- Rating
- 1
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 1
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
The paper focuses on an integration of AI and fusion plasma diagnostics and adopts a self-supervised MAE framework to accomplish diagnostics.
Critical strengths
Overall, the paper is a good shape.
Critical weaknesses
- From the perspective of AI domain, the novelty of the paper is limited, by simply combining several existing ingredients in the literature. The paper fails to show the uniqueness of the fusion plasma diagnostics, and its added requirements on the model training. Correspondingly, the paper is difficult to follow for the readers in AI domain.
- The final result of the paper is also difficult to understand. The compared baselines are the direct application of pretrained checkpoint, and are inconsistent with the SpectralTF-MAE, which is pretrained on the investigated EAST dataset. Simlar spectral-specific pretrained models, such as SpectralGPT,HyperSIGMA,spatial-spectral MAE, are missing to be compared. So, it is hard to evaluate the performance superiority of the proposed algorithm. On the other hand, one of the claimed contribution is its performance on downstream tasks. But Table 2 and Fig. 1 shows inconsistent results on performance improvement.
- The method for partitioning data into training, validation, and test sets shall be clearly specified. The paper states that CXRS and XCS data are paired based on discharge and acquisition time; however, it does not explicitly clarify whether the training, validation, and test sets are strictly partitioned according to shot ID. In the context of tokamak data, spectra from consecutive time points within the same discharge—as well as those from successive discharges sharing similar experimental configurations—are often highly correlated. The authors should provide a clear description of their data partitioning strategy to enhance the credibility of the experimental results.
- The paper shall be further polished to meet the high standards of ICLR. There still exists several formatting issues in the manuscript.
Questions for authors
- Clarify the uniqueness and novelty of the paper.
- Explain the superiority and consistency of the proposed method.