acceptodds
Under review as a conference paper at ICLR 2027

Learning Deep Choice Hierarchies from Four Exact Probability Responses

Abstract

Can four probability responses reveal an unknown deep choice hierarchy, and can an inexact reconstruction be certified? We study reduced nested-logit trees of arbitrary finite arity with unknown parameters and affine item-input scales, under independently adjustable continuous inputs and full positive probability-vector access. A scale-free finite-coupling identity reuses the same responses across all levels. A baseline and three random perturbations identify the entire model almost surely; for three or more alternatives, four are optimal even with adaptive queries. For inexact observations, a candidate-only shared-response certificate uses the proposed tree's clades to exclude every competing compatible topology, with cubic arithmetic work after a strict binary proposal is supplied. When unique structure cannot be certified, a separate packed outer cover can instead certify one common predictor across structures and all available-item sets on a declared domain. These guarantees require family membership, valid observation intervals, and successful verified computation; refusal is permitted. Across 12 fresh synthetic models and 72 correlated design/precision conditions, shared-response certification provides 66 total-variation bounds at most 0.01, versus 36 for packed certification. A matched enclosure ablation supports the mechanism. Public-component polytomies require the complementary packed route. Float32 certification remains weak, a dense classical control is faster locally, and frequency-based structure recovery fails the prespecified criterion under the tested sampling conditions. This is a probability-query boundary with conditional certification, not recovery from four choices or a general noisy-sample guarantee.

Primary area:
learning theory
Keywords:
query learning, identifiability, nested logit, hierarchical models, verified prediction

Reviews

Among:
Shape:
1234this paper, Bottom 10%
Figure 1. Mean review rating of the reviewed papers at ICLR 2027. This paper averages 1.67 over 3 reviews, above 10% of the others.
Reviewer_eU6hOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
2
Informativeness
2
Presentation
2
Soundness
3
Read review
Paper summary

This paper studies identification of reduced nested-logit hierarchies under a probability-query oracle with independently adjustable continuous item inputs, unknown affine input scales, and access to the full probability vector. The main theoretical result shows that one baseline plus three generic perturbations recover the full canonical model almost surely, and that four responses are necessary for probability-one full-model recovery for n >= 3, even with adaptive queries. For inexact probability intervals, the paper further develops a candidate-only certificate for strict binary structures and a packed outer-cover method for prediction under structural ambiguity. The experiments mainly audit numerical behavior on synthetic models and public fitted components.

Critical strengths
  1. Sharp and nontrivial exact-query characterization. The scale-free contraction is elegant: the same three perturbations can be reused recursively despite unknown input scales and hierarchy depth. The matching lower bound against adaptive queries makes the four-response result substantially stronger than a sufficient-recovery construction alone.

  2. Careful treatment of finite precision. Rather than implicitly extending the exact theorem to noisy observations, the paper develops explicit certificates with refusal and reports adverse numerical results. This separation between exact identifiability, conditional certification, and statistical learning is scientifically valuable.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The main result relies on a rather strong and specialized information model. Each query exposes a complete probability vector and permits independent continuous perturbations of every item, while model-family membership is assumed. I am therefore uncertain that the sharp four-query boundary has sufficient relevance beyond this oracle-identification setting. This is my main reason for leaning toward rejection.

  2. The bridge to realistic finite-information settings remains limited. The certificates assume valid probability enclosures and family membership, the strict-tree certificate can refuse and the packed alternative is worst-case exponential. Moreover, the paper reports weak float32 certification and unsuccessful frequency-based structure recovery even at very large simulated sample sizes. Thus the empirical evidence currently supports the mathematical scope of the method more strongly than practical statistical usefulness.

Questions for authors
  1. What concrete application or API setting motivates the assumed oracle—i.e., independently adjustable per-item continuous inputs and reliable full probability vectors, while the underlying hierarchy and parameters remain inaccessible? In such a setting, why is the number of probability queries the relevant bottleneck rather than total computation or probability-estimation cost?

  2. Is there a useful separation/conditioning assumption under which the exact four-response result can be converted into a finite-sample recovery or certification guarantee? In particular, should the poor frequency-based results be viewed mainly as a limitation of the current numerical estimator, or as evidence that sample complexity can become arbitrarily poor without additional margin assumptions?

