- Rating
- 3(+1)
- Confidence
- 2
- Informativeness
- 2
- Presentation
- 2
- Soundness
- 2
Read review
Paper summary
This paper addresses the issue that existing unsupervised time-series domain adaptation methods overlook intermediate-resolution temporal structures. Based on the Stationary Wavelet Transform, it reveals differences across resolutions in transferability, discriminability, and category-level decision-making capability, and proposes PRISM, a time-series domain adaptation framework. PRISM progressively integrates multi-resolution features and decision information through cross-resolution knowledge transfer and committee-based consensus training, thereby improving cross-domain consistency and generalization. Experiments on six datasets demonstrate that the proposed method outperforms existing approaches.
Critical strengths
- This paper introduces a stationary wavelet transform to construct an intermediate-resolution hierarchy. Three types of experiments systematically validate two key insights: the trade-off between resolution, transferability, and discriminability, and the class-specific decision advantages of different resolutions. These findings provide clear empirical justification for the proposed method.
- Two dedicated mechanisms are designed to address these insights. Cross-Resolution Knowledge Transfer (CRT) employs asymmetric KL divergence to transfer discriminative information from fine to coarse resolutions in the source domain and regularize transferability from coarse to fine resolutions in the target domain, aligning with the characteristics of the multi-resolution hierarchy. Committee-based Consensus Training (CCT) uses the original resolution as the anchor and the remaining resolutions as an auxiliary committee, incorporating confidence masks to filter noisy predictions.
Critical weaknesses
-
CRT and CCT are arranged in a sequential architecture and share multi-resolution representations and classifier outputs, but lack explicitly designed interaction interfaces, feedback pathways, or joint loss terms. Although the combined use of the two modules achieves better performance than either module alone, the source of their synergistic gains has not been disentangled. Therefore, it remains unclear whether the improvement stems from positive interactions between the two mechanisms or merely from the additive gains contributed by each module independently.
-
The Stationary Wavelet Transform, knowledge distillation, committee learning, and adversarial domain adaptation are all well-established techniques. However, the paper does not clearly articulate whether its core contribution lies in proposing a novel domain adaptation principle or paradigm, or merely in engineering a combination of existing techniques for multi-resolution time-series data.
Questions for authors
- The two key multi-resolution properties identified in the paper—the trade-off between transferability and discriminability, and the class-specific decision advantages of different resolutions—are validated only within the DANN framework and on activity recognition datasets. Have the authors investigated whether these patterns also hold under other domain adaptation paradigms, across different task types, and with alternative multiscale decomposition methods? If not, is there any theoretical or empirical evidence supporting the generalizability of these findings to a broader range of time-series domain adaptation scenarios?
4 comments
Looking Forward to Your Feedback Before the Discussion Ends
Dear Reviewer dP9e,
Thank you again for your insightful and valuable comments!
We would like to kindly follow up on our previous rebuttal, in which we conducted additional experiments to explicitly demonstrate the positive interactions between CRT and CCT (W1), further clarified the core contributions and novelty of our work (W2), and provided additional empirical evidence supporting the generalizability and broader applicability of the two key multi-resolution properties identified in our paper (Q1).
As one week has passed since we submitted our rebuttal and fewer than 48 hours remain in the author-reviewer discussion period, we would greatly appreciate it if you could share your thoughts on our responses. We would be happy to provide any further clarification if some concerns remain.
Thank you again for your time, consideration, and constructive feedback. We look forward to hearing from you.
Best Regards,
All Authors
I appreciate the authors’ response. I have no further questions and have raised my score.
Official Comment by Authors
Dear Reviewer dP9e,
We would like to express our sincere gratitude for your careful consideration of our rebuttal and your positive assessment of our responses. We are particularly grateful that our clarifications have addressed your concerns and that you have decided to raise your rating. Your thoughtful feedback, time, and effort throughout the review process are deeply appreciated and have been invaluable in helping us improve our work.
Thank you again for your thoughtful consideration and support!
Best Regards,
All Authors
Looking forward to your feedback
Dear Reviewer dP9e,
Thank you very much for your insightful and valuable comments!
In our previous response, we have addressed your queries by conducting additional experiments to explicitly demonstrate the positive interactions between CRT and CCT (W1), further clarifying the core contributions and novelty of our work (W2), and providing additional empirical evidence supporting the generalizability and broader applicability of the two key multi-resolution properties identified in our paper (Q1).
We would be happy to provide further responses. We look forward to your feedback.
Thanks for your comments again!
Best Regards,
All Authors