rich, layout-controlled image generation. The training recipe includes multi-granularity captions, structured layout annotations, and progressive-resolution training. The prompt enhancer converts short requests into detailed content and layout specifications. The paper also introduces LLTB for bilingual long-text rendering and RLA for human evaluation of complex graphic designs, reporting competitive performance on both.
Critical strengths
-
This paper targets to address a useful problem: generating text and layouts for practical images such as poster and infographic images.
-
Training a capable model from scratch represents substantial engineering effort. The reported long-text rendering and layout-control results are promising.
3.The paper provides considerable detail about the training recipe and evaluates both the generator and the complete system.
Critical weaknesses
-
The distinction from existing work could be clearer. I appreciate the substantial effort involved in building and training this system. However, the paper currently reads more like a technical report, and several design choices have close precedents: Z-Image uses multi-granularity captions and OCR supervision, Qwen-Image adopts progressive training, and Ideogram 4 uses structured JSON conditioning with bounding boxes and LLM-based prompt expansion. These similarities do not diminish the engineering value, but I would appreciate a clearer explanation of the core contribution beyond these existing practices, supported by targeted comparisons or ablations.
-
The release scope of the data-related resources remains unclear. The paper promises to release the model, training recipe, and evaluation framework, but does not specify whether this includes the data-processing pipeline, filtering configurations, generated captions, structured layout annotations, or final training-data manifest. Access to the original public datasets alone would not be sufficient to reconstruct this supervision. Given the importance of data preparation to this work, the authors should clarify which resources will be released and how others can reproduce the key processing steps.
Questions for authors
Could the authors clarify the core research contribution beyond integrating practices already described in reports such as Z-Image, Qwen-Image, and Ideogram 4? In particular, which methodological distinction or generalizable empirical finding is specific to MORTIS, and what evidence supports it?
This is my main concern. I recognize the substantial engineering effort and strong reported results, and a convincing clarification of the contribution beyond the overall system implementation could lead me to raise my score.
3 comments
To Reviewer R2Rb
Dear Reviewer R2Rb,
We hope this message finds you well. As the discussion period draws to a close, we would like to kindly follow up to ensure that we have fully addressed your concerns. If you have any further questions or feedback you would like us to consider, we would be grateful if you could let us know. We particularly appreciate your thoughtful suggestions on clarifying MORTIS’s core contribution beyond existing practices, and sincerely welcome any further guidance on how we could make this distinction clearer.
Thank you very much for the time and effort you have dedicated to reviewing our paper.
Best regards,
The Authors
I recognize the practical contribution of the model and its documented training recipe. However, the core techniques largely follow existing practices, and the experiments do not sufficiently establish a distinct research contribution beyond them. In its current form, I view the work as a useful technical report, but I am not convinced that the research contribution is strong enough to support conference acceptance.
Response to Reviewer R2Rb
Thank you for the careful review and for recognizing the practical relevance of dense-text and layout generation. Your question about the research contribution is helpful: we should make the empirical findings and the design choices they support more explicit.
Weakness 1 & Question 1: The core contribution and its relationship to prior work.
MORTIS demonstrates that a 5B DiT, paired with a strong language encoder and detailed visual supervision, can achieve strong dense-text rendering and layout generation. The central training recipe is minimal filtering + maximal captioning: retain varied visual data and describe it thoroughly, including its text, line structure, layout, and imperfections. We see three main findings from this study.
1. Preserving data diversity matters for text rendering. We retain images with properties such as watermarks, blur, or compression artifacts and describe those properties in the captions. This preserves information-rich examples that additional quality filtering can remove. Appendix B.2 and Table 10 test this choice directly: at 1.6M training steps, adding heuristic filtering reduces the trained model's OneIG text score from 0.5243 to 0.1180. The result supports a concrete data-design choice for dense-text generation: retain the visual content and provide supervision that describes it accurately.
2. Detailed text and layout conditions make a measurable difference. Appendix C describes how we build multi-granularity captions, verbatim text with line breaks, and structured layout annotations. For structured conditions, Appendix C.3 uses multiple schemas, field dropout, element-order randomization, and several coordinate conventions. This provides varied supervision for a single model that accepts both natural language and structured specifications.
Fig. 4(b) compares structured specifications with natural-language descriptions of the same plans and shows the benefit of making the layout explicit. We have also added a fixed-model test of line-break conditioning: retaining line breaks increases average LLTB coverage from 88.3% to 96.3%, with improvements of 11.8 points for long English text and 10.1 points for long Chinese text. Appendix K, Fig. 10 further illustrates layout transfer to an unseen resolution, where center-relative pixel coordinates better preserve the intended spatial scale than normalized coordinates.
3. A compact diffusion backbone can make effective use of this supervision. The 5B DiT is paired with a separately specified 9B text encoder, which supports language understanding and generalization across input formats. In our additional LLTB comparisons, MORTIS reaches a 96.3% six-subset average, compared with 92.93% for Qwen Image 2.1, 95.43% for MiniMax H3 Image (4096), and 93.69% for MiniMax H3 Image (2048). The two comparison models use 8B and 32B text encoders, respectively. MORTIS's results show that strong text rendering can be achieved with a compact DiT through the combination of language understanding and detailed visual supervision; a larger text encoder alone does not determine the outcome.
The evaluation also makes this recipe easier to study. RLA measures complete systems, Fig. 4(a) compares renderers with shared enhanced prompts, and Fig. 4(b) changes the specification format while fixing the renderer. Together, these experiments examine how planning, conditioning, and rendering contribute to the final image.
Multi-granularity captions, OCR supervision, progressive training, and JSON conditions have precedents in the works you mention. Our contribution is the documented training recipe, the resulting 5B rendering model, and the empirical findings above. We will revise the discussion of Z-Image, Qwen-Image, and Ideogram 4 to make these connections and findings easier to identify.
Weakness 2 & Question 2: Release scope and reproduction of data preparation.
Thank you for asking us to make the release scope concrete. We plan to release the model, training recipe, and evaluation framework. Appendices B and C describe the data processing and annotation procedure, and we will provide reference captioning prompts and the annotation models' inference parameters to help others reproduce that procedure.
The annotated training corpus, including the generated captions and structured layout annotations, is outside the planned release. We will state this explicitly in the paper, together with the resources and settings that will be available.
Thank you again for the constructive feedback. It helped us sharpen the presentation of both the contribution and the resources we intend to share.