Reviewer_XfzQOpenReview ↗
Rating
2
Confidence
1
Informativeness
2
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

This paper addresses the task of identifying which alternatives belong to the same groups in a nested logit model and how these groups are structured hierarchically.

The authors show that the proposed method can identify the hierarchical structure and model parameters almost surely using four query response pairs, assuming independently controllable continuous inputs and access to exact choice probabilities for all alternatives.

The paper also proposes methods for conditionally certifying the uniqueness of a candidate structure or upper bound on prediction error when probability observations are imprecise, and evaluates their performance and limitations through synthetic experiments.

Critical strengths

This paper proposes a framework for recovering the hierarchical structure using only four query-response pairs under a restricted observation model. A strength is that the proposed algorithm is logically structured and clearly described, making its steps easy to understand and follow.

Critical weaknesses
  1. The clarity and readability of Sections 1 and 2 could be improved (very bad readability).

Despite the disclosure in the AI Use Statement, the overall readability of the manuscript, including the introduction, is very poor, and citations to prior work are not provided at appropriate points, making it difficult for readers unfamiliar with the field to follow the paper’s claims.

More concretely, The connections between the key definitions and assumptions and the prior literature are not sufficiently explicit, especially in Sections 1 and 2. When introducing the recursive formulation in Eq. (1) and the assumptions of the information model, the authors should explain more explicitly how these elements relate to prior work and to the contributions of this paper.

Questions for authors
  1. Could the authors clarify which components of the information model defined in Section 2 are drawn from the existing literature on nested logit models and model extraction via probability queries, and which are assumptions specific to this work?

  2. Could the authors clarify the significance of papers contributions? In particular, it would be helpful to explain which limitations of prior work each contribution addresses and what theoretical or practical advantages it provides.

  3. Is it possible to make the search over candidate pairs more efficient, reducing the actual number of tests or computation time while preserving the exact identification guarantee? For example, could unnecessary tests of candidate pairs be avoided, or could valid pairs for merging be identified more quickly?

Reviewer_JJwMOpenReview ↗
Rating
1
Confidence
1
Informativeness
1
Presentation
1
Soundness
2
Read review
Paper summary

The authors proposed an approach to reveal deep choice hierarchy through four probability responses. The authors mention unknown-scale contraction and two complementary conditional certificate as their contributions.

Critical strengths

The authors addressed an important problem. I appreciate their attempt to approach the problem from both theoretical and empirical perspective.

Critical weaknesses

Below I share my concerns.

  1. Many part of the paper including the abstract and introduction is really hard to understand as described in a convoluted way. The authors should consider writing it in a simple manner with proper examples. The authors showed comparison with [1]. To improve presentation, they can have a look at that paper as motivation. For example, in the abstract the authors provided "We study reduced nested-logit trees of arbitrary finite arity with unknown parameters and affine item-input scales, under independently adjustable continuous inputs and full positive probability-vector access.". This does not make enough sense if someone is not very familiar with the target domain. The author should increase readability of the paper.
  2. The authors used few terms without proper definitions: recursive deep-tree (line 94), Intervention (97), continuous-input coordinates (101) etc.
  3. h, pi , k_A, f_A are undefined.
  4. The proof for Theorem 1 was not found in the paper. Its not clear if its in some other form.
  5. Experiment section is quite convoluted and is not interpretable.
  6. The authors mentioned that “AI systems were used substantially for literature search, research planning, formulation and check- ing of propositions and proofs, experimental design, synthetic-model code, implementation, data processing, analysis, translation, and drafting”. To my opinion, that is extensive use of AI which degraded the paper quality. I would request the authors to correct me if I am wrong.

[1] Xintong Yu, Will Ma, and Michael Zhao. Experimental assortments for choice estimation and nest identification, 2026. URL https://arxiv.org/abs/2602.16137. arXiv:2602.16137, version 2

Questions for authors

Below I share my questions:

  1. What did the author implied with their statement: “low-precision certificates can be useless, and the tested frequency-learning extension fails”.
  2. Why is the proof for Theorem 1 is not in the paper? I would request the authors to clarify if I misunderstood something.

From OpenReview, CC BY 4.0. Authors as signed there; shown unedited.

Related papers

Loading the map…

Discussion (0)

Sign in to comment.