- Rating
- 2
- Confidence
- 3
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
FETK collects evolutionary algorithm design experience, distills it into natural-language knowledge through validation-gated updates, and generates architectures for new problems using one LLM call. Continuous parameters are subsequently tuned on each target problem. Experiments cover BBOB and MA-BBOB.
Critical strengths
- Reusing design experience across problems addresses a relevant limitation of iterative LLM-based algorithm design.
- The evaluation includes component ablations, dimensional transfer, an additional data split, and repeated architecture generation and knowledge learning.
Critical weaknesses
- End-to-end resource comparability remains unresolved. Appendix D allows 5,000 parameter configurations per test problem, each requiring objective evaluations. At , this permits evaluations before the reported -evaluation final run. Baseline-specific design and tuning costs are not fully compared. Reduced deployment-time LLM usage therefore does not establish overall optimization efficiency.
- The contribution of distilled knowledge is not fully isolated. AO-1 supplies example architectures, but does not test directly selecting a cached training architecture using landscape features and applying identical parameter tuning.
- Some landscape interpretations lack validation. Ordering samples by nearest-neighbor distance does not ensure spatial adjacency for the reported “autocorrelation”; the additive quadratic coefficient ratio likewise does not generally characterize the full objective’s conditioning.
Questions for authors
- How do the conclusions change under matched total objective-evaluation budgets, including target-specific tuning?
- Can landscape-based selection from cached architectures match FETK under identical tuning, and does knowledge validation itself include parameter tuning?