- Rating
- 3
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
The paper diagnoses a conflict between new-object acquisition and temporal consistency. SlotCommit learns slot activation and begins slot–slot contrastive learning after first activation, allowing new representations to form before enforcing consistency.
Critical strengths
-
Clear problem diagnosis supported by event-centered acquisition and resident-preservation measurements.
-
Strong matched-architecture ablations separate delayed onset, commitment gradients, regularization strength, and idle capacity.
Critical weaknesses
-
Commitment is irreversible within a sequence. The mechanism does not explicitly renew acquisition freedom when a previously committed slot is reused.
-
Detailed acquisition evidence is concentrated on MOVi-C; equivalent mechanism validation on real videos is missing.
Questions for authors
-
How does the method handle slot reuse after object departure, prolonged occlusion, or capacity exhaustion?
-
Can acquisition and resident-preservation gains be demonstrated directly on real videos?
-
Do onset-only gains persist on matched architectures across MOVi-E and YouTube-VIS?
Response to Reviewer 8rfT
We thank the reviewer for the careful assessment and for highlighting the problem diagnosis and the matched-architecture ablations. We address each point below.
W1 & Q1: Irreversible commitment, and slot reuse after departure, prolonged occlusion, or capacity exhaustion.
Irreversibility is a deliberate design choice, not an omission. A committed slot keeps its SSC term so that it remains bound to a single object identity. This is the standard notion of temporal consistency in video object-centric learning, where a slot serves as “a stable object-specific identifier over time” (Manasyan et al., 2025). It is also assumed by the standard video-level FG-ARI and mBO, which penalize a slot that represents different objects at different times. “Renewing acquisition freedom” for a committed slot would mean letting one slot carry two identities within the same video, which these metrics, and any downstream use of slot trajectories, treat as an error.
Departure and prolonged occlusion. In both cases the slot stays committed and keeps its SSC term, exactly as under standard SSC, so it remains tied to its object instead of being released to a different one. Identity-sensitive tracking metrics on full MOVi-C videos, which penalize slot switches and reuse, show better identity consistency than prior SSC-based methods:
Reuse for new objects. Under persistent commitment, new objects are meant to be acquired by idle, uncommitted slots rather than by reusing a committed one. On MOVi-C, at least one idle slot is available at t_e−1 in 100% of entry events (5.69 on average).
Capacity exhaustion. When all slots are already committed, a new object must share or reuse a slot. This limitation is inherent to any model with a fixed number of slots (e.g., VideoSAUR, SlotContrast) and is not introduced by learned onset. In this case, the recruited slot incurs exactly the standard SSC term, so SlotCommit reduces to the SSC baseline and is never more restrictive. Addressing exhaustion requires varying the number of slots, which is orthogonal to learning when consistency begins.
W2 & Q2–3: Validation on real videos, and onset-only gains on matched architectures across datasets.
Why the detailed analysis focuses on MOVi-C. The paper establishes the mechanism through controlled experiments on MOVi-C (Tables 1–3, 8; Appendices B–D), and this choice is deliberate. Entering objects make up 20.7% of annotated objects on MOVi-C, compared with 8.5% on MOVi-E. MOVi-C’s exhaustive instance annotations also allow acquisition, pre-entry slot utilization, and resident preservation to be measured jointly. YouTube-VIS annotates only a subset of salient objects, so an apparently unused slot may represent unannotated content, and an object’s first annotated appearance need not correspond to its physical entry. We therefore use MOVi-C for the fine-grained analysis.
Onset-only gains on matched architectures (Q3) and on real videos (Q2). To test whether the gains hold beyond MOVi-C, we ran the matched comparison on MOVi-E and YouTube-VIS: same architecture, gate, and evidence aggregation, with only the SSC onset rule differing.
The onset-only gains persist across datasets. On MOVi-E, learned onset improves entrant IoU from 16.4 to 20.5 and idle-slot acquisition from 25.9 to 27.5, without reducing resident IoU (36.8 → 37.4), the same pattern as on MOVi-C. On real videos (YouTube-VIS), learned onset improves idle-slot acquisition from 5.2 to 17.4 and entrant IoU from 27.1 to 29.7, while resident IoU also improves (37.9 → 39.9). Qualitative real-video examples in Fig. 6 show the same behavior: an idle slot is recruited for the entering object instead of reusing a slot already assigned to another object.
Reference
Manasyan, A., Seitzer, M., Radovic, F., Martius, G., and Zadaianchuk, A. Temporally Consistent Object-Centric Learning by Contrasting Slots. In CVPR, pp. 5401–5411, 2025.