- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 3
- Presentation
- 3
- Soundness
- 3
Read review
Paper summary
This paper proposes Latent Harness, a parameter-efficient approach to internalizing behaviors induced by explicit instructions or agent harnesses. The method freezes the backbone and trains rank-8 adapters at the output of each decoder block, using instruction-conditioned teacher outputs or decision pairs extracted from successful agent trajectories. The learned modules support runtime adjustment of intervention strength, injection phase, and behavior composition; instruction compilation additionally removes the need to repeat the source instruction at inference. Experiments across reasoning, code generation, and tool-use benchmarks examine behavioral fidelity, cross-task transfer, composition, and policy alignment. The authors report recovering at least half of the explicit instruction gains in eight of ten preselected settings and outperforming capacity-matched LoRA in selected agent evaluations. Additional analyses investigate behavioral markers and failure modes, showing that effectiveness depends on the model, task, and intervention configuration.
Critical strengths
- The paper addresses a clear and practical problem: internalizing instruction- and harness-induced behaviors through lightweight adaptation.
- The method is parameter-efficient and supports flexible control of intervention strength, injection phase, and module composition.
- Behavioral markers and carefully designed controls provide evidence of behavioral transfer beyond accuracy improvements.
- Experiments cover diverse tasks and models, with gains over capacity-matched LoRA in selected settings.
Critical weaknesses
-
Limited evaluation scope. The experiments only consider models with up to 8B parameters, leaving effectiveness on larger, more capable models unclear. The selected benchmarks also provide limited evidence of applicability to more complex, long-horizon agent tasks.
-
Small evaluation sets for agent tasks. ToolHop, SearchQA, and API-Bank are evaluated on only 95, 50, and 34 samples, respectively. Several reported improvements therefore correspond to only a few additional solved tasks. Although repeated evaluations help assess variability, the small task pools limit confidence in the robustness and generalizability of these gains.
-
Limited methodological novelty. The proposed adapter closely resembles existing bottleneck adapters and representation-finetuning methods such as LoReFT and DiReFT. In particular, its linear variant closely matches a bias-free DiReFT intervention. Without direct comparisons under matched training data and parameter budgets, the benefits of the proposed adaptation design over these existing methods remain unclear.
Questions for authors
-
Could you evaluate the method on larger LLMs and more challenging agent benchmarks, such as SWE-bench Verified or Terminal-Bench, to assess its applicability beyond the current settings?
-
Could you directly compare the method against LoReFT and DiReFT using the same backbone and training data, with matched parameter and hyperparameter-tuning budgets, to clarify the contribution of the proposed adaptation design